When it comes to selecting Thanksgiving wines, I have a mantra. It has never varied from the first time I wrote this annual holiday column: Thanksgiving menus cover so many taste profiles that it is not hard to choose a wine that is a good pairing for something on your menu. So you should follow your taste preferences and go with a wine that best suits your palate. Just remember a few pairing rules. These simple suggestions are modified from an article Ray Isles wrote for Food & Wine magazine a few years ago.
• Choose a high-acidity white to go with anything you would squeeze a lemon on. For example, Sauvignon Blanc or Spanish Albarino or French Chablis with crab or shrimp cocktail.
• Choose low-alcohol wines with sweet or spicy dishes. Example, Riesling or Gewurztraminer with Asian or Latin dishes.
• Choose tannic, full-bodied reds with rich meats or poultry such as turkey. Example, Cabernet Sauvignon, Syrah, Zinfandel or Malbec with Thanksgiving turkey.
• With sweet desserts, choose wine with a hefty dose of residual sugar, such as Port, Madeira, Moscato or semi-dry Champagne or sparkling white.
To that list I add what seems to me the most important rule of all. For this purely American holiday, it seems to me, only American wine should be served.
With all of this in mind I have made a list of what I think would be acceptable choices for most dinner tables. If you do not shop in luxury wine stores (the big ones with larger inventory), then I suggest that you look for wines with only four numbers in the code. Those with five numbers are only available at luxury stores.
Sparkling wine is not just a lovely way to begin a festive meal, but it also can be enjoyed throughout the meal. There are two American sparklers currently in our stores which are big favorites of mine. They hail from New Mexico and have an interesting pedigree. The Gruet family is French, originally from the Champagne region, where they made sparkling wine. In 1983, on a trip to the United States, Gilbert Gruet discovered vines growing in Southern New Mexico at 4,300 feet altitude and decided to buy land and plant grapes. The first sparkling wine went on the market in 1989 and was an instant success. These wines have spent 24 months on tirage (in the bottle undergoing second fermentation) in the traditional Methode champenoise that produces tiny and pervasive bubbles.
• Gruet Brut, Sparkling White, NV, New Mexico PLCB No. 29250, $16.99
Spicy tropical fruits and juicy green apples on the nose. A Wine Spectator Best Buy.
• Gruet Rose, Sparkling Rose, NV, New Mexico PLCB No. 39937, $17.99
• Chateau Ste. Michelle Riesling, 2013, Cold Creek Vineyard, Columbia Valley, Wash. PLCB No. 38567, $17.99
A bright and racy Riesling made from fruit grown on 30-year-old vines. Offers aromas of ripe peaches and dried apricots wrapped around a spicy core. The wine has great acidity and a long and bright finish.
• Apothic White, NV, California PLCB No. 5061, $9.99
A blend of Chardonnay, Pinot Grigio and Riesling grapes. This is a well-balanced affordable white with fruity aromas and nice mouthfeel.
• Flora Springs Chardonnay, 2012, Napa, Calif. PLCB No. 33510, $12.99
This wine is on the Chairman’s Selection list and well priced. It exhibits aromas of spice, peach, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg and Granny Smith apples making it work well with a number of Thanksgiving menu items.
• Eberle Muscat Canelli, 2013, Paso Robles, Calif. PLCB No. 33479, $9.99
This is a great combination of sweet and acid that makes a wonderful dessert wine and will be perfect with pumpkin- or apple pie and other desserts. It is unoaked with aromas of peach, pineapple, orange and mango. The fact that winemaker Gary Eberle is a Pittsburgh boy who was a star on the Penn State football team adds some extra pizzazz to an already great wine.
• Kimmel Four Block Merlot, 2012, Mendocino County, Calif. PLCB No. 33478, $12.99
Although primarily Merlot, (92 percent) this wine is fleshed out with small amounts of Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc, Malbec and Petit Verdot. The color is deep, dark cherry-red and the aromas cover a wide spectrum from cranberries to red fruits and dark chocolate. In the mouth, ripe plums predominate.
• Renwood Reserve Zinfandel 2010, Dry Creek Valley, Calif. PLCB No. 33487, $14.99
The winemaker describes this wine as “rich garnet-red color with intense aromas reminiscent of toasted berry pie, with some tobacco leaf. The wine has a supple tannin structure with a rich texture. Flavors of Bing cherry pie, cranberries, tobacco leaf with hints of toasted oak.”
• RVTZ Maison Grand Cru Syrah, 2013, Russian River, Sonoma, Calif. PLCB No. 33455, $12.99
Bursting with aromas of dried berries, pomegranate, cedar and licorice, this will marry well with turkey and dressing.
• Liberty School Cabernet Sauvignon, 2012, Paso Robles, Calif. PLCB No. 3246, $13.99
Long recognized as a great entry-level cab, this wine is light in body but with all the typical Cabernet Sauvignon aromas and tastes.
• Roots Run Deep Educated Guess Cabernet Sauvignon, 2012, Napa Valley, Calif. PLCB No. 48843, $19.99
A classic Cab packed with ripe blackberries and cassis and dark cherry. I discovered this wine through my pal Dr. Bob Arffa, who sends out a monthly newsletter with wonderful reviews of wines available in PLCB markets. This one is a winner (as in fact are all his recommendations).
You also could take a trip to your local PLCB shop, stroll the aisles and make your own picks.
And have a blessed Thanksgiving with your loved ones.
Elizabeth Downer: elizabethdowner@gmail.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.