Despite recent snow and freezing rain, anglers have begun augering their way across Western Pennsylvania, with first ice yielding trophy-size catches.

At Lake Arthur this past week, Butler area anglers iced big northern pike, including Joe Gowan's 13-pound, 6-ounce, 38 incher and several 5-plus pound bass, such as Mike Iarrapino's 6-pound, 15-ounce largemouth.

At the Shenango Reservoir, Bull Dawson of Hermitage caught a 16 & 1/2-inch crappie and many more up to 14 inches.

Though it is the clear, black early season ice that anglers covet, a colder than normal forecast could spell months of hard water action. AccuWeather senior meteorologist Dave Mohler says temperatures will average two or three degrees below the usual high of 35 and the low of 19. He also predicts 20 percent more snow than usual, which could make ice angling tricky by masking soft spots around fallen timber and other structure, and by insulating ice and slowing its formation.

Advertise with us

As a rule, four inches is considered the minimum thickness for venturing onto ice, according to the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission.

Good early reports and a frigid forecast are welcome news to hard water die-hards such as Carol Stolz of Bradford, who iced the state record 35-pound, 48 1/2-inch northern pike, and Mike Kuna of McCandless, a competitive ice angler specializing in crappie. He and fishing partner Bob Griffith of Vandergrift are competing in the Ice Team North American Ice Fishing Championship on Lake Mary in Alexandria, Minn., this weekend. The pair is also scheduled to give a seminar Jan. 8 at the new Sportsman's Warehouse off Mt. Nebo Road on tips for fishing local lakes, such as Arthur, Yellow Creek, Glade Run, Wilhelm and North Park, and the Shenango Reservoir.

"We look for the structure crappie normally relate to," Kuna said, "for places that should hold fish, like drop offs, creek channels and humps. If you see the trunk of a tree off shore, you can follow the line and guesstimate where the structure is, although you don't want to get close to it because it isn't safe."

Early in the season, before vegetation is completely gone, Kuna also targets weedlines since panfish can be found there. Until the dead of winter, when their metabolism is at its slowest, most fish will be actively feeding, which is one reason early-season ice is such a big draw.

If he is sight-fishing for crappie, Kuna uses a 16-inch rod, otherwise he fishes 20- to 24-inch rods with four pound test, and small jigs tipped with maggots or waxworms.

Advertise with us

"I start with a 1/32nd ounce jig and adjust from there," he said. As with any fishing, the key is finding where fish are.

"With crappie and other panfish, if you catch one, you know you're onto a bunch," said Kuna, who marks locations during open water seasons. "A lake map that shows drop offs, channels and structure will save you a lot of time and energy drilling holes."

Once on the ice, he uses a sonar-type fish finder with real-time display that helps pinpoint depths and the presence of fish.

Ice anglers are allowed to fish five devices at a time. Until last year, only two could be jigging rods. Now all five can be either rods or tip-ups. Kuna typically puts out a single tip-up with steel leader in the hope of catching a northern pike.

Where pike are the target, Stolz is the expert. He caught his state record off a steep bank just four feet from shore at the Allegheny Reservoir, fishing a large dead shiner on 60-pound test with Spider wire leader on New Year's Day 2003.

Advertise with us

"You'll only catch pike during the day," he said. "We get our walleyes at night. Walleye are also deeper, usually in 20 to 25 feet."

Stolz targets those on smaller, lighter leader, smaller hooks and emerald shiners. "Walleye are slow biting," he said. "You might get just seven or eight a day. Other days, you'll get 50, depending on barometric pressure. If it's on the rise, fish will bite. If it's on the decline, they won't."

At Kinzua, walleye anglers are likely to get into perch in the same spots, he said, and three-quarter pound perch are not unusual. Stolz also ice fishes on Kyle Lake in DuBois and Glendale Lake in Cambria County, and -- his favorite for perch -- Lake Erie at Dunkirk, N.Y.

Stolz, who has ice-fished most his life, said safety is all-important.

"Never go alone or you won't stand a chance," he said, adding that rope and picks of life are essential. He and his friends start augering close to shore, then move across the lake doing hole-checks as they go. He, too, likes early season ice because it is typically clear enough for anglers to see fish and fish to see their bait.

Advertise with us

"Once snow falls and then melts and refreezes, you're going to get softer ice and that's to be avoided," he said.

Ice anglers also need to prepare for the cold, he said, since conditions can be brutal. "That's the hardest thing about ice-fishing," Stolz said. "Handing the weather."

For more on Kuna's seminar, visit www.sportsmanswarehouse.com/events_pa.htm. For ice-fishing safety tips, visit www.fish.state.pa.us.

Bob Donaldson, Post-Gazette

Anglers worked hard to drill holes through the five inches of ice that covered North Park Lake in March 2003. With recent cold temperatures, many lakes and ponds in Western Pennsylvania have a layer of ice.

Advertise with us

Click photo for larger image.More Coverage:

Fishing Notebook: Youth camp applications being taken

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.