Tattoo shops, with traditional American-style tattoo drawings covering the walls, constant buzzing and heavy metal music, embody an unforgettable experience that can be transformational for some people — and a regret for others.
Alex Rogers, a longtime West Deer resident who got his first tattoo when he was in his early 20s, uses the term “clinical intimacy” to describe the experience of getting a tattoo — the physical closeness to another person while your body undergoes a change you chose for yourself.
“I am actively being transformed. I am being altered in a way that I want,” he said.
He got his first tattoo around 2017 from an artist at Ravenwood Collective in Lawrenceville, an establishment that’s now closed.
“I had a vague sense of an image in my mind of what I wanted, and like any good academic, I decided, ‘Let’s look around. Let’s do some research. Find what you think strikes a chord with you,’” Rogers said.
What he didn't know at the time was that no state or county laws protected him or the artist.
Currently, in Pennsylvania, the only regulation or law regarding tattooing is that it is illegal to tattoo anyone under the age of 18 without parental consent. Pennsylvania is one of the few states that don’t have any laws beyond an age requirement.
While Philadelphia, Erie and some other counties have detailed regulations, Allegheny County does not. But local tattoo artists say it is a self-regulating industry with its own social checks and balances.
“There is a shared responsibility — [even] in this lawless state,” said Jess Scutella, a tattoo artist at Kyklops Tattoo in the South Side Flats.
Consumers must do their research when choosing a tattoo shop. But in recent years, there has been at least one proposal for regulation.
In 2023, state Rep. Abby Major, who represents parts of Armstrong and Westmoreland counties, proposed the Tattoo Practice Act.
The Leechburg Republican’s goal was to allow prospective customers “the ability to see that an artist is licensed, knows correct and sterile procedures and help them choose one that is licensed and regulated,” Major said in an interview with WJAC-TV in Johnstown.
Though the bill died in committee, the question remains: Can the tattoo industry truly monitor itself?
Getting ink
Long gone is the era of tattoo shops with beige tile, dim lighting and ancient black leather couches, where you sit and pick your tattoo from a suspiciously sticky black book.
For just $37.99, an Amazon Prime membership, and a course at YouTube University, anyone can open a tattooing business.
Now, in sleek shops with fake plants and mid-century modern abstract art, bright-eyed newcomers can put needle to skin with limited experience. Some started their careers doing micro tattoos out of a bedroom in their apartments.
The tattoo industry relies on apprenticeships to pass down skills and traditions. However, proper training, with years under an experienced artist, is becoming less common due in part to the increased ease of obtaining supplies, according to local tattoo artists.
Kelly Smith, owner of Rogue Tattoo in Lawrenceville, has worked as a tattoo artist of 11 years. Looking like an inked-up Ms. Frizzle with themed dresses and a bright smile, Smith is covered from neck to toe in tattoos of various styles and colors.
“I think apprenticeships are something that were once valued at a high standard,” Smith said. “The problem is with younger people who just didn't do that.… They don't have anyone to tell them about the history.”
“There is no formal way of sharing that,” said Scutella. “It was handed down information, you know? I went through an apprenticeship, and it was passed on to me in that way.”
Scutella has been tattooing for 11 years and specializes in Americana tattoos and Japanese Irezumi, a style characterized by full-body designs.
“There's no school because there's no firm definition of what an apprenticeship is,” Scutella said.
Cash-grabs posing as tattoo schools, training programs and multi-level marketing schemes tarnish the legitimacy of structured education for aspiring artists, according to Scutella.
Smith said that some apprenticeships are a combination of cleaning and doing “all the [expletive] work, basically.” Some are like “Hey, give me, like, 3 grand.”
Scutella learned from a former Navy cook turned graffiti artist. “My teacher forced me to learn about the hundreds and thousands of years of history.”
But tattooing isn't like, say, the publishing industry. You can't give someone hepatitis B via a poorly written mystery novel.
Bonnie Ramone, a tattoo artist of 15 years, co-owns The Kindred Spirit Tattoo Co. in Bloomfield with Kristin Hawk, who has been tattooing for nine years. Like a gothic Dolly Parton, Ramone sports dramatic makeup accentuating angular features and jet black hair that stands 6 inches off her head.
There used to be a wall that tattoo artists had to climb to become professionals, Ramone said. There were gatekeepers prohibiting just anyone from becoming a tattoo artist.
Before disposable products were available, one of those hurdles to opening a shop was the cost of equipment, which included an autoclave. It’s a machine that uses heat and pressure to sterilize equipment and is most commonly used in medical facilities. Its cost, depending on the size, can be $2,000-$50,000 or more.
According to Ramone, reputable suppliers would sell only to business owners who had a tattoo license or other proof or experience.
But now Amazon and other online sellers offer supplies without verifying the skill or legitimacy of the tattooer or shop. Coupled with high demand after the COVID-19 pandemic, the market was flooded with inexperienced tattoo artists using disposable supplies.
“I know people who opened their own shop, with no experience, and charge the same as those with years of experience,” said Madeline Nicowski, a tattooer at the South Side’s Godspeed Tattoo and Body Piercing.
“There was all this money with nowhere to go,” Ramone said. “People would just go teach themselves at home, then start tattooing friends and open their own business out of their house.”
‘Don’t worry’
Rogers, who has gotten tattoos from different artists over the years but now relies only on Ramone, recalls one particularly memorable experience from an early session.
“We were probably an hour and a half into the session, and my blood sugar tanks,” he said. “That's not a sensation I'm used to, so I was kind of alarmed. But my artist at the time was wonderful, and you know, she was like ‘I know what's happening. Don't worry.’”
Experienced tattoo artists know the inherent risks and best practices to prevent skin infections and other health issues.
Tattooing works by using any number of needles to repeatedly puncture the skin and deposit pigment in the dermis layer (the second layer of the skin), making a permanent design.
Blood-borne illnesses can be readily spread through tattooing, including HPV and HSV, hepatitis B and C, a staph infection, syphilis, HIV and others. There can also be allergic reactions to the pigmentation and other unexpected consequences.
“If this were a ‘sterile’ operation, you would have had to scrub in and scrub out,” Ramone said.
She said that clients often assume that the environments where they can get a tattoo have to be sterile, but they really need to be free from harmful bacteria, viruses or other microorganisms.
“Once you touch anything, your gloves are dirty,” said Jason Angst, a tattoo artist and owner of Artisan Tattoo in Garfield.
Ramone characterizes tattooing as half medical procedure and half art form.
One way tattoo artists are trained to prevent the spread of disease is by obtaining a blood-borne pathogen certification. The certification demonstrates their knowledge of how to prevent, recognize and respond to exposure to infectious microorganisms found in human blood, including HIV and hepatitis B and C.
The certification doesn't cost much, and is offered by a plethora of online companies and organizations that includes National CPR Foundation, American Red Cross or the Pennsylvania Bloodborne Pathogens Training Class.
Using new needles, wearing gloves, using a chemical disinfectant, wrapping or cleaning any non-porous surface that is going to be used, and many other practices are integral to preventing infection.
“People need to know that they can ask about these things,” said Scutella. “They have a right to know this place is committed to knowing about how literal diseases are transferred.”
One way that shops and artists ensure that everyone involved understands the procedure and potential risk is by using a consent form.
“It’s helpful both ways,” said Smith. “It lets us know if you have any health concerns that we need to be aware of what medications you might be on, if you are diabetic, how well your diabetes is maintained, things like that.”
Beyond diabetes, many factors can affect tattoo healing, including pregnancy and skin conditions like keratosis pilaris.
“If there's no exchange of information between the consumer and the shop. I mean, there's no accountability in that way, then,” Scutella said.
“Ask questions and, if they don’t like it, be scared,” said Nicowski.
‘Literally under their skin’
About 41% of adults under 30 have a tattoo, according to the 2023 survey by Pew Research Center. Now more than ever, consumers need to pay attention to who they are allowing to tattoo them.
“[At] the end of the day, this is a service industry and we're meant to take care of people at a time when we're literally under their skin,” Ramone said. “It’s a very intimate act.”
“Finding your doctor, finding your therapist is like finding your tattoo artist,” Namie Bey, owner of Diiviinetime in Mount Oliver, said. “ I recommend going to different tattoo shops. Check how long they have been tattooing."
Reputation and references fuel the industry, but experienced tattoo artists warn against doing the research solely by Instagram and TikTok or noting the number of artists’ social media followers.
“Social media is just not reality,” Angst said. “We could go on Instagram right now, and I can show you [that] well over half of the tattoos that are being promoted are Photoshopped.”
“A portfolio should have healed work,” Scutella said. “There are entire styles right now that don't look good when they're healed.... They are tattooing for the photograph, or tattooing for the post, versus tattooing for the longevity of the tattoo.”
“Research, research, research,” Smith said. “If you can go visit [the shop], fantastic. If the shop is willing to show you around, even better.”
“Ask to see their space, ask to see their studio or … the setting in which you’re getting tattooed,” Rogers said. “ You’re not going to go see a brand-new doctor … and [they’re] like, ‘Oh yeah’ it’s set up in my basement.”
“Trust your local community, trust people who have worked with the artists before,” Angst said. “They'll let you know if somebody is screwing up, if somebody's cutting corners and being weird.”
“The regret factor is one worth investing to eliminate,” said Rogers.
Correction, posted Oct. 2, 2025: This story has been updated to correct Jess Scutella’s pronouns, which are they/them.
Correction, posted Sept. 12, 2025: An earlier version of this story misspelled the name of Kristin Hawk, co-owner of The Kindred Spirit Tattoo Co. in Bloomfield.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.