As ubiquitous a part of any childhood as scraped knees and the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Legos and Uno, playground humiliation and “Star Wars” adulation, the modest peanut butter and jelly sandwich was given its first mention in a 1901 article in the Boston Cooking School Magazine of Culinary Science and Domestic Economics.

Opining on the always controversial topic of “Peanuts and Pralines,” Julia Davis Chandler wrote:

“For variety, some day try making little sandwiches, or bread fingers, of three very thin layers of bread and two of filling, one of peanut paste, whatever brand you prefer, and currant or crab apple jelly for the other. The combination is delicious, and so far as I know, original.”

And it was considered highfalutin fare, too. At the time, peanut butter was an expensive delicacy often paired with pimento cheese and crackers (and presumably a huge glass of water) in elite New York teahouses.

Advertise with us

New production methods for peanut butter — and the advent of sliced bread — made the PB&J the actual best thing since … y’know … but also expanded its popularity to both American GIs and American kids who played with G.I. Joes. It’s been a staple ever since.

So it stands to reason that in an era of eateries dedicated to single items — grilled cheese or soup or meatballs, for instance — that a place might be based around this classic. And now there is, in Bloomfield. Peanut Butter Jelly Time! opened Thanksgiving week and is the brainchild of siblings Chris and Lauren Firman.

The name is taken from a patently absurd club song (that’s actually about a car) of the same name. The song became something of a minor viral sensation in 2002 when its video, featuring a ridiculous 8-bit dancing banana, hit the Web. (Seriously, Google it — so dumb it’s funny.) The song was also briefly featured to hilarious effect in a 2005 episode of “Family Guy.” It’s an esoteric reference for fairly specific fare.

But in an age where hamburgers and tacos can push north of $15, would Peanut Butter Jelly Time! recapture the highbrow history of the sandwich with gold-flecked peanut butter and caviar jelly on a cronut with champagne?

Perhaps it would have a deconstructed PBJ & PBR where you overpay for a surly chef with tattoo sleeves, a Keisel-beard and Warby Parkers to hand you a tall boy along with jars of Skippy and Smuckers and a loaf of Town Talk and you make it yourself?

Advertise with us

Or maybe a molecular gastronomy PBJ with an essence of peanut butter foam and dehydrated jelly powder hit with liquid nitrogen, while Swedish EDM thumps on the speakers?

Nope. Cut the culinary cynicism. This is as cheery a place as you’ll find. Brightly colored and inexpensive, it’s perfect for families and has a menu that’s full of fun takes on the original, with any (mostly sweet) ingredient imaginable.

The permutations are potentially endless. Some have bananas, some marshmallow spread, chocolate sauce or caramel. They come on waffles, toast or Cinnabon bread and can include cream cheese, pickle chips, honey or fresh fruit. They turn them into “calzones,” “hot dogs” and 13 different variations of “sushi.”

The peanut butter is housemade, and the jellies and jams are made locally by Breadspreads by Susan out of Avella. The sandwiches start at 99 cents for a traditional on white bread (crusts optional), and, ironically, the most expensive thing on the menu is a $6.99 … grilled cheese.

Folks of any age can appreciate the place, but the experts are in elementary school — prime PB&J consumption years. So we put together a panel of experts — the kids of a few PG staffers — to give us their thoughts.

Advertise with us

Eight-year-old Jesse Batz of Mt. Lebanon was resolute in his opinion that these were among the “best peanut butter sandwiches” he’d ever had.

Elsie Webb, 6, of Aspinwall, played coy and would not tip her hand much as to her thoughts, but a wide grin of missing baby teeth suggested she was pleased.

Our final panelist, 5-year-old Henry Howard of Shadyside, was the resident iconoclast of the group and said he’d prefer turkey and cheese. Mr. Howard likely has a big future hating on bands everyone else likes and reminding people that soccer is the “real football.”

So to paraphrase the old Kix commercial, go ahead and call Peanut Butter Jelly Time “Kid tested, Munch approved.”

Peanut Butter Jelly Time: 4709 Liberty Ave., Bloomfield; 412-422-0225 or pbjpgh.com.

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412.