A recent column from the food and drink website The Takeout’s entertaining anonymous advice columnist, “The Salty Waitress,” tackles to the oft-debated question of how soon is too soon to review a restaurant:

“Now whether it’s fair to judge a restaurant in its first couple weeks is debatable. On the one hand, it’s open for business and charging real money. If a mechanic’s shop just opened, and I took my car in, and they only fixed part of the engine’s problem, I wouldn’t chalk it up to a learning experience. Why should restaurants be any different? Because there’s a more subtle dance to the service a restaurant provides. It’s not just a matter of making a widget. That’s why most real restaurant critics won’t visit a restaurant until it’s been open at least a month — and will go back multiple times.”

Or, as a bartender once told me much more succinctly: “I wait a few months to visit a new restaurant so they can get all the suck out of their system.”

Well put.

Advertise with us

Which brings me to an examination of The Vault Taproom, which opened in late July to quite a bit of fanfare because of its location — in the former nearly three-decade East Carson Street home of iconic coffeeshop The Beehive — and for the technological novelty of incorporating an iPourIt self-service tap system for beer and wine.

Owner Kyle Wolfe is a University of Pittsburgh-educated chemical engineer turned first-time restaurateur. His transformation of the space was both stunning, with a beautiful new U-shaped LED-lit bar, yet boring, with nothing but white walls around.

In mid-August, the menu was large and well-conceived, if poorly executed. A Saturday brunch I had was completely forgettable. On another visit, a bowl of chicken noodle pho sounded interesting; instead it was completely bland. Likewise, a duck confit banh mi seemed promising; rather the meat was almost gelatinous and kind of gross. Service was friendly but lackadaisical.

A few months later, and the experience could not have been more different. And better.

All credit due to executive chef Todd Cassell, a native of Columbus, Ohio, and a graduate of the New England Culinary Institute in Montpelier, Vt., and a Marine Corps veteran. Perhaps his Devil Dog bona fides have rubbed off staff-wide: On a recent and busy Friday night the restaurant was well drilled, and the food on the pared-down menu was delicious.

Advertise with us

The Chef’s Chili ($6) is perfect for the suddenly freezing weather. It’s heavy on the meat — with house-smoked pork butt and brisket burnt ends — has a touch of heat from Fresno chilis and is rounded out with Guinness and a paprika crema.

Roasted Winter Squash Hummus ($8) was light and a bit sweet, topped with spiced pepitas for texture and served with English cucumbers, red bell pepper, carrots, crispy toasted pita triangles and golden beet chips for dipping.

The 12-hour Smoked Brisket Reuben ($16) was like a detonating bomb of savory smoke. The peppered brisket was as tender, flavorful and of the same high quality one would expect at a better barbecue joint. The gruyere and the light touch of sauerkraut and housemade Russian dressing were a nice complement, and lightly toasted Mancini’s rye bread brought it all together.

The side of perfectly creamy orecchiette mac and cheese topped with crunchy buttered panko crumbs was as good as one could ask for.

My dining companion relayed high marks for The Signature burger ($13) topped with gruyere, grilled Vidalia onions, a sweet tomato jam and bibb lettuce on a brioche bun.

Advertise with us

Lead bartender Paige Barker, a transplant from Lexington, Ky., who came to Pittsburgh a few years ago to help open local franchises of Bonefish Grill, has created an excellent cocktail menu.

Her Pineapple Death Squad ($11) with Del Maguey Vida mezcal, house falernum, pineapple gum syrup and lime juice was citrus forward and subtly smoky on the back end. A nicely balanced drink. The same goes for the lightly sour Naked & Famous ($12), also made with mezcal, yellow Chartreuse, Aperol and lime.

There’s even some interesting artwork on the wall now, including a re-imagining of the Rene Magritte classic “The Son of Man,” except with an avocado replacing the apple — millennial zeitgeist if ever there was such a thing.

Oddly, the beer setup, which garnered all the initial buzz, is probably the least interesting thing about the place. The tap list is more than acceptable with a nice mix of local and national craft beer. It’s sort of fun to pour your own. But that novelty fades quickly. The food and cocktails will be what keeps people coming back, and right now, The Vault is hitting a stride and doing both very well.

The Vault Taproom: 1327 E. Carson St., South Side Flats; 412-904-4462; https://www.thevaultpgh.com.

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412.