Bob Sarnese is only half-joking when he talks about getting followed by folks eager to know where he catches big crappie, including the 3-pound, 8-ounce monster he caught in June.

"One guy came up real close to me in 6 feet [of water] and splashed his anchors in," said Sarnese, who this year caught a couple other three-plus pounders, which is almost triple the angler award minimum. "He sat there gawking. He was taking notes."

Because of his taxidermy business, he isn't out as much as he would like in fall, but living in Prospect two minutes from Lake Arthur in Butler County allows him to steal away when he can.

"Crappie are putting the feedbag on now for winter," he said. "When you catch one now you can just imagine how it looked in spring when it was full of eggs. But you can catch big ones any time of year."

Advertise with us

Sarnese hits the shallower spots in spring and fall, early in the morning and at night, although crappie will move deeper when the sun gets higher.

"I fish structure constantly," he said. "Those fish don't seem to leave the brush, especially in fall, because that's where the baitfish will be. There and in the shallows. It's like chasing rabbits from one brush pile to the next."

By fall, too, fish have gotten smarter, he said. "They've seen all the boats and heard all the traffic. They're not stupid. They know what's going on. You've got to sneak up on them. These younger guys'll come blowing by with their radios on. I tell people to keep their talking to a minimum."

Sarnese remembers when Lake Arthur was built around 1970 and has used old PennDOT maps to locate submerged structures. Since then, brush and cribs have been added by park managers and by local anglers.

"Crab apple trees are the best to use," Sarnese said. "They're unforgiving once you get hung up on them, but they don't break, and they have a lot of branches, so one tree makes a big brush pile."

Advertise with us

Areas around where beavers have been working also can be hot spots, he said. "You'll find fish hanging off the beaver huts and downed timber."

Logs, stumps and brush piles are the key to finding crappie. He said the older the brush pile, the bigger the fish.

Sarnese vertical jigs, using four-foot ice fishing rods he has modified for his purpose and seven-foot or longer rods. That way his bait is in different places -- one over the brush pile and one on the edge.

"I fish just over the side of the boat," he said. "I back troll a lot, from one pile to the next, or I'll throw an anchor, and let the wind drift me. I'll use 100 feet of rope."

He fishes six-pound test because of the hybrid stripers and other bass in the lake. "I've caught muskies and every other damn thing jigging for crappie," he said.

Advertise with us

He will stay in one spot, "working it to death," and uses bobbers, not buoys, to mark brush.

"I'll drop over the bottom, wind a couple of turns, and start moving the boat around a little. I'll 'dink, dink, dink' three or four times, leave the rod sit, then 'dink, dink, dink' and leave it sit. On flat days, I'll jiggle more. Most guys are out there pulling it clear out of the water, pumping it to beat the band. Fish have big eyes. Keep it subtle," he said.

"I'll get right into the brush pile, where the big fish are. The closer to the water you get the tip of your rod, the sooner you'll see the strike. Once you set the hook, be ready with the net. Crapppie are called paper mouths for a reason. They'll roll around a little and then 'pink!' the hook'll come out."

The biggest challenge with fishing structure is avoiding snags, although the closer you get to brush the better. Sarnese said, "If you're not getting snagged, you're not fishing."

If he gets snagged in shallow water, he winds down to the snag and pushes the lure off the snag with the rod tip. "That's how I get most of my snags out. Just winding down to them."

Advertise with us

Sarnese fishes basic jigs, usually 1/16 ounce, and a 1-inch curly tail and fathead minnow hooked through the lips. In strong winds, he'll go to a heavier jig. "When you're back trolling, the object is to keep your line as straight as you can," he said. "I've gone up to 1/8 ounce jig, but you'll mostly catch the big stuff on that."

He also does well on tube jigs and curly tails without live bait.

"Most people'll bobber for crappie, but I catch way more fish my way," he said.

As busy as he is in fall, "any time there's a front blowing through, I'm gone," he said. "Cloudy days are good and any change in temperature."

Bob Sarnese of Prospect shows off a 3 1/2 pound crappie he caught at Lake Arthur in Butler County.

Advertise with us

Click photo for larger image.Fishing Notebook:

No camping at Erie sites

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.