For a Memorial Day weekend road trip to Fort Necessity National Battlefield in Fayette County, I researched other area attractions, and by “attractions” I mean my family’s favorite kind: Places to eat and drink.

We hit five of them, if you count as two the Christian W. Klay Winery and its Ridge Runner Distillery across Fayette Springs Road. We did a quick tasting at each and scored a bottle of Peach Pie Moonshine as a perfect souvenir.

We spent more time at three other places along this rolling, touristy stretch of the old National Road, starting, for second breakfast, at the Bittersweet Cafe, which I’ve been wanting to visit since it opened last year. On the road from Farmington to Ohiopyle, it looks like a pretty mountain cabin, surrounded by beautiful gardens. We pulled in and walked up onto the long covered side porch, where a big family group was eating, and in through the antique store to the cafe, which is warmly welcoming. The counter, refrigerated case and menu board offered all sorts of tempting baked goods, breakfast and lunch sandwiches and side dishes, as well as espresso and other drinks.

Owner Terri Krysak, who describes herself as “an on-the-job trained baker, chef and caterer,” and her family raise many of their ingredients on site, including their own honey (you can see the hives by the vegetable garden out back), and use other local produce as they can, cooking from scratch. But thanks in part to their proximity to international attractions such as Fallingwater, customers literally come from all over the world, judging by the pins in the map on one wall. I know some who want to come back just to eat here.

Advertise with us

My wife’s big breakfast sandwich ($6) was a free-range egg, sausage and three cheeses with house red pepper jelly and house mustard on a house-made English muffin, no less. My son ordered his half-pound burger ($10) plain, but it was on a housemade bun, too. I just got a dish of a colorful chickpea/carrot/dried currant salad ($4). We ate outside at a table in the front garden, surrounded by potted plants and sunshine. We all can’t wait to return so we can try a slice of pie and some other desserts, but we had places to go.

That included, after spending several hours at the National Park Service fort site, downtown Uniontown, where I finally visited another place I’d been wanting to try: the tavern at the former Hotel Titlow, a four-story brick landmark built in 1905. It looked like we were thwarted because children aren’t allowed in the bar, but we could sit in the adjacent dining room. I walked over to tour the old-school, tin-ceilinged barroom and pick out a bottle of craft beer ($5.50) and the bartender told me how that dining room actually is in the former lobby. Upstairs now is apartments, but the first floor isn’t much changed, and the period artifacts evoke the feeling of a classic hotel.

Sitting at our white-clothed table, we read the placemat history of the place and learned that we were there on the 76th anniversary of the death of founder George F. Titlow — to the very minute. So we toasted him with my wife’s glass of Pinot Grigio ($8) and my son’s Sprite ($3), which he had with a cup of wedding soup ($3). When the rear dining room, the Grille, opened at 4, we popped in there to have a look, and I wished we could stay in that cozy space for a classic American dinner, but we had to ... well, go eat dinner.

For that, I headed back on Route 40 to Hopwood and finally entered the 200-year-old stone tavern where I’d wanted to eat since it was Chez Gerard French restaurant. It was purchased three years ago, renovated and reopened last July by psychologist Roxanne McCarthy, who moved here from New York City because her sister runs the Christian Klay winery up on “the Mountain.” She exposed the old beams and thick stone walls and started a seasonal, locally sourced farm-to-table menu, executed by former Nemacolin Woodlands Resort and Stone House chef Joshua Diehl.

The doctor herself greeted us that Saturday afternoon and chatted about her beliefs on healthy foods such as baby kale. Alas, our servers said they were out of several dishes and had only basic canned beer, because a cocktail competition (with Ridge Runner Distillery) had “cleaned us out” the previous weekend. My wife ordered a glass of Malbec ($7). I had to settle for a can of Yuengling ($3).

Advertise with us

We still had plenty of choices from the menu and started with the interesting Roasted Cauliflower “Hummus” served with naan, the Indian flatbread ($11). That plate was prettily decorated with black onion or Nigella seeds and an orange flower from the restaurant’s pretty garden. (The owner said that despite her local sourcing, “We try to do international foods -— it’s just more interesting,” and the menu does include nonlocal items such as shrimp.)

We all were happy that the kids menu included the grilled chicken salad ($6) that my son devoured. My wife enjoyed the Chicken Piccatta ($23), deliciously described as being served with house-made cappellini; lemon, wine and stock reduction; fresh mozzarella; prosciutto; Parmigiano Reggiano; and summer vegetables. It was good, too, but color- and content-wise, noticeably lacking in veggies.

And I could barely see any spinach in my Longhorn Steak & Eggs ($26), a grass-fed cut served with sunny-side-up eggs. The eggs, with deep-orange yolks, were perfectly cooked, but the steak was too rare, and the hashed potatoes seemed to be missing any house-cured ham.

I wished for more farm on the table — and a little more attention to detail — but everybody was nice and it was still a fine feed, and I’m sure the selection of veggies will swell in the summer. My family looks forward to going back.

Then we’ll hit a few more local “attractions,” such as the Stone House’s outdoor barbecue.

Advertise with us

Bittersweet Cafe is at 205 Farmington-Ohiopyle Road, Farmington, PA 15437 (724-329-4411 and mybittersweetcafe.com). Hours are 9 a.m.-5 p.m., 9 a.m.-5 p.m. Thursday, 9 a.m.-8 p.m. Friday-Saturday and noon-6 p.m. Sunday. 

The Titlow Tavern & Grille is at 92 W. Main St., Uniontown, PA 15401 (724-437-6749 and titlowtavern.net). Grille hours are 11 a.m.-9:30 p.m. Monday-Thursday, 11 a.m.-10:30 p.m. Friday and 4 to 10:30 p.m. Saturday (the tavern stays open until 11 p.m. Monday-Thursday and from 11 a.m.-1:30 a.m. Friday-Saturday).

Dr. McCarthy’s Kitchen is at 1186 National Pike in Hopwood, PA 15445; 724-550-4355 and drmccarthyskitchen.com. Summer (April to October) hours are 11 a.m.- 8 p.m. Tuesday-Thursday, 11 a.m.-9 p.m. Friday-Saturday and 11 a.m.-2 p.m. (brunch) and 5 to 8 p.m. Sunday.

Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.