Douglass Oster, Post-Gazette
Slippery Rock Creek in Butler County has long been a magnet for trout fishermen in Western Pennsylvania.
Click photo for larger image.
Weighing in on proposed trout stream regulations
Outdoors: Commission's proposals well crafted
Fishing Notebook: Four-pack of events scheduled for Saturday
The Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission's top biologist, Rick Hoopes, said he is surprised by angler comments supporting the proposed new one-a-day, 24-inch minimum for Trophy Trout.
"I don't know if it's because people think there are a lot of them," he said, "but anyone who knows the reality knows how rare a 24-inch trout is. It's less than one percent of [the fish] in Pennsylvania streams."
It could be that anglers applaud the 24-inch minimum as de facto Catch and Release, especially for the 18 existing Catch and Release streams, such as Yellow Breeches Creek and Spring Creek, proposed for re-designation as Trophy Trout Artificial Lures Only.
It's a change not everyone supports, even among the Fish and Boat commissioners.
"Me personally? I'd like to keep Catch and Release," said commissioner Bill Sabatose, who chairs the fisheries committee. "We'll see what fishermen want, but that's my opinion. Put the resource first."
Re-designating current Catch and Release waters as Trophy Trout Artificial Lures Only doesn't make sense, says Dwight Landis of Bellefonte, the author of "Trout Streams of Pennsylvania, an Angler's Guide," since most are small free-stoners where a 14-inch trout is unusual and a 24-incher is practically non-existent.
"You can't label a little mountain stream, like Hunt's Run or the East Fork of Sinnemahoning, as Trophy Trout waters. It would be false advertising. People would drive there in search of big fish and say, 'What?' They ought to just keep these streams Catch and Release."
Though Hoopes had proposed a one-a-day, 16-inch minimum (up from two-a-day, 14 inches) for Trophy Trout -- about five percent of stocked trout -- Sabatose said he came up with 24 inches, in part because it also would apply to existing All Tackle Trophy Trout waters, such as sections of the Youghiogheny and Clarion rivers, where anglers have a good shot at catching a 20-plus inch trout. "The other commissioners jumped right on it," he said.
The commission's seven-member board decided at a special meeting two weeks ago to seek public comment before voting on this and other proposed changes later this year.
The other changes include replacing the Heritage Trout Angling and the Delayed Harvest Fly Fishing Only programs with a new program called Catch and Release Fly Fishing Only and allowing wading, barbed hooks and round-the-clock fishing on previously restricted streams.
All are aimed at attracting new anglers.
Also on the commission table are changes to some of the state's 3,012 wild trout streams or sections of stream beginning in April. That's when the commissioners are expected to add 23 wild trout streams to its Class A list, remove 25 streams from the general wild trout list and shorten the downstream limits on 60 others.
Some sections had been placed on the list originally on the basis of anecdotal evidence rather than actual surveys, said Hoopes, though they eventually may be surveyed and returned to the list.
Hoopes said the commission revisited its wild trout list following a court case several years ago in which it challenged a permit the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection had granted for a landfill operation near a wild trout water. Commonwealth Court directed the commission to publish criteria for wild trout designations as well as a list of streams.
Any stream found to contain naturally reproducing fish is included on the list. Sub-lists exist for Class A waters, which have the densest population of wild trout, and Wilderness streams, which are located in remote places. Many wild trout waters are also stocked, and anglers can expect to see more, said fish commission spokesman Dan Tredinnick.
"It's no secret that we're going to discuss stocking certain Class A streams that may have a Class A biomass but not enough adult trout to support a high-use recreational fishery," he said. "Class A are the ones people get indignant about and defensive of. They won't be de-listed necessarily, but they'll possibly get stocked."
Not coincidentally, many streams, like Young Woman's Creek in Clinton County, which were transferred from the Class A list to the stocking list last year, are in the north-central part of the state, where Gov. Ed Rendell is concentrating new tourism efforts.
"Some folks say it's sacrilege to stock over wild trout," Tredinnick said.
"But, if recreation is part of the local economy, some guys say if we don't do it, the economy will die.
"Our job is to cut through the noise and figure out what must be done. It does bring up the question, 'What makes a quality fishery?' Is it the recreational potential, the origin of the fish, the setting?"
According to Ken Undercoffer, former Pennsylvania Trout Unlimited president, maintaining the pristine quality of the natural resource comes first, even if it means fewer license sales.
He opposes stocking wild trout streams and said wild populations will thrive, even under increased pressure, if they are carefully managed for Catch and Release.
Currently, many fall under general regulations, which allow for a five-a-day harvest.
The commission also is assessing the results of a creel survey it conducted last year on 200 randomly selected wild trout streams or sections in the north-central part of the state to determine how they are fished, as well as their potential as destination, or tourism, waters.
Each was visited four times, said Hoopes, yielding 800 "observations." The information will be given to a Penn State University professor who will use the data to develop economic impact projections, such as those that were created for the steelhead fishery in Erie.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.