HARRISBURG -- Customers pay $575 to hunt the 250 boars fenced in at the Tioga Boar Hunting Preserve, an activity unregulated by the Pennsylvania Game Commission.

That may change after next week, when the state Supreme Court is scheduled to hear oral arguments in a case that pits the commission against an animal rights activist seeking to ban the practice.

Johnna Seeton is appealing a lower-court decision last year that said the Game Commission didn't have to oversee a practice the company's Web site describes as "challenging a big tusker." Seeton calls it an unsportsmanlike canned hunt.

The 1,500-acre preserve outside Tioga, near the New York border, is one of about a half-dozen high-fence preserves in Pennsylvania that sell the right to hunt such animals as boar, elk, ram and buffalo.

Advertise with us

"These hunts are inhumane, because the animal has no way of escaping a fenced area," Ms. Seeton said. "The animal is caught, and it does not appear at all to be a fair chase."

Ms. Seeton, a Humane Society officer whose territory includes five south-central Pennsylvania counties, said she wanted the Game Commission to end boar hunts entirely. At least 12 states prohibit fenced-in hunts of all mammals, and eight others have partial bans, according to the society.

Pete Gee, who has run the Tioga preserve for 40 years, said boars were more like barnyard pigs than bears, deer and other animals the state hunting agency currently regulates.

"If you had a pure Hampshire hybrid hog and you butchered [it], it would be pork chop for pork chop the same meat," he said.

Among Mr. Gee's customers, boars are the most popular quarry he offers, but they also can pursue deer, sheep, goat, turkey, buffalo or elk.

Advertise with us

He disputed the notion that his boar hunts were not a fair fight.

"A boar can run 40 miles an hour," Mr. Gee said. "How far can a man run at 40 miles an hour? They're highly intelligent, and [the boar has] got lots of sport, lots of room to get away."

Commonwealth Court Senior Judge Keith B. Quigley dismissed Ms. Seeton's lawsuit in December after deciding it was reasonable for the commission to decide that boars were not among the "protected mammals" that must be regulated.

Doug Sherman, a senior deputy attorney general who represents the Game Commission in the case, said the agency did not consider the preserve's boars to be wild mammals because they aren't living in a state of nature.

Game Commission spokesman Jerry Feaser said the agency had no interest in regulating boar hunting.

Ms. Seeton's lawyer, Gordon A. Einhorn, said he wanted the Supreme Court to declare boars are protected mammals under state law and send the case back to Commonwealth Court, which he hopes would then order the Game Commission to investigate and take appropriate action.