Sometimes, deer hunting defies logic. Like the morning of Dec. 1 when I watched four antlerless deer through the riflescope at 80 yards. They were pawing the thin snow to reach the grass in an isolated pasture. I did not squeeze the trigger and later tried to understand why.

The question seemed keenly appropriate because my dad and myself had just spent a 6-degree dawn on a stand together, trying to coax the sun above the eastern hills while engaged in the supposed purpose of killing a deer. We shivered some, sniffled, I stuck a pair of those adhesive sock warmers inside my boots and we pondered the atmospheric riddle that presents itself when you can see the rising sun with your eye, yet its direct warming rays are still striking far above your head.

Refraction, we concluded, then returned to scanning the woods and listening for footfalls in the frozen crust.

I had walked out to the truck to get the coffee jug when I saw the four deer. Somehow, it did not seem like the right opportunity at the right time. I like to go into the woods and find a deer in its "natural" setting. Besides, the weather predictors were promising fresh and heavy snow for last Saturday, the last day of the season. With one valid deer tag left, it would be enjoyable, even a bit adventuresome, to hunt after the storm. Knowing I would not shoot that day, I returned to the frigid stand and we shared the steaming coffee.

Advertise with us

Clearly, there is something at work in hunting besides the drive to kill.

Part of hunting's pull is to watch people you care about grow competent in the outdoors. On the first Saturday of the season, my father and myself heard a single shot from my 19-year-old son's location. I started up the ridge toward his favorite area to investigate, and encountered a deer lying on the snow in the open woods.

Barely topping the rise just beyond, I could see Aaron methodically making his way along a blood trail toward me. He took a few careful steps, squatted down, scanned the ground before him, then repeated the pattern, ever closer, intent on the trail.

Eventually he saw me there, and walked over. I was sorry to interrupt the process but its happy ending was the salient point. The two of us shared an hour in honest admiration of a wild creature, quiet talk and humble celebration. I know of no experience like it available to a father and son.

Nothing else plumbs the same questions. Nothing else clarifies in the same way the connections among all life. And nothing else conveys the melded emotions of achievement and responsibility, accompanied by a sense that you have approached something profound.

Advertise with us

We tagged the deer, tied on my red drag rope that I have used for unknown numbers of whitetails, and headed down the hill. I had the packs and rifles and Aaron had his deer. It was one of the least labor-intensive drags in our hunting history. The challenge on the steep, snowy slope was to stay ahead of the deer and avoid obstacles. Young and athletic, he was up to it.

At the bottom of the ridge we crossed the creek and dragged the deer uphill into the open where my dad -- Aaron's grandfather -- could see us from his stand. He waved his orange hat, we waved back and Aaron bet me that he would venture down to join us. He did, and we shared a rendezvous something like the one Aaron and I had savored on the hillside an hour earlier.

In a world where it is no longer necessary to endure the cold and wind, and where meat remains relatively cheap at the chain store grocery, deer hunting does defy logic.

But logic alone can have its shortcomings.

It can, followed blindly, lead to a dull and tamed existence.

Advertise with us

It can't offer a cup of coffee like the one you share when the steam feels good on your face.

And only rarely can it lead you to the top of a snowy ridge, where you can look around, think about your loved ones in their chosen spots and know there is nowhere else you would rather be.