We are accustomed to thinking about nature as generally good-natured, benevolent, a source of respite and inspiration, a stream to fish or a trail to hike. Doubtless, that view is a recent one in the human experience, formed gradually over centuries as people forged the evolving ability to keep nature at arm's length, to experience it on our terms, in increments to our liking and convenience.
If that cozy acquaintance needed centuries to assemble, it took only hours to shake to its roots as Hurricane Katrina shredded the fabric of civilization built across 250 years about the mouth of the Mississippi River. We may at times perceive nature as generous, beautiful, serene or violent, but it is ultimately omnipotent and indifferent.
To write about the pleasant enjoyment of nature -- particularly, that aspect of nature we call the outdoors -- at a time when people at the lower end of our own watershed are suffering at the extremes feels trivial. To flush a toilet or to shower prompts a nagging second thought; to wash a car seems sinful. The last thing they need along the lower Mississippi right now is more water. Hopefully, we are holding as much back as we can in the reservoirs on the Youghiogheny, at Kinzua, Loyalhanna and Tionesta, until the floods recede and more flow can pass benignly to the Gulf of Mexico.
Here in the uplands, there is a temptation to think about the absurdity of a city built below the bed of its river, below the receiving sea itself, and to ponder the futility of trying to confine the continent's Mississippi, which meandered back and forth across its delta for hundreds of thousands of years before the levees. But those are the vain thoughts of the distant unaffected, best banished until another later day when they might prove in some way useful. Now is the time to send whatever we can--money, medicine, trained personnel who know how to make a difference, thoughts, prayers, whatever might help.
Our own region, as far as we know, is not naturally subject to misery on such a scale. We live in a moderate place, sheltered by weathered hills well settled on their bedrock roots. Storms from any direction must spend themselves to get here. The seasons turn predictably, before the heat or the cold become entrenched. One way to understand what it means to live in this, our, place might be to consider that we accept the annual and dependable inconvenience of an inland upland winter -- ice, snow, chill -- in exchange for geographic insulation from infrequent but inevitable large scale destruction. Of course, that bargain is an empty one for those who live close by our rivers. It was only one year ago that a storm called Ivan swelled streams here until they swallowed neighborhoods.
But with all due empathy to those so afflicted, it was still different here. Help was nearer at hand, the isolation was not so utter, the options not so few nor so fierce.
Western Pennsylvania's only event of comparable despair happened at Johnstown in 1889. Two thousand people were killed there by a temporarily impounded part of the Conemaugh River, unleashed all at once but constrained in a gorge with nowhere to go but some lower point, with a city in its implacable path. If we are inclined to question the reasoning in placing a city below a lake, we might be asked how different is it to place a lake above a city.
After Katrina, it feels as though some "tipping point" may have been crossed, reminding our ancestral memory of our ultimate inability to control nature's expressions of power and change. If so, it is a perspective not without its own value, that may be called upon after the crisis is managed, when new decisions are made about how best to live with an hospitable but fluid planet.
Every day the atmosphere simmers, the seas churn, and water cycles -- vapor to rain -- between them. People find a place to their liking and then find themselves sometimes in the way of all that. Each place has its own natural blessings and its own companion risks. We cannot make that different than it is. All we can do is live, be mindful, learn, and try to help one another when the time is at hand.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.