For a guy hoping to make an impression in a new city, chef David Murphy knows how to make an entrance.
A recent culinary transplant from the thriving and dynamic Austin, Texas, dining scene, Mr. Murphy was the winner Sunday night on the Food Network's "Cutthroat Kitchen" -- the same week that he'll make his debut in a Pittsburgh kitchen at Carmella's Plates & Pints on the South Side.
Not unlike a Steelers Sunday, a packed house at Carmella's alternately cheered and booed during the broadcast before ultimately chanting, "DA-VID! DA-VID!" after he'd won that episode of the competition show, hosted by celebrity chef Alton Brown.
Mr. Murphy said he was offered a spot on the show after twice narrowly missing the cut for "Top Chef." The hourlong program was edited down from what he described as a grueling 13-hour filming day in Los Angeles that was marked by huge rushes of adrenaline followed by hours of inactivity.
"This is my career," he said. "I'd go from doing push-ups and drinking coffee to stay pumped up, and then I'd go out and perform. But then you'd have to sit around for two hours while the film crew had lunch."
His winning dish was a take on a lemon meringue pie that included micro-basil, blueberry compote, lemon sorbet and a toasted coriander meringue. He confessed he wouldn't serve it at his restaurant and that it was good for "what it was" and that "when you have 30 minutes to cook and 60 seconds to grab your ingredients -- that's intense."
He bested the competition during challenges that called for creating a waffle breakfast and an empanada, and his last remaining competitor was hobbled by having to wear ski boots while cooking, an element of the show's gimmicky appeal.
Although the episode was taped in August, he'd signed a nondisclosure agreement to keep the secret until Sunday night (but confessed that he did tell his grandmother back in Montgomery, Texas). His take-home prize was $6,500, but the notoriety is arguably more valuable for a chef in a new town.
Mr. Murphy came to Pittsburgh in August after working at the James Beard award-winning restaurant Uchi in Austin. His brother lives in Pittsburgh and heard Carmella's owners, Carmella Salem and Mike Alberter, were looking for a chef. Ms. Salem got in touch, and after an extended professional courtship, he accepted the job.
Since taking over the once smoky, straight-from-central-casting, classic East Carson Street dive the Inn Termission Lounge in September 2013, the building has undergone extensive renovations and refurbishments while remaining open as a bar. The kitchen will open to the public Saturday.
"I think Pittsburgh is right on the precipice of doing great things. That's why I came. This feels to me like Austin 10 years ago," he said.
While Mr. Murphy is new to Pittsburgh, co-owner Ms. Salem is a South Side fixture. She came here from Bridgeport, Ohio, to study theater at Point Park but ended up as the star of her own nightly "one-woman show" for more than two decades, having started as a bartender in 1993 at Fat Head's shortly after it opened. That was followed by a stint at McArdle's Pub before running Jekyll & Hyde's along with Mr. Alberter from 1996 until last year.
She concedes that it's been a leap of faith moving from a college-age, shot and beer crowd to innovative dining and premium spirits. That included education on bourbons and scotches (of which they stock more than 100, including a dozen on tap) and to develop a cocktail menu with bartenders Justin Dickson and Sean Enright.
"As I got older, I knew that I wanted a more professional clientele, and food will do that," she said of Mr. Murphy's seasonal menu, which will have a focus on wild game. "I wanted to bring something completely new and unique to Pittsburgh."
The Inn Termission, which had been open since 1978 (before that it was the long-running Roxy's Cafe), became available after owner John Schwarzmeier died in 2011 and his wife, Patrice, decided to retire from the business. Although it was in need of some TLC, Ms. Salem was enamored of the handsome fixtures including a Victorian facade, slate floor, copper work above the bar, stained-glass windows and exposed wooden beams.
The motif is roughly a pre-Prohibition-era hunting lodge, replete with a custom-built fireplace in the room's center, taxidermy, and antiques curated by Mr. Alberter including photographs and ephemera ranging from an early 20th-century wedding certificate to an 1891 Harper's Weekly lithograph depicting "idle young men" loafing outside a liquor store, naturally. Tables are custom made from a craftsman in Latrobe. Flatware comes from Strip District potter Daniel Kuhn. Silverware are mismatched antiques.
Not exactly the dives she's accustomed to.
"It's a challenge, but it doesn't scare me. I'm so excited. I have no idea what my life will be like after this restaurant opens, but I'm ready for it," she said. "I love being in the social limelight and making my customers feel special. That's my story.“
munch@post-gazette.com or Twitter @ PGMunch. Become a Facebook Friend of Munch at www.facebook.com/munchPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.