Dear Eric: For the last 45 years or so I’ve hosted Thanksgiving for my family. I’ve had as many as 25 people. My sister has two sons, and they’ve always stayed with me. Quite frankly, it’s now an issue. Only one son comes but he now has three sons of his own, ranging from 22 to 8. My sister also stays with me. They come on Wednesday and stay till Friday. It’s a lot considering all I have to do for the holiday.
I know if I say something about a hotel, they will be highly insulted.
My daughter also comes and stays, but that’s different. She’s one person and my daughter. Advice?
— Overwhelmed
Dear Overwhelmed: I don’t want to sound flippant here, but if they’re insulted by you stating that you’re at capacity and can’t host six (maybe more) people, that’s on them. The solution is not to continue to bear the burden.
Special occasions, especially at holidays, often fall on one person’s shoulders – by default and by deflection. Often, it’s a woman, reflecting some family members’ assumptions that it’s her responsibility and she wants to do it. You may be or have been happy to host, and you can also be worn out from hosting now. Both can be true, and your family can and should hear that.
It's not too late to talk to your nephew and your sister and say that, after 45 years, Thanksgiving is outpacing you and you need the family to take a greater role in making it happen. It’s important that the work you’re doing not go unseen. Holidays don’t just happen. By saying, “this is a lot of work; can you help me host it?” you offer your family the chance to step up, which can enrich their experience of the holiday. If they state that it just won’t be the same if they’re not staying with you, then ask them how they can make the experience of hosting easier on you. Maybe that means taking on some more meal preparation, or hiring a cleaning service to come reset things, or shortening the trip. There are a lot of possibilities, and they should be the ones coming up with them and presenting them to you. It’s not your responsibility to make this work. You’re already making it work. It’s their responsibility to make it work for you, too.
Dear Eric: I have been recently looking over my canceled checks and realizing how many are the result of personal requests from friends and family to support runs, walks, book fairs, swims, and also favorite charities via obituaries that state "no flowers.”
Now, in more and more cases, I have received nothing from the family. I feel they are asking for a donation to a charity or organization of their choice, not one I am interested in. This leaves less for me to donate to organizations that I support.
Is there any way to politely ask a family member if they were notified that I donated to the charity of their choice?
I am doing this because I want the family to know I cared for their loved one and want them to know I am thinking of them. A pre-printed thank you, phone call, or email would be OK; I know this is a sad and stressful time.
I have often sent food via a reputable company such as Harry & David and also noted in a sympathy card a specific charity when the obituary just says something like "donations to the local food bank,” I've included the name of the local food bank I supported. Ideas and suggestions appreciated.
— Acknowledgements
Dear Acknowledgements: Your tactic of noting your donation in a card is a good start, probably the best start. When people ask for donations in lieu of flowers or other sentiments, it’s often done as a way of giving those who care an option for paying that care forward. If you’re concerned that the donation didn’t go through, of course you can always ask. But sometimes it’s best to just let a kindness be a kindness. The thought is what counts.
I often write that thank you notes are not a lost art. Acknowledgement is more than a courtesy. However, as you mentioned, this particular social grace can sometimes get lost in the tumult of grief and post-death duties. Best to not take it personally.
If you’re feeling overextended with donations, for fundraisers and bereavements, make a budget for those expenses. If you spend through that budget, just send a card – whether it’s one of encouragement for a fun run or sympathy. Or even a text, in the case of some fundraisers. This budget would allow you to devote more money to the charities that are closest to your heart.
Dear Eric: Nearly three years ago, I let my sister know my husband had been diagnosed with Alzheimer's. For reasons I don't understand, she cut off contact with us other than an occasional text. I was heartbroken and begged her to explain what I had done so I could properly apologize.
Before that we had had weekly hour-long phone calls.
I begged her in a series of letters to forgive me and give me another chance. Her response was to send me a series of criticisms via text, saying I was a bully and given to making cutting remarks. I had no idea what she was referring to and asked for examples. She could not come up with anything but advised me to cultivate friendships in my own town.
Almost two years later, I finally received a letter from her asking for forgiveness for hurting me. She still never explained what I had done, but of course I rushed to write that no forgiveness was needed, and I would be grateful to resume contact. By the way, our mother had Alzheimer’s, so I speculate that having contact with us is a painful reminder of that history. Maybe? We are both in our 70s.
Since then, she has emailed me occasionally, never more than once a week or every other week. I have not had the courage to ask again to resume our calls, remembering how devastated I was at her previous rejection.
I am sad that our relationship is a shadow of what it once was. Yet I don't know how to change anything. Asking for more feels very risky. What should I do, Eric?
— Missing My Sister
Dear Sister: You extended her a lot of grace by forgiving her. It’s preferable that apologies come with an acknowledgment of harm done and a commitment to make right what can be made right. I don’t know that she made that commitment and now you’re suffering for it, again.
Take the risk and ask for what you want. But do it with the knowledge that she may not be capable of giving you what you really want — a healthy connection, free from cruelty. I understand that, as your sister, you want her in your life. But it will be healthy for you to set up emotional boundaries to keep yourself safe.
You are worthy of more than crumbs from this relationship. You’re not responsible for what she thinks. If she has a grievance with you, she can bring it up. But, as you related, she wasn’t able to come up with one. Right now, it seems as if you’re being punished for something that, possibly, only exists in her mind. If you got something out of the weekly phone calls, proceed with caution. But make sure you’re also checking in with people who love you in the way that you deserve to be loved.
Send questions to R. Eric Thomas at eric@askingeric.com or P.O. Box 22474, Philadelphia, PA 19110. Follow him on Instagram and sign up for his weekly newsletter at rericthomas.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.