Chronic Wasting Disease is now known to exist in wild deer populations to the north and south of Pennsylvania. West Virginia Division of Natural Resources officials confirmed last week that a two-and-a-half year old whitetail buck killed on a highway in Hampshire County tested positive for CWD. Hampshire County is in West Virginia's Ridge and Valley region in the state's eastern panhandle, about 25 miles south of Bedford County in Pennsylvania.
The disease was confirmed last spring in captive and wild deer herds in southcentral New York.
Chronic Wasting Disease is a poorly understood, transmissible neurological disease that can infect all species of deer and elk. It is always fatal and there is no way to test a living animal for CWD. Tests are done by removing the brain stem and examining it for spongey deformation caused by errant proteins that veterinarians call "prions."
Chronic Wasting Disease was first recognized in 1967 at a deer research facility in Colorado. It then sprang up in captive elk and wild mule deer, in several western states in the mid-1990s. Since then confirmed cases have been found progressively farther east, in Wisconsin, Illinois, New York and West Virginia.
The West Virginia discovery rekindles concerns that the disease may soon be found in Pennsylvania.
"We are very near to finalizing the update of our CWD response plan," said Bob Boyd, assistant director of the Pennsylvania Game Commission's Bureau of Wildlife Management. "And we should know a lot more about the disease near our borders after this coming hunting season. New York and certainly West Virginia really haven't had the opportunity to map out the extent of the disease yet. The hunting season will allow them to get some good information from hunters -- where the hotspots are. New York will have mandatory check stations in the disease containment area. All hunters will be required to report there with deer so they can be tested."
Much of the concern in Pennsylvania centers on captive deer facilities, such as farms where deer are raised for meat or for sale to commercial shooting operations. Various sources put the number of such facilities in Pennsylvania between 800 and 1,100 operations. Formerly, operators of captive deer facilities routinely transported deer to and from other captive herds around the country. After CWD was discovered in Wisconsin in 2002, Pennsylvania prohibited the importation of captive deer from outside the state unless the animal came from a monitored herd certified free of CWD.
Currently, though, there is no mandatory testing program for CWD in captive herds within Pennsylvania. The state Department of Agriculture operates a voluntary monitoring program but only about a quarter of captive operations participate.
On Aug. 22, before the West Virginia CWD case was confirmed, Department of Agriculture Secretary Dennis Wolff indicated that a mandatory program was being developed for Pennsylvania.
"Early detection is certainly the key to successful containment of CWD," Wolff said. "We are currently working with the task force [state and federal agencies, deer farm operators and hunting groups] to develop a mandatory surveillance requirement for Pennsylvania's captive deer herds."
Hoy Murphy, public information officer for the West Virginia Division of Natural Resources in Charleston, said his state had only about a dozen captive deer operations and strictly regulated captive deer transport.
Even if Pennsylvania tightens its regulations on captive herds, the possibility of transmission of CWD among wild deer still remains. Recent research conducted by the Game Commission on dispersal behavior of whitetail bucks found that young male deer in habitat similar to the Hampshire County ridge and valley country travel as much as 19.6 miles from the place of their birth to establish a home range.
Pennsylvania does not test road-killed deer for CWD. "Two different research studies outlined at the recent Chronic Wasting Disease Symposium in Madison, Wis., produced conflicting results about whether checking road-killed deer is an effective way to track the disease," Boyd said.
"We routinely check road kills. We think it provides a broad sample of information across the state," Murphy said.
The Game Commission does random checks of hunter killed deer during the hunting seasons. Last year the Commission tested 3,699 deer for CWD, none of which tested positive. Some statisticians, however, consider the sample size (less than one percent of the total deer kill) to be inadequate to detect the disease in the state.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.