Warner Independent Pictures

"March of the Penguins"

Click photo for larger image.

The documentary "March of the Penguins" is doing what few movies of its kind have done. It's making money. It's also terrific family entertainment.

Advertise with us

"Penguins" has struck a chord with the movie-going public. Two weeks ago, USA Today reported that its $16.3 million take had vaulted it into third place among the highest-grossing documentaries. If you're looking for a G-rated film for children, this is it.

With a running time of one hour and 20 minutes, "Penguins" chronicles a year in the lives of a colony of emperor penguins. French director Luc Jacquet describes the film as a, "... very straightforward story of survival ... I attempted to take the viewer along like a father or mother takes his child on a journey with a bedtime story."

Filmed in Antarctica, the crew endured unimaginable conditions for more than a year. Temperatures approached minus-100 degrees and winds blew up to 100 mph. But this incredible story of survival focuses on the penguins.

They've thrived under these conditions for millennia. And that is the appeal of the film. I defy anyone to watch this movie and not marvel at these incredible birds. That the adult penguins are incredible photogenic and the young indescribably cute simply adds to its charm.

"Penguins" gets two big thumbs up. But I do have some reservations. Scenes of predation of young penguins, though not prolonged or particularly gruesome, left my nephew's young daughter teary-eyed. Young children can be sensitive to scenes of predation. For most though, "Penguins" is a gentle introduction to the reality of predator-prey relations. And it would have been instructive if the narrator had identified the large predatory bird that swooped in on the chicks. It was a Southern Giant Petrel, and it's diet includes fish, squid and small penguins.

Advertise with us

My only criticism of the film was its anthropomorphic tone. Confusion and ignorance result when animals are assigned human attributes. A blurb in the film's press notes reads, "March of the Penguins" tells one of the most beautiful love stories on earth." No it doesn't. Those words are intended to appeal to the vast majority of the public who have no biological training.

A more honest yet equally effective and compelling promo might have read, "Penguins" tells one of the planet's most compelling, haunting and beautiful tales of survival, perseverance and renewal."

Woopecker challenge

In May, I wrote of the rediscovery of the ivory-billed Woodpecker by a team of ornithologists organized by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology. I called it "the biggest conservation story of my lifetime." Over the course of a year, a handful of expert birders saw an individual ivory-bill several times in the swamps of Arkansas's Cache River National Refuge.

Last month, news broke that three biologists -- Jerry Jackson of Florida Gulf Coast University, Richard Prum of Yale and Mark Robbins of the University of Kansas -- were planning to publish a challenge to the conclusion that ivory-bills still exist. They claimed the observational and video evidence was inconclusive. Basically, they were challenging the expertise of the Cornell team.

Advertise with us

I was skeptical of the trio's criticism because they had no new evidence of their own. In fact, according to a source at Cornell, none of the three had participated in the year-long search for the Arkansas ivory-bill. Perhaps being left out fueled their skepticism. Jackson in particular, author of In Search of the Ivory-billed Woodpecker (2004), had missed a chance to write the ultimate final chapter. But a few weeks ago, after hearing audio recordings of the ivory-bill's diagnostic call and distinctive double raps on a tree, Prum and Robbins changed their tune. In comments to the New York Times, both admitted they were convinced the ivory-bill lives. Jackson was out of the country and had not yet heard the tapes.

Science is based on repeatable observations, and challenging conclusions is part of the process. But there should be new information on which to base those challenges.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.