A professional football player’s recent video message announcing to the public that he is gay has generated a range of emotions within the region’s LGBTQ community, but one word used to describe the moment is this: progress.
That’s how Kenneth McDowell, the CEO and founder of the PGH LGBTQ+ Coalition puts it.
“We have to keep pushing the envelope,” Mr. McDowell said. “For so long sports haven’t been friendly for LGBTQIA individuals. The needle moves every year.”
Mr. McDowell was among those reacting to an Instagram video released Monday by Carl Nassib, a Las Vegas Raiders defensive end. In the video, taken outside Mr. Nassib’s home in West Chester, Pa., the former Penn State player said, “I’ve been meaning to do this for a while now, but I finally feel comfortable enough to get it off my chest.”
Leaders at local LGBTQ organizations say Mr. Nassib’s video will benefit not just gay athletes but the LGBTQ community in general.
“With athletes coming out, it can really help combat that hatred that’s happening with all of these trans bills against kids,” said Dena Stanley, founder and organizer of the Pittsburgh Pride Group and executive director of TransYOUniting, a nonprofit that provides resources to the Pittsburgh trans community.
Read More
“It’s amazing when any public figure, such as [Mr. Nassib], just comes out and is living in his truth because there are a lot of people, a lot of children, a lot of folks who see this and get the courage to live in their truth as well,” Ms. Stanley said.
Kerry Long, deputy executive director of Stonewall Alliance, said she thinks it’s “refreshing to see a white male come out, who has such an important job and an important role and is such a public figure. It's a great step for us in the community.”
She also said she believed growing up in sports must have been hard for Mr. Nassib due to the machismo associated with the sport.
“I can only imagine being a young gay player in that environment,” Ms. Long said. “Coming up in West Chester, Pa., which is kind of a rural area, and going to Penn State, which is kind of a rural college, it had to be incredibly difficult for him growing up to have this secret that he may have kept for a while, and gratefully and luckily he did have those resources in his family, his friends, his coaches to go to.”
______________
View this post on Instagram
______________
In the video, Mr. Nassib said the coming-out process shouldn’t need to be an issue.
“I think that representation and visibility are so important,” he said. “I actually hope that one day, videos like this and the whole coming-out process are just not necessary. But until then, I’m going to do my best and do my part to cultivate a culture that’s accepting, that’s compassionate.”
Ms. Stanley called Mr. Nassib’s announcement “awesome” because “we do need more folks out, loud and proud in spaces such as that.”
“But just as much as representation matters, language matters as well,” Ms. Stanley said on how Mr. Nassib is being portrayed by the media. “It’s like there’s erasure of the folks that came before him where he was able to feel comfortable coming out. Where he will be celebrated, there were folks before him, such as Michael [Sam], who weren’t even tolerated at all and there were plenty of folks before him as well. ... It just goes back to white supremacy in a sense and how privilege works.”
Defensive end Michael Sam came out after his college football career and became the first publicly gay player to be drafted by the NFL when he was selected by the St. Louis Rams in 2014. But he was let go in the preseason, which makes Mr. Nassib the first active NFL player to publicly come out as gay.
Andrew Twigg, president of the Steel City Volleyball League, an LGBTQIA+ organization founded in 1982, pointed out how despite Mr. Nassib’s coming out, greater strides still need to be made in the NFL and athletics in terms of inclusivity.
"Visibility is important, but we need diversity within that visibility," Mr. Twigg said. "[Nassib's announcement] is a big deal, but it's not the be-all-end-all."
"Those who don’t present in line with gender stereotypes don't have this privilege,” Mr. Twigg said of Mr. Nassib being able to choose when to come out.
Those who do not have the same privilege “paved the way for him, but this story is about him."
Seeing a Pennsylvania native come out on such a public stage “means the world” to young people, Mr. McDowell said.
“To see people live normal lives and be so successful step into a world finally as their authentic self is important and amazing to witness,” Mr. McDowell said. “Youth or even some older folks may themselves be inspired by his actions.”
According to Dr. Gerald Montano, assistant professor of pediatrics and medical director of the Gender and Sexual Development Program at UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh, young people often struggle with their identity. Dr. Montano said they saw around 400 to 500 patients from the southwestern Pennsylvania, eastern Ohio and West Virginia areas who came to them needing help over their gender identity and/or sexual orientation in 2019.
LGBTQ youths also experience higher rates of mental health problems compared to their non-LGBTQ peers, according to Dr. Montano.
“For example, lesbian, gay and bisexual youth are three times as likely compared to their straight peers to engage in substance use to deal with the stress from stigma and discrimination, and about 50% of transgender youth have thought about suicide because of the stress they experience from stigma and discrimination and from the stress of their bodies not matching their gender identity,” Dr. Montano explained.
Mr. Nassib’s coming out also happens during a time where transgender athletes are caught in legal and legislative debates. This past April, a group of Pennsylvania Republican representatives introduced a bill that would ban transgender females from participating in all-girls high school or college sports teams. The same month, the West Virginia Senate nearly passed a bill that would have banned transgender females from competing in female sports in middle and high schools and colleges.
To Mr. McDowell, Mr. Nassib coming out during Pride Month “makes it all that much better.”
“This month is a celebration for those we’ve lost and also those yet to come,” Mr. McDowell said. “This battle isn’t over, and I’m sure that Carl will give back to our community.”
In his Instagram post, Mr. Nassib pledged to donate $100,000 to The Trevor Project, a nonprofit which provides suicide prevention services among LGBTQ youth.
“For someone like me, who has been so lucky and cherishes every day, it brings me incredible sadness to think that our LGBTQ youth are at such an elevated risk for suicide,” Mr. Nassib wrote online. “I feel an immense responsibility to help in any way I can — and you can too. Studies have shown that all it takes is one accepting adult to decrease the risk of an LGBTQ kid attempting suicide. Whether you’re a friend, a parent, a coach or a teammate — you can be that person.”
Many in the LGBTQ community imagine a bleak future for themselves because they have heard so many stories of the struggles of people like themselves, Dr. Montano said. Seeing a public figure such as Mr. Nassib come out as gay and donate to The Trevor Project “challenges the belief that LGBTQ people cannot have happy and productive lives and fills them with hope. Although it is heartening to see more and more athletes come out as gay, lesbian or bisexual, our transgender athletes are still lacking.”
And while Mr. Nassib, as a white, cisgender, gay male, may not be an inspiration for trans youth or lesbian/bisexual girls or LGBTQ+ people of color, representation matters, according to Dr. Montano.
“It is with hope that Carl Nassib’s coming out might inspire other athletes within the LGBTQ spectrum to come out as well,” Dr. Montano said.
Hannah Wyman: hwyman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1255



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.