Fiscal responsibility went belly up. Giving up meat was a fruitless endeavor. Becoming a teetotaler was a total no-go. No carbs? No bueno.
All of the aforementioned vices have been sworn off (and then abruptly resumed) in years past by yours truly in failed attempts to observe Lent. Doing so was not as much a nod to my long-lapsed Catholicism but rather a quixotic attempt to break bad habits and set new ones. Alas, willpower has never been a particularly strong suit.
This year, however, was different. In an honest effort to become more mindful about what I’m eating and how much of it I’m shoveling into my maw, I successfully abstained from a whole slew of goodies for the annual 40-day season. Hamburgers, fries, wings, chips, ice cream, pop — I haven’t had any of the above since early March and am not in any particular rush for them. I’ve lost a few pounds and feel pretty good.
But for one item on the banned list — pizza! — I marked the time like a prisoner notching on a cell wall the days left on a sentence. Lent ended Thursday. You can do the math on how my weekend was spent: huffing down the outstanding pizzas and quaffing fermented apple juice at Threadbare Cider House in Spring Garden.
It was opened in late 2017 by the folks behind Wigle Whiskey, which was inspired by the lore of local Whiskey Rebellion distiller Phillip Wigle. Threadbare, as my colleague Bob Batz wrote at the time, “is all about someone who was Mr. Wigle’s contemporary: Johnny Appleseed. John ‘Johnny Appleseed’ Chapman was a real person, if a real eccentric, who lived in Pittsburgh in the 1790s as he made a name for himself, planting the seeds of cider apples throughout the frontier, wearing no shoes and tattered clothing. Hence the name Threadbare.”
Threadbare and Wigle offices now are consolidated in this renovated 1,500-square-foot brick-and-beam building, which used to house the offices for a sprawling early 1900s tannery, one of the biggest in the country. Cider is produced on-site, and a full kitchen serves meat, cheese and pickle platters; soup and salad; six-cut pizzas; and rotating desserts. The executive chef is Jay Wess, who honed his skills under a bona fide Pittsburgh pizza G.O.A.T., Sonja Finn of Dinette in East Liberty.
Mr. Wess makes sourdough crusts started with some yeast from the cider-making side (there’s also a gluten-free cornmeal polenta crust), and it is delicious.
A basic pepperoni ($13) was anything but, with that flavorful thin crust baked to cracker crispness and topped with a local pepperoni.
The “Stinging Nettle,” a white pizza topped with sage cream, mozzarella, crimini mushroom and its namesake root, was rich and earthy ($14).
Another white pizza, this one with roasted apples, mozzarella, rosemary and slow-cooked pork from Fallen Aspen Farm in Lawrence County, was an absolute masterpiece. The tart apple, fragrant rosemary, salty cheese and juicy pork hit nearly every taste receptor on the tongue.
I’d written off hard cider as a hard pass years ago, likely because of some cloyingly sweet mass-produced and sugar-laden product. But the baker’s dozen of varieties at Threadbare, which uses apples from local orchards, are all dry to off-dry — refreshing with a faint sweetness and a light pucker factor, and a few that are downright funky in a good way. They’re strong, with ABVs in the same range of single and double IPAs, but can be ordered in three-ounce samplers for $3 so noobs like myself can try a few and figure out what’s good.
Threadbare ciders and Wigle products are both employed in a slate of cocktails with great balance, including a perfect Sazerac ($10).
Service was pleasant good, and the long communal tables are perfect for an extended stay filled with drink and conversation — and a primo fix to quell a pizza jones that was six weeks in the making.
Threadbare Cider House: 1291 Spring Garden Ave., Spring Garden; 412-322-5100; threadbarecider.com.
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.