It was famed filmmaker Federico Fellini who once posited that “Life is a combination of magic and pasta,” and it was while watching one of his films playing on the flat screen behind the bar at Garbarino’s in East Liberty that it dawned on me that my early-40s paunch is directly the result of the magic of pasta. And sauce. And bread. And olive oil. And wine. And digestif. And all of the good things that entail a proper Italian feast.

Semolina, eggs, salt and oil made into: Pappardelle. Tagliatelle. Strozzapreti. Pici. Rigatoni. Paccheri. Spaghetti. Bucatini. Fettuce. Penne. Ziti. Linguine. Orecchiette. Mafalde. Cavatappi. Cavatelli. Gemelli. Maccheroni. Agnolotti. Ravioli.

I could eat it for every meal and love it all so much that I created an Instagram hashtag, #pittsburghpastaporn. Feel free to contribute. Because from the South Side to the Strip, Highland Park to Harmony, and Allentown to Downtown we’re living in an absolute golden age of Italian dining in Pittsburgh, probably not seen since bygone stalwarts such as Pasta Piatto and Minutello’s dominated the scene and the Tambellini empire was at its height.

So it’s a crowded field with a deep bench that Andrew Garbarino waded into earlier this year when he reimagined the downstairs space of his ultra-luxe Twisted Frenchman restaurant — previously a casual French bistro that didn’t go over — in East Liberty as Garbarino’s Restaurant 4th Gen, serving classic Italian and Italian-American dishes. The name is an homage to Mr. Garbarino’s great-grandaunt Louisa, an immigrant from Genoa who in 1945 opened Garbarino’s Restaurant in Lynbrook on Long Island, N.Y., and ran it until it closed in 1996.

Advertise with us

“I never wanted an Italian restaurant,” the Johnstown native said shortly after the restaurant’s rechristening in April. He’d studied at the prestigious Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, N.Y., and while he has been drawn to creating food that pushes boundaries, a return to his roots was appealing. And given the early results at Garbarino’s, one might wonder why he didn’t consider it sooner.

Life gave Mr. Garbarino lemons, and with them he’s made limoncello. Quite literally. There is a lovely house basil limoncello at the bar, where the staff makes some terrific cocktails like the Baum Boulevardier ($10) a classic with Old Forester rye, Cinzano, Campari and Peychaud’s bitters.

A touch adopted from the namesake Garbarino’s, fresh bread is served with sizzling butter and oil and roasted garlic cloves in a cast iron pan. It’s a nice upgrade on the perfunctory bread and butter or oil and balsamic that are standard at Italian spots.

The Italian Sausage Beans and Greens ($13) is one of the best interpretations I’ve ever had of this Western Pennsylvania staple. Sweet and spicy pork sausage and cannellini beans are in a flavorful chicken stock made richer with the addition of butter, and only a light smattering of escarole.

As tomato season sadly winds to a close, a Caprese ($14) was refreshing and served with a baseball of burrata, though it could’ve done with less balsamic and a dash of salt.

Advertise with us

They deal in carne classics like a decadent Veal Chop, Chicken Piccata and a 14-ounce New York Strip, as well as veg-friendly Eggplant Parm and Wild Mushroom Risotto ($19-46).

But the housemade pasta was what I was here for and it did not disappoint. The Spaghetti Bolognese ($19) is a masterpiece. A base of rendered guanciale fat amps up the flavor of the ground prosciutto, beef and veal. Tomatoes and diced carrots give it a distinctive orange hue, and the spaghetti is cut extra long so your forearms will feel like Popeye’s after fork-twirling it through the rich Bolognese sauce.

Another winner: the Rigatoni Siciliana ($19), with sausage, eggplant, banana peppers, marinara and smoked mozzarella, which Mr. Garbarino described as being like the “best parts of the top of a pizza” in a pasta dish. He’s not wrong, as it is a blast of great flavor.

A minor misfire was the Rigatoni Amatriciana ($18). The pasta was perfect, the marinara hearty, but it was a little light on the guanciale and red pepper flake that give this classic it’s distinctive smoky and piquant taste.

Mr. Garbarino might have never intended to have an Italian restaurant, but the one he’s created does his family name and history proud. Besides, as Fellini also said: “Experience is what you get while looking for something else.”

Advertise with us

Garbarino’s 4th Gen Restaurant: 5925 Baum Blvd., East Liberty; 412-665-2880; http://garbarinos.com/

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412.