Anglers and the rest of the public have until Nov. 18 to weigh in on a plan that could once again put a high-quality Westmoreland County wild trout stream into a tug of war between a mining company and environmentalists.
The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection is taking comment on New Enterprise Stone and Lime Company's proposal to quarry limestone from near the headwaters of Indian Creek before deciding whether to issue a permit, something the company has been seeking for seven years. Specifically at issue is New Enterprise's plan for disposing of sediment-laden storm water and other runoff in the Henderson quarry, which is fewer than 100 yards from the headwaters of the stream, where populations of wild trout have been documented. The lower reaches are stocked.
The Mountain Watershed Association, a group that has spent millions of dollars restoring Indian Creek, has opposed the company's previous water-handling proposals and isn't optimistic about the latest one, according to hydro-geologist David Perry, the watershed association's technical consultant.
"I've been involved in mining studies too long to believe this plan won't, to use a highly technical term, crap up the creek," he said.
At a recent public meeting, New Enterprise presented DEP-ordered hydrological studies showing that a well on the site of the 70-acre quarry could be injected with water at a rate of 70 gallons per minute over 24 hours, releasing water into the aquafer -- the natural underground rock layer that transmits water -- without harming the stream.
Perry said he hasn't completed his review of the data, but has his doubts that settling ponds through which the water would first pass to remove sediment are big enough to handle sequential rain events, and that the well won't fill up with sediment over time, clogging pore spaces and preventing water from being injected into the aquafer.
"If you've ever seen mine water, it looks like mud," he said. He also is concerned with a six-inch crack in the well. "No one knows what a crack will lead to," he said. "If it daylights water into Indian Creek, that could be very bad, especially in summer, when water is warm."
Trout are a cold-water species that can die when water temperature climbs above 75 degrees.
Siltation can be just as deadly, according to Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission biologist Rick Lorson, because it can smother streambeds and reduce the invertebrate population that trout feed on. It can harm spawning habitat by covering the clean gravel that trout need to reproduce.
The Indian Creek watershed includes 21 tributaries and 11 streams totaling 276 miles. The watershed association has focused over the years on coal mine discharge remediation and stream bank restoration, securing millions of dollars in government grants, including some from DEP, to improve water quality.
Because wild trout are in the headwaters, the fish commission has classified the portion of the stream above the confluence with Champion Creek as a high quality cold water fishery, which is a notch below Class A status, said Lorson. The commission performs pre- and in-season trout stockings in the 1.6 mile Delayed Artificial Lures Only section from the T-916 Bridge downstream to the Route 381 Bridge in the town of Jones Mills, which gets average to heavy angling pressure.
Indian Creek is part of the gateway to the Laurel Highlands, adjacent to state forestland. It also is close to the Pennsylvania turnpike's Donegal interchange that carries traffic to Seven Springs and Ohiopyle State Park. That makes salt from winter de-icing of roads and litter from motorists on-going problems.
According to Perry, the last thing Indian Creek needs is a mining operation. "Although I'm paid to review the technical stuff," said Perry, "I'm also a member of the watershed association, and, personally, aesthetically, I think it's a lousy place to locate a mine."
New Enterprise did not return phone calls. But DEP spokesman Kurt Knaus said the technical review will be done within three months and will be followed by a review of the permit application.
"The level of detail from New Enterprise far surpasses what most quarries have submitted on application," he said. "They've done a series of four tests since February 2002. We're going by hydrological studies of injection tests, which is usually the most complete and thorough you can do."
Copies of the New Enterprise plan can be reviewed at DEP's Greensburg district mining office. To make an appointment, call 724-925-5500 or 724-925-5531.
Indian Creek in Westmoreland COunty is a natural trout stream. The Indian Creek watershed totals 278 miles.
Click photo for larger image.Related Story:
Fishing Notebook: Test inconclusive on death of stocked fish in area lakes
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.