It was Irish literary giant Jonathan Swift who opined, “He was a bold man that first ate an oyster,” but it’s another quote by a Scottish chap of local import whose allegorical thoughts on bivalve mollusks are featured on the website for Muddy Waters Oyster Bar in East Liberty: “The first man gets the oyster, the second man gets the shell.”

That, of course, was Andrew Carnegie’s advice to hustle in life, and it’s an appropriate sentiment for an impressive debut by Greensburg native chef Adam Kucenic’s first solo endeavor.

And while the restaurant’s name likely refers as much (or more) to the natural habitats of the featured fare, the Southern influences on the menu are certainly a nod to the stage name of Mississippian McKinley Morganfield, who became the father of the Chicago blues. To that end, a look at Muddy Waters Oyster Bar through the lyrics of … Muddy Waters.

“Well, if the river was whiskey, and I was a divin’ duck, Well, I would dive to the bottom, never would I come up.” — “Rollin’ and Tumblin’”

Advertise with us

Liquor bottles — mostly whiskies — are backlit in understated shelving bordered by clean white subway tile, while patrons find elbow room on a handsome white marble bar top. Blues (natch!) on the stereo ease the vibe, and distressed corrugated steel paneling in the dining room give a roadhouse kind of look.

The cocktail slate is both modest and well executed. The Sazerac was perfect with a nice bite from the rye and the absinthe rinse, and the French 75 pleased a friend such that he shared memories of slamming down several in rapid succession to ease the sting of a rough outing at the Caribbean Stud table at a Louisiana casino.

A selection of sparkling white wines, the natural accompaniment to freshly shucked oysters, are available. One gripe: no draft beer. Although the selection of higher-end canned beers was more than acceptable.

“He gonna make pretty women’s, Jump and shout, Then the world wanna know, What this all about.” — “Hoochie Coochie Man”

While the aphrodisiac properties of oysters have never been definitively determined, let’s just roll with that notion and the lyrics (actually written by the legendary Willie Dixon) from the famously suggestive bluesman’s best-known song to pair with the restaurant’s signature item.

Advertise with us

East Coast oysters are $3 a piece, West Coast $4, and a chef’s tasting combining both into a dozen is $36. An order of Oysters Rockefeller or chargrilled oysters are $15.

We opted for two each of the East Coast oysters, from Barnstable and Beavertails, Mass., Charles Island, Conn., and James River, Va., presented with a house mignonette sauce.

Even at a restaurant, most shellfish make you work a little for their spoils, but there is something deeply satisfying about the ritual consumption of oysters — hitting them with a dollop of hot sauce, tilting the shell to your face and SLUURRRP!

I particularly enjoyed the Barnstable oysters, which had a buttery taste, and the James River, which were wonderfully clean and briny.

“Going down to Louisiana to get me a mojo hand.” — “Got My Mojo Workin’”

Advertise with us

Po’ Boys, shrimp and grits and fried green tomatoes are among many items that offer a taste of the South, but the Crab Boil Reuben ($15) is among the more unique offerings on the menu.

Pastrami is marinated with the crab boil seasonings, “sauerkraut” comes from pickled collard greens, and a remoulade substitutes for Russian dressing. It’s on toasted rye with gruyere cheese and pickles — I’ve never had a sandwich quite like it.

The Louisiana Lobster Roll ($20) is a simple, clean classic with Maine lobster and crawfish with lemon and butter on Breadworks bread.

The Seafood Gumbo ($24) was simply outstanding. So much going on — fried oysters, shrimp, lobster, crawfish, Andouille sausage, dirty rice and okra, all in a richly flavored broth, with a gentle heat.

“Well, I give ’er, Give her all a-my money, Tell me what more, can I do?” — “She’s Alright”

Advertise with us

This is quality fare, and one expects it to be priced accordingly, but a bit of fair warning: The tab can grow fairly quickly. To wit: An appetizer, eight oysters, a sandwich each and a split order of gumbo and the bill was already $90, before a single drink was ordered.

A price of $16 seems too much to ask for a Po’ Boy (not to mention ironic), as does $20 for a lobster roll (even if it is quite good). Then again, we are well into the Google era of the East End.

“Everythin’, everythin’, everythin’s gonna be alright this mornin’.” — “Mannish Boy”

Bottom line: Food, service, drinks all well above the line. A little pricey, but that’s not unforgivable for a genuinely fun evening in a cool new spot.

Muddy Waters Oyster Bar: 130 S. Highland Ave., East Liberty; 412-361-0555; muddywaterspgh.com.

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412.