In an era of new restaurants with million-dollar build-outs meticulously executed by top-dollar design teams, menus that read like the SAT verbal section, PR reps on speed dial and chefs with local Q ratings at least on par with the Penguins’ fourth line, a modest Bloomfield sandwich shop would seem an unlikely spot to become a hot dining destination.
There’s a raccoon pelt on the wall, under a drop ceiling, and an old bowling alley lane for a countertop. More than once during an afternoon lunch rush, nebby neighborhood nonnies poke their heads in through the open doorway and holler a hello to anyone who’s listening. And the hirsute and heavily tattooed gentleman working the griddle looks like he could pass for a Guns N’ Roses roadie.
But to borrow Han Solo’s line about the Millennium Falcon, “She may not look like much, but she’s got it where it counts, kid.”
Indeed. The food is straight-up killer. And it has a genuine vibe that you can’t get from a focus-grouped concept. That’s all part of the charm at DJ’s Sandwich Shoppe. Opened in late March in the former site of the neighborhood institution Mama Ros’ Bloomfield Sandwich Shop, it’s run by the aforementioned affable fellow, DJ Smulick. He’s the proprietor and cleaver wielder extraordinaire of his nearby namesake DJ’s Butcher’s Block butcher shop.
Mr. Smulick is a graduate of the prestigious Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, N.Y., and his itinerant career has taken him into some of the nation’s top kitchens from the Big Apple to the Big Easy, and all over Pittsburgh. Four years ago he opened his butcher’s shop to acclaim for the high quality cuts and varieties of meats he offers — heavy emphasis on local and grass-fed — as well as his roughly two dozen signature sausages, which can range from standard hot or sweet Italian to elaborate combinations such as blueberry jalapeno maple or Creole gator.
This weekend, Mr. Smulick will put his bratwursts to the test at 2 p.m. Saturday at Grist House Brewery in Millvale against stiff competition from the Berlin Street Food truck and Lawrenceville’s Butcher on Butler in the inaugural Pittsburgh Brat Festival.
Read More
But the sandwich shop gives a new definition to “street meat” as the menu features Mr. Smulick’s exceptional products, expertly crafted a few doors up on Liberty Avenue.
The venison and bacon burger topped with a fried farm egg and organic cheddar ($12) was fantastic. Although seemingly simple in construction, it was wonderfully complex in flavor: the sharp taste of the venison was complemented by the smoky bacon, which was added to give the lean meat more fat and juice, and the viscous runny egg was a deep yellow gold that mixed well with the meat.
On another visit, a special was the “Roadkill” burger made from a proprietary patty that combines elk, venison, beef, pork and bison meats and is topped with a liberal glob of shredded barbecue pork in a tangy sauce ($12). If it really was roadkill, it would have taken an Abrams tank to fell this herd of beasts.
The pulled pork sandwich ($7) itself was eye-popping with thick, sinewy strands of almost rope-like shredded meat and bright magenta pickled slaw atop it.
All the sandwiches are served on a grilled bun from the Paddy Cake Bakery a few short blocks away, and with peppery, spicy pucker-inducing pickles made in house. Other items include a filet and rib-eye steak sandwich, a corned beef Reuben, wild boar chili and chicken chorizo and egg tacos.
DJ’s is open for breakfast and lunch, and late nights on the weekend, but almost amazingly, in the social media era, the place is still something of a secret having garnered only a few mentions on local websites and a handful of Yelp reviews. Given the high quality fare, that won’t be the case much longer.
DJ’s Sandwich Shop: 4613 Liberty Ave., Bloomfield; 412-390-5917.
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.