After a five-year search finally turned up her dream house, Sarah Rose thought she had lost it.

Built in 1872, the house on the Mexican War Streets had checked all the boxes and was suddenly under contract.

She couldn’t resist one more look with her husband, Matt Naeger. They saw the buyers walking out with a real estate agent and she rolled down her window.

“You just bought our dream house!” Rose hollered.

Advertise with us

Except they didn’t.

The deal fell through, and Howard Hanna Real Estate agent Karl Owens was pretty sure he recognized the woman’s face in the car.

He called Rose and, in August 2021, she and Naeger bought the three-story North Side house with a staid brick facade that hides a new rooftop deck and outdoor kitchen.

It’s one of 13 stops Sept. 17 on the 51st annual Mexican War Streets House & Garden Tour, which runs from 11 a.m.-5 p.m. Tickets are $30 each in advance at mexicanwarstreets.org. No tickets will be sold on the day of the tour.

Though they bought the house two years ago, the couple only moved in recently. Blame pandemic supply issues and the difficulty and expense of transforming the upper two floors and back patio of a 151-year-old row house into “an adult playground space.”

Advertise with us

With four of their five children in college or on their own, Rose calls this their “second life.” And it looks like a pretty nice one.

The outdoor kitchen was built inside a three-car garage with doors opening to two alleys. A new cutout in the brick wall created a serving counter for the dining table where they often eat dinner.

A gas grill stands on the new stamped-concrete patio and a pizza oven is on order. An old barn door and locker room bench, both purchased at an Iowa auction, add character.

“I love auctions,” said Rose, a military brat who has lived in many places. “I’ve been carrying around this door for 20 years.”

Naeger, a Ligonier native, has his home office in a new third-floor space that easily transitions into a guest bedroom. Steps away is the 12- by 10-foot rooftop deck that offers a glimpse of the Downtown skyline and fireworks on the North Shore.

Advertise with us

“I will take my laptop and work out here if it’s mostly sunny,” he said.

This was the second rooftop deck I’ve seen on a North Side house tour in a month, and it’s a pretty impressive amenity. But it’s not an easy add.

Pittsburgh now requires supporting steel beams that run through the walls to the ground. They’re visible in one of the walls of their youngest son’s bedroom and in the dining room, near the new mini-bar that replaced an awkward closet.

Architect John Francona, who lives nearby, also designed a new master suite on the second floor.

In addition to an exposed brick wall, the bedroom features light-up nightstands with built-in wireless chargers, ceiling anchors for aerial yoga and a “fandelier” with spinning blades that tuck out of sight when the fan is turned off. Everything, including the washer and dryer in the walk-in closet, can be controlled by a smartphone.

Advertise with us

“We wanted to bring some technology into the history,” Rose said.

The house’s history is most evident on the first floor, which has 14-foot ceilings, indoor shutters, more exposed brick and original wide-plank pine floors. One of three original fireplaces still burns wood and has inlaid marble in the mantel.

The walls feature many pieces by local artists, family and friends, including their youngest son and Rose’s grandmother in Columbus, Ohio.

She and Naeger have made a clean break from the suburban existence they shared with their children in Robinson for 10 years.

“This is where we want to spend the rest of our lives,” Rose said.

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com.