It was a fitting, almost fortuitous email to receive moments after sitting down to type out a column about a mostly magnificent meal: the Merriam-Webster Word of the Day — ingurgitate.
A transitive verb from the Latin roots “in” (in) and “gurgit” (whirlpool) it means “to swallow greedily or in large quantities: guzzle.” As in, Munch ingurgitated a delicious dinner recently at Carmella’s Plates & Pints on the South Side.
It is named for the establishment’s matriarch and muse, co-owner Carmella Salem, a South Side bartending fixture for more than two decades who, along with business partner Mike Alberter, took over the classic East Carson Street dive the Inn Termission Lounge in September 2013 and has given it quite the spit-shine. Extensive renovations to the building include a beautiful restoration of the Victorian facade; the addition of gas lamps outside; and a refurbishment of the slate floor and copper work in the bar, and the stained-glass windows and exposed wooden beams in the dining room.
The motif is roughly that of a pre-Prohibition-era hunting lodge, replete with a custom-built fireplace in the dining room, taxidermy, and antiques collected by Mr. Alberter (my favorite: an 1891 Harper’s Weekly lithograph depicting “idle young men” loafing outside a liquor store). The handsome wooden tables were custom-made by a craftsman in Latrobe, and the flatware comes from Strip District potter Daniel Kuhn.
Stocking more than 170 bourbons and scotches, the bar recently added some excellent tequilas and mescals to go with a craft and classic cocktail menu, infused liquors, wines and dozens of draft and bottled beers.
The restaurant opened in November but after a business union with award-winning avant-garde chef David Murphy ended abruptly, Ms. Salem and Mr. Alberter tapped Kevin Lintelman to take over the kitchen.
Mr. Lintelman, who learned under local culinary mogul Richard DeShantz, capitalized on the opportunity, creating a well-executed menu of mostly comfort food dressed up with creative flair.
Starters and small plates range from Steak Tartar ($11) to Roasted Cauliflower ($14) and Duck Confit Tacos ($14). We tried the Smoked Tomato Hummus ($5), so good it could be consumed by the gallon, and the fun and spicy Devlish Eggs ($8), deviled eggs in panko breadcrumbs with green onion, a Korean chili sauce and serrano peppers.
Entrees include a Smoked Pork Chop ($19), a New York Strip Steak ($24) and Crab Cakes ($19), which were mildly seasoned and lightly fried and served with a roasted corn remoulade over a crisp green bean salad.
Then, there is the Bison Burger ($14). In an era of what-else-can-we-pile-on-this-patty, it is a model of delicious restraint, simply topped with aged cheddar, a beef jus adding extra flavor, some tang from sauteed burgundy onions and sweetness from bread and butter pickles, between fresh brioche buns with a side of a smoky cole slaw.
Some men are kept awake at night by desires of riches or of the flesh, or anxious ruminations on the past and future. But like a modern J. Wellington Wimpy, I think about this hamburger, and who I’d gladly pay Tuesday for one today.
A nitpick (to be read in snooty European accent of your choosing) regarding the Shrimp Carbonara ($19), which, while quite good, was not carbonara. The parmesan- and cream-covered noodles lacked the requisite pepper; there was no pancetta or guanciale and the shrimp and peas, although perfectly done were extraneous, and the egg yolk was presented dippy-style to the side. Clever and tasty — just call it something else.
Ms. Salem ran a shot-and-beer pub for most of her career and has a devoted following, but has conceded it’s been an education moving to dining and premium spirits.
That’s occasionally reflected in the staff’s hesitant knowledge of the items available, but service is otherwise consistently warm.
I’d be remiss not to mention our excellent waiter, “Spider,” who immediately had me launching into Joe Pesci’s “Goodfellas” lines — “Spidah! Gimme a Cutty & wahtah!” — although I refrained from shooting him in the foot.
Later on weekend nights, the bar area can get a little raucous — and on occasional midweek evenings, like during a Penguins playoff game last month when a patron let fly unprintable gems about the team’s blue-line play.
But true to the lineage of its forebears, “The Mish” and Roxy’s Cafe, it retains a backslapping, corner bar character and comfort to complement the top-shelf food and drink that’s ready for guests to — word of the day! — ingurgitate.
Carmella’s Plates & Pints: 1908 E. Carson St., South Side Flats; 412-918-1215; facebook.com/CarmellasPlatesAndPints.
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com and on Twitter @gigs412.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.