Want to start an argument that will inflame passions with the heat of a thousand brick ovens and inspire as much rancor as the great Mt. Lebanon deer culling debate of 2015?

Make only this simple query: What's your favorite pizza?

Ask a hundred people, you'll get a hundred answers. When you adjust further for regional styles and toppings, the debate might only be slightly less polarizing than Kanye West's sunny disposition.

We've been in the midst of an ongoing pizza revolution here in Pittsburgh, one that started slowly but has picked up steam in recent years. While the neighborhood slice shops remain legendary, the wood and coal-fired gourmet creations of trained pizzaolos that were once a true novelty and limited to a small handful of destination spots around the region are increasingly commonplace. Consider that less than three years ago there were none in Downtown Pittsburgh, now there are six there alone and outstanding pies are being slung area-wide from Upper St. Clair to Harmony.

Advertise with us

The latest to join the competition is Circolo (literally "circle"), which is showing quite a bit of promise since opening in late January in a handsome corner building on East Carson Street in the South Side, which previously housed a dumpy sports bar.

Owners Troy and Dana Potteiger sought a more mature audience for the establishment (read: not college kids swilling cheap hooch) and to that end, the makeover, which includes an upstairs piano lounge and cigar bar, is already a great success, creating a warm space that is just as comfortable to have a nosh and a glass of wine alone as it is on a date or with a group of friends. Service was excellent on multiple visits and the bar staff is particularly good, as is the selection of craft beers, wines and cocktails.

In addition to the pizzas, chef William Scherz designed a menu of red sauce staples like the house signature meatballs, a blend of pork, beef, veal and spices served in a cast-iron skillet ($13). Meatball spots are also in vogue of late and those at Circolo are as good as you'll find.

Typically one wouldn't come to an Italian place to order wings, but these whole chicken wings finished off in the woodfired oven and topped with a house sriracha chili sauce were well worth making an exception.

A misstep was the artisan Italian meat and cheese sampler ($11). While the fontina, maytag bleu, provolone, aged asiago, sopressata, capicola, prosciutto were of acceptable quality, the whole plate was so heavily drizzled with a balsamic reduction it looked like a Jackson Pollock painting. Although visually appealing, the sweet and sticky balsamic completely overpowered everything else, ruining the otherwise decent selection of meats and cheeses.

Advertise with us

However, that same balsamic reduction was put to great use in the excellent mushroom formaggi pizza ($16), acting as an excellent complement to the garlic ricotta cheese, roasted cremini mushrooms, sharp fontina cheese, fresh thyme, and white truffle oil, with a nice consistency to the crust.

Another winner was the Salumist ($18), a solid pie with a San Marzano tomato sauce base, sopressata, Italian sausage, pancetta, hand-pulled mozzarella, and basil.

The "Broke Da Mout" ($16) was somewhat less successful. Although the components were all good -- San Marzano tomato sauce, broken meatballs, ricotta, hand-pulled mozzarella, caramelized onions, roasted mushrooms, fire roasted red peppers, and oregano -- the engineering on this one was more Leaning Tower and less Sistine Chapel. That is to say that the toppings were too heavy for the thin pizza and kind of fell off the crust making it hard to eat (at least without utensils).

For dessert, an outstanding piece of a house-baked cheesecake ($5) was a perfect ending.

In his 2014 autobiography, actor Neil Patrick Harris said "Magic is like pizza: even when it's bad, it's pretty good," and while I'd stop short of calling the pizzas at Circolo "magic" they easily surpass the pretty good barometer.

Advertise with us

Circolo is at 2100 E. Carson St., South Side; 412-251-5240; circolopgh.com.

munch@post-gazette.com or Twitter @ PGMunch. Become a Facebook Friend of Munch at www.facebook.com/munchPG.