Pittsburgh and its suburbs may be the ideal example of urban deer problems. The hilly, wooded terrain, networked by older neighborhoods and spreading new development offer whitetails plenty of places to hide, and gardens and plantings to munch.
The dense development also provides them refuge from hunters. The herds grow larger, cross highways in heavy traffic and wear out their welcome with homeowners who once were thrilled to see a deer on their lawn.
To formulate a better urban deer program, the Pennsylvania Game Commission is now asking individuals, organizations and municipalities for ideas on managing deer in urban and suburban communities.
"The excessive whitetail populations in some Pennsylvania urban and suburban settings are living proof that you can have too much of a good thing," said Jeannine Tardiff, a Game Commission biologist heading up the project. Tardiff asked that hunters, homeowners, municipal officials and others consider the following points before submitting ideas to the agency.
What are your primary concerns with urban/suburban deer?
What methods would you support to manage urban/suburban deer problems?
What actions do you believe would encourage landowners and community leaders to allow increased hunting access to small woodlots and other areas harboring deer in urban/suburban areas?
What actions are needed to encourage hunters to focus efforts in urban/suburban areas where increased harvest is needed?
Comments can be made by e-mail to urbandeer@pgc.state.pa.us or by mail to: Pennsylvania Game Commission, Attn: Draft Urban Deer Management Strategy, 2001 Elmerton Avenue, Harrisburg, Pa., 17110-9797. Deadline for comments is Sept. 16.
An agency news release said possible management options are not limited to recreational hunting, and encouraged those considering comments to think creatively about the problem. Here are a couple of ideas that might fit that invitation.
Several years ago a Penn State professor, whose name now escapes me, was proposing a tactic to reduce roadkills in urban areas that made a lot of sense. Unfortunately, I have not seen his ideas implemented. His point was that deer were attracted to stabilization plantings on highway cuts and fills.
Too often, he said, fences to exclude deer from the road were placed at the outer edge of the plantings, at the edge of heavier cover. Attracted to the food, deer find a way to get over or under the fence, then wander onto the road. The professor advocated placing fences nearer to the highway and allowing deer access to the vegetation without crossing the fence. In that scenario the fence would still deter deer from crossing the road.
Another idea is to ask developers who build homes in formerly rural areas to share the cost of future deer problems. There are precedents for such an approach. Loggers, natural gas producers and coal operators buy bonds against the damage they may cause to municipal roads. Townships and boroughs can then retain the bond if the user defaults on his pledge to make repairs. Also, developers must construct streets to municipal specifications before the township assumes responsibility for their maintenance. The design and layout of new subdivisions can have a huge impact on their attractiveness to deer and on the accessibility of deer to hunters.
Municipalities could begin to incorporate anticipated deer problems into their design specifications. Or they could require developers of rural land to post a "deer damage bond" with the municipality, to defray future costs it will incur when deer begin to damage residents' property.
An agency spokesman said the goal is to reduce deer numbers to what managers call "cultural carrying capacity." Cultural carrying capacity is not what the habitat can support nutritionally, but what the community can tolerate in terms of damage.
Meanwhile, for those hunters who do have access to hunting property around the city, more than 60,000 antlerless deer licenses remain unsold in Wildlife Management 2B, which includes Allegheny County and bordering portions of Butler, Beaver, Washington and Westmoreland counties. The Game Commission begins accepting applications for unsold licenses by mail tomorrow.
A deer in North Park ignores park goers while feeding on apples that have fallen on the ground. More and more deer are being found in urban areas.
By the numbers
Antlerless deer licenses available in Wildlife Management Units as of Aug. 18.
WMU
Allocation
Distributed
Remaining
Status
1A
40,000
24,888
15,112
Open
1B
27,000
27,000
0
Closed
2A
55,000
20,118
34,882
Open
2B
68,000
5,605
62,395
Open
2C
53,000
37,701
15,299
Open
2D
56,000
41,939
14,061
Open
2E
21,000
18,796
2,204
Open
2F
30,000
30,000
0
Closed
2G
29,000
29,000
0
Closed
3A
27,000
21,763
5,237
Open
3B
41,000
27,226
13,774
Open
3C
32,000
26,327
5,673
Open
3D
38,000
24,190
13,810
Open
4A
35,000
25,333
9,667
Open
4B
35,000
25,577
9,423
Open
4C
39,000
30,272
8,728
Open
4D
40,000
37,488
2,510
Open
4E
38,000
21,034
16,966
Open
5A
28,000
9,808
18,192
Open
5B
56,000
22,416
33,584
Open
5C
71,000
13,932
57,068
Open
5D
20,000
600
19,400
Open
Totals
879,000
521,013
357,987
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.