In the closing moments of Martin Scorsese’s 1990 mafia masterpiece “Goodfellas,” Henry Hill (played by Ray Liotta) delivers a soliloquy lamenting his new life in the flyover country of the witness protection program in which he memorably addresses its drawbacks.
“Today, everything is different; there’s no action,” Hill says. “I have to wait around like everyone else. Can’t even get decent food. Right after I got here, I ordered some spaghetti with marinara sauce, and I got egg noodles and ketchup.”
I have a friend in the same boat. Not witness protection, mind you. But rather, an inability to find quality ethnic fare. A proud Italian-American son of the Mon Valley, he lived in Chicago for 20 years before and briefly returned to Pittsburgh — no shortage of good gravy in either town — before taking a job in the dead center of Pennsylvania in a college town largely bereft of any options aside from Il giardino delle olive (take a guess).
Needless to say, when he rolls into town now, he’s on a full-on sauce jones, ready to mainline marinara if that’s what it takes. It was with his plight in mind that an investigation of two new red sauce joints, Alida’s Woodfired Cucina and Piazza Talarico, both a few short blocks apart on Penn Avenue in Lawrenceville, unfolded.
Opened in November by the family behind bygone collegiate haunt The Panther Hollow Inn, Alida’s is in the shiny new Shoppes at Doughboy and it does wood-oven pizza, housemade pasta and bread and other entrees pretty well. It gets bonus points for calling its appetizer portion of pork meatballs Bocce Balls ($10).
Of the half-dozen signature pizzas, the Rossa Caliente featured fresh mozzarella, soppressata, Romano, hot Peruvian peppers, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil ($18) and was a terrific and spicy pie.
Read More
My heaping helping of the lasagna ($15) was very good, with only ricotta cheese and a subtly sweet house tomato sauce (but no meat) and served with grilled bread, and I’d like to make a return visit to try the linguine with anchovy, garlic and breadcrumbs ($10). A side cup of wedding soup was warming on a yet another cold Pittsburgh spring night.
My friend was only lukewarm on the tortellini special, which came in a light tomato cream sauce with grilled bread ($17), and his side salad, unfortunately, had some rather peaked-looking produce.
Alida’s has a full service bar and the interior is perfectly nice but lacking in atmosphere — to that end, it kind of felt like a suburban Bravo! in the middle of the city. But, the food was mostly pretty good, and that’s what matters.
Just up the street, the pocket-sized Piazza Talarico — so named because of a rear courtyard that will be a delight if it EVER. WARMS. UP. HERE. — is a welcoming classic Italian trattoria with snug seating and the Talarico family’s passed-down recipes, including some impressive house wine sold under the banner of Papa Joe’s Wine Cellar. Old family pictures adorn the plastered walls, as does a copy of the ship manifest that brought some of this Zelienople clan’s ancestors to America from Calabria.
Daughter Beth Talarico is the chef, daughter Katie makes the wine with “Papa” Joe, and they do their family name proud with simple but delicious dishes.
Greens & Beans ($9) Escarole and cannellini beans in chicken broth was a fine starter, as was a nearly paper-thin pepperoni pizza ($14) with fresh mozzarella and basil.
Having never even heard of it before, I found the Easter pie ($8) was something of a revelation — part quiche, part calzone with eggs and pepperoni ensconced in a flaky crust.
Grandma’s Sauce ($14) — rigatoni with traditional meat-flavored tomato sauce and three huge meatballs for an additional $3 — was a bowl of beautiful comfort and a slightly tangy sauce. A return visit is in order for the Baked Maccheroni ($16), which is the same dish but amped up with pepperoni, cheese and boiled eggs.
They make nine red and white varietals, and the Vino da Tavola — a table wine blend of Cabernet Sauvignon and Sangiovese grapes ($7 a glass) — was almost dangerously smooth and juicy.
And, needless to say, my buddy got his red sauce fix.
Alida’s Woodfired Cucina: 3345 Penn Ave., Lawrenceville; 412-742-4495; https://www.alidaspgh.com.
Piazza Talarico: 3832 Penn Ave., Lawrenceville; 412-652-9426; https://www.piazzatalarico.com/#come-together.
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter@gigs412.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.