For as long as she can remember, Sandra Kozera’s family has held a Christmas Eve party, as relatives and friends come and go from church services and feast on meatballs and cookies.

This year, the party will feature something new: menorahs with candles ablaze, thanks to family friend and regular party attendee Elizabeth Collura, who is Jewish.

“We’ll be bringing our menorahs, bringing presents,” said Ms. Collura of Mount Washington. “We’ll basically be doing Hanukkah at the Christmas Eve party.”

Dec. 24 marks the first time in 38 years that the first night of Hanukkah will fall on Christmas Eve. It will only be the fourth time since 1902 for this particular coincidence of the calendar. The next overlap will be in 2027, and then after that, in 2073.

Advertise with us

Hanukkah lasts eight days — to commemorate a jar of oil that seemed only enough to burn for one night, but lasted for eight — but the first night is often the most important, said Alex Greenbaum, rabbi at Beth El Congregation in Mt. Lebanon.

The first night includes an extra prayer, he said, and many families give the biggest gift on the first night. “By night No. 8, you are lucky to remember lighting the menorah,” he laughed. “Your children are lucky to get socks.”

There are at least 600,000 children in the United States who are being raised with some degree of Judaism and also in another religion, according to a 2013 “Portrait of Jewish Americans” report from the Pew Research Center. That study also found that 44 percent of its married Jewish respondents were married to a non-Jew.

Ms. Collura is one of those. Her husband, Mike, was raised Catholic, and while they are primarily raising their 6-year-old daughter, Rachel, to be Jewish, she participates in Christmas every year at her grandfather’s house.

Handling both religions is a topic that the Colluras, who are co-chairs of an interfaith group at Temple Sinai in Squirrel Hill, have figured out over time.

Advertise with us

Because of the “extraordinary” intermarriage rates, it’s a subject that Rabbi Greenbaum often gives advice on in his congregation. “I support the Christmas tree ... if you talk to 10 rabbis, you might find nine that disagree, but I not only support it, I encourage my interfaith families to respect both religions,” he said. “When I deal with an interfaith marriage, I believe you’re not rejecting one religion, you’re enhancing both.”

The sometimes tricky intersection of Christmas and Hanukkah — dubbed “Christmukkah” in a 2003 episode of the television show “The O.C.,” has been a recent favorite of merchandisers, who are not shy about trying to capitalize on those celebrating both holidays.

The company Modern Tribe offers a $32 ugly Christmukkah sweater, a button-down cardigan with a menorah and dreidel on one side and bows of holly on the other. My Tree Topper, featured on “Shark Tank,” sells a currently sold-out Star of David to top a Christmas tree, and YamaClaus sells a red plush yarmulke with a Santa-like white puffball on it.

That swag will likely not be in effect at Ms. Kozera’s house in Ross when they gather for the Christmas Eve/​Hanukkah celebration — the first time that most of her older relatives will see a menorah being lit.

“This will be sort of an event,” she said. “It’s the first opportunity we’re going to have to do it. I’m very excited.”

Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1308.