A trial date could be set tomorrow in a long-festering feud over fishing access to the Little Juniata, one of central Pennsylvania's most coveted trout streams.
FISHING NOTEBOOK:
Commission hunts for Susquehanna poachers
Lawyers representing all parties in the Commonwealth vs. Don Beaver and the exclusive Spring Ridge Club will appear at a pre-trial conference in Huntingdon County common pleas court. The trial could be scheduled for sometime next spring, according to Kurt Knaus, spokesman for the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, the lead plaintiff in the suit. Other plaintiffs include the Pennsylvania Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, and Allan Bright, a local tackle shop owner who claims Beaver's attempts to keep the public off a 1.3-mile section of the Little Juniata near Spruce Creek have hurt his business. The state is seeking to prevent Beaver and his club from barring angler access to the stream.
Bright, who owns Spruce Creek Outfitters, is seeking monetary damages, although his attorney Stan Stein, of Pittsburgh, said he hasn't yet established the amount.
"We have to get into Don Beaver's financial records to determine how much he gained by advertising the Little J as private water and putting up signs harassing people who fish there," Stein said. "That part of the case has been put on hold until the judge adjudicates the major issue."
That issue is whether the Little Juniata is navigable water, as defined by colonial era law that says any waterway large enough to carry commercial traffic can be used and enjoyed by the public. Though the Little Juniata, which flows into the Juniata River, no longer is used to transport produce or iron ore, the fact that it once was means it still bears that designation, said Stein, who indicated a similar case involving the Lehigh River in eastern Pennsylvania set precedent.
Stein said he expects Beaver to dispute the Little Juniata's navigability by claiming it was used commercially only seasonally and in high water periods. Beaver rents or has purchased property adjacent to the Little Juniata from landowner Connie Espy, who also is a defendant in the lawsuit.
In the past, he has erected cables across the stream near the Espy farm so that Spring Ridge Club members who pay more than $57,000 to join and $4,000 a year can fish the stream exclusively.
While the public is not entitled to access the Little Juniata from the Espy property, the state says anglers have every right to wade to the water in question from public access points elsewhere in the stream. The plaintiffs say that those who have tried have been run off the water or videotaped by Beaver and his associates. While neither Beaver nor his lawyer, Tom Reed of Pittsburgh, would comment, Beaver in the past has alleged that anglers have hurled insults.
The Espy property is just one of many that Beaver leases or has purchased from property owners on blue ribbon streams for Spring Ridge Club members and other paying customers to fish. While it may be the only one large enough for a navigability dispute, it isn't the only one to generate controversy. Beaver has acquired portions of Yellow Creek, a stream where for years a coalition of anglers and conservationists has fought to maintain access.
One of that goup, Len Lichvar, is being stonewalled as a nominee to the fish commission board because of Beaver and other landowners' unhappiness with his activism, according to Randy Buchanan, a founding member of the Yellow Creek Coalition and president of the Mountain Laurel chapter of Trout Unlimited. Buchanan said Beaver has convinced Senate president pro tem Robert Jubelirer, who lives in his district, to keep Lichvar from board consideration, which has resulted in the seat remaining vacant for more than two years.
Shrinking access to fisheries is a statewide problem, with record landowner postings and desperate efforts by the fish commission and conservation groups to stem the tide. As hard as some anglers have battled for public access, groups such as the Pennsylvania Landowners Association -- on whose board Beaver serves -- fight for privatization.
The landowners group has a foothold in Central Pennsylvania and in Erie, where access is so dire that the state created a special Lake Erie stamp to raise money it can use to purchase easements. Stein suggested the commission may eventually have to do something similar in other parts of the state. He said the Little Juniata case will send an important message, since "rumblings" by landowners wanting to privatize are now being heard on other waters, including the Clarion River, which is navigable.
"We have an excellent navigability case," Stein said, "but if we were to lose, it would have serious adverse impact because it would give people even more cause to close their land.
The case against Beaver will be decided not by a jury, but by Huntingdon County common pleas judge Stewart Kurtz.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.