Not everybody likes Facebook's new universal "Like" button.
The so-called "open graph" platform that the social networking site launched last week gathers data about Facebook users and their preferences when they're on websites that participate in the new feature.
One critic who particularly doesn't like this feature is U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y. He has asked the Federal Trade Commission to establish guidelines for how social networking sites such as Facebook, Twitter and others can share such information. He blasted Facebook for selling its users' private information to marketing companies.
In his letter to the FTC, Mr. Schumer wrote that Facebook's changes "have limited the ability of users to control the information they share and keep private. ... Currently, there is little guidance on what social networking sites can and cannot do and how disclosure is provided."
But some don't see government regulation as the solution. As a reader, Thomas of Clairton put it in a e-mail: "I don't think our government should step in and make guidelines. People need to held responsible for their actions. ... Buyer beware."
Facebook users for some time have been able to hit a Facebook "like" button to tell everyone in their friend network about a song, band, book, movie, product -- or anything they enjoy and want to share.
Now with the new feature they don't even have to be on Facebook to do that. Facebook members can find a Facebook "like" button on partner sites, and that information will post on their Facebook update automatically. That information in turn can go to third parties, such as advertisers trying to create targeted ads.
Pandora, the Internet music service, is one of the initial partner sites that has signed on to this feature. Here's how it works: If you create a Pandora playlist based on your favorite bands, that information could be shared with concert sites that will inform you when they're coming to town. And information gathered from other music sites about your musical tastes could be automatically incorporated into your Pandora playlists.
The new Facebook features are designed to enhance the personalized Web experience and promote social networking activities on the Web. "The power of the open graph is that it helps to create a smarter, personalized Web that gets better with every action taken," Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg wrote on the Facebook company blog.
It's a shortcut and convenience that will appeal to some users, but not all. Facebook users can opt out of the Instant Personalization feature, but it's time-consuming and requires several steps.
There are several ways to opt out -- either through the partner site or through Facebook itself.
Visitors to sites using the Facebook social plug-in will see a bar telling them that it's "using Facebook to personalize your experience." There's a "No thanks" link to opt out. This way, the user has to opt out manually for each Facebook partner site he or she lands on.
On Facebook itself, users can go to the privacy settings section and choose "Applications and websites." The last entry -- Instant Personalization -- has a command that disables the feature.
However, one's Facebook friends who don't opt out can still share information about you. There's a way to disable that, too: Go to the "What Your friends can share about you" in the "Applications and websites" link and go through the options there -- personal info, photos, videos, relationship status, etc.
But opting out isn't enough for critics like Mr. Schumer, who believes there should be an "opt-in" option instead for people who want to let their personal information be used.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation also criticized the new Facebook policies. "Once upon a time, Facebook could be used simply to share your interests and information with a select small community of your own choosing. ... How times have changed," wrote foundation senior staff attorney Kurt Opsahl on the organization's website. "Today, Facebook removed its users' ability to control who can see their own interests and personal information. ... Facebook users would be better off and better able to express themselves if they could choose whether or not to link their interests and activities to a community, if they decide to list them."
Specific data about users' interests as well as their ages and other demographic information is a gold mine for advertisers, and Facebook, which now has 400 million users, is in a position to profit from that information.
"They want to know what their members are doing outside of Facebook so they can target content and advertising to that specific individual. They know what you're doing within Facebook -- who you're chatting with most often, what groups you've joined," said Michael Hussey, founder and CEO of PeekYou, a people search engine that gathers information on people and organizes it much as Google does with websites. By gathering user information -- say from someone who spends a lot of time on hockey or football sites -- Facebook can create tailored lists of special interest groups.
"If they can capture that information and you're willing to submit that from outside of the Facebook network. ... To tie all of your online activities into one space can be pretty powerful. Everyone wants this sort of data," Mr. Hussey said.
"For it to be successful and trusted, they need to be open and honest and transparent," he said. "What do you know about me and how is it being used, and how does it improve my Facebook experience?"




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.