Three months after the CITGO Bassmaster Classic pros set low-weight records on Western Pennsylvania rivers, local anglers have landed two scale-tipping trophy bass.

Ron Cardinale of Turtle Creek pulled a 6-pound, 3-ounce smallmouth bass from the Monongahela River, fishing from shore in about five feet of water near a discharge at the mouth of the Youghiogheny Oct. 27.

A week later, Ken Will of Shaler caught a 6-pound, 22-inch smallmouth just before 10 a.m. on a windy day at Freeport on the Allegheny River. He was fishing a red and silver lead nose vibrating blade bait he purchased from a television infomercial, according to his brother Chuck.

"I was jagging Ken that the only fish caught with those 'Zippi's' was him ... boy, did I ever end up eating my words," Chuck Will said.

Advertise with us

Cardinale's bass came on the first cast of the day. "I didn't even have my second rod baited up when my other rod bent in half," said Cardinale, 32. He was using a wounded shad from the river for bait. It was about 12:30 p.m. "I saw this huge brownish-black tail and thought it was a carp until I gave it a couple of hard pulls and saw what I had. I said, 'This ain't no carp.' I started shakin'. I didn't even have a cooler, so I put it in a plastic bag."

"I'm thinking, 'The Classic guys didn't get nothin' like this, and they fished right where I did.'"

Cardinale said he ran to a bait shop and even a police station in a frantic, but futile, search for a scale, then took the fish home and revived it in his kitchen sink. He wound up at Lee Murray's Lock Three Bait and Tackle in Cheswick, where his photo was taken and the fish was officially weighed and measured. It had a 15 7/8 th inch girth and was 22 inches long. Cardinale said he returned to the river and watched in amazement as the fish swam away.

Bass that size are rare on rivers, especially this year, according to Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson, whose recent surveys on the Ohio and Allegheny rivers -- including Freeport where Will released his behemoth -- showed large numbers of bass, but few to none more than 12 inches.

Lorson blames harsh conditions of the past couple years and below-average year classes from the late 1990s. "We ended up with a situation where mortality was high among big fish," Lorson said. "In 2004, we had high water through most of the year and a low forage supply, which didn't let fish go into last winter in as good a shape, especially fish six to eight years old. Only a small percentage were able to make it." Younger fish toughed it out, although conditions caused them to grow more slowly. He said a fish the size of Cardinale's would be eight to 15 years old.

Advertise with us

Lorson performed nighttime electro-fishing on the Ohio River below the Emsworth and Dashield's dams, and on the Allegheny River at Freeport and at Tarentum, which included Big Bass Program water. Sampling done Sept. 20 at Freeport showed 41 percent fewer 12-inch plus smallmouth were caught per hour than in surveys done there in 1989 and 1993, although total catch rates per hour were up by 42 percent, said Lorson. "There are enough year classes out there of reasonable size that are going to be coming on."

While harsh conditions of previous years can be blamed for the number of sub-legal bass plaguing anglers in recent months, good growing conditions this year have led to an explosion of baitfish on the rivers, and game fish are making up for lost time.

"I was at Montour Run and there were just clouds and clouds of shad in the water," Lorson said. "I aged some bass scales and they're now growing like crazy." This was an excellent year for emerald shiners, too, though shad are the rivers' main forage, he said. Shad have short life spans, which indicates they are this year's fish, he said.

Fall is normally when big fish are caught on the rivers, since most species feed heavily with the approach of cold weather. Bass, which spawn in late spring, tend to go to deeper pools in fall, whereas walleye, a late winter-early spring spawner, begin their upriver migration, Lorson said. But given the number of small fish and the abundance of prey, Lorson said anglers may face more of a challenge.

Prolonged mild temperatures haven't helped, either. "Maybe November will turn out to be a good month," Lorson said, "but I'm a little surprised that the good fishing hasn't really panned out yet." He predicts that, two years from now, the rivers will yield some of their best sizes and catch rates ever. "2007," he ventured, "will be a banner year."

Advertise with us

Ron Cardinale of Turtle Creek holds the 6-pound, 3-ounce smallmouth bass he pulled out of the Monongahela River Oct. 27.

Click photo for larger image.Fishing Notebook:

Four men caught bagging steelhead

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.