Moira Harrington never wanted to be a restaurateur. She was a lawyer and former city magistrate when her brother, Kelly, died unexpectedly in 2009. Her mother, Trese, asked her and her sister, Michele, who goes by “Mike,” to help her run Tessaro’s in Bloomfield.
“I used to come in for social visits,” she said. “My brother said a restaurant is hard work. I thought he was exaggerating. He wasn’t exaggerating.”
The Irish-American sisters could have simply done their familial duty and assisted their 85-year-old mother. Instead, the restaurant with an Italian name in an Italian neighborhood but no Italian food has thrived and grown. Since a major expansion and renovation that was completed last year, there’s even more room for regulars who relish their huge hamburgers and other fare. The restaurant’s maximum occupancy grew from 70 to 99 and that doesn’t count the new outdoor patio.
Earlier this year, Tessaro’s was a finalist in the PG’s 2015-16 Renovation Inspiration Contest, commercial division, for carefully combining three storefronts without sacrificing the atmosphere of the restaurant their brother bought in 1985. Entries are now being accepted at http://biz.post-gazette.com/renovationcontest/ for the 2016-17 contest, which honors well-done renovations of homes and businesses in buildings at least 25 years old.
The Tessaro’s project works at many levels, but the most important is this: It feels like it’s been this way forever.
The oldest of the three buildings, 4601 Liberty, went up in 1892 and sold dry goods. After prohibition ended in 1933, it became a tavern and was a “shot and a beer” bar when Richard Tessaro opened his restaurant in 1981. When Mr. Harrington bought it four years later, he kept its name and character, including an original tin ceiling, long wood bar and red-and-black checkerboard linoleum floor.
In 1995, he purchased the adjacent storefront and created more dining space. With an assist from his mother and her friend, Maryanne Sever, portrait artist Hathaway Morton painted a series of murals depicting Harrington family members and longtime employees. Four of them still work at Tessaro’s today, one for 18 years and the three others for 28-29 years. Moira Harrington said her mother and brother appear at least six times each in the murals.
“She’s in almost every single panel,” she said, laughing.
Mr. Harrington bought the third building, occupied by a vacuum shop, a few years later. But he was done with renovation.
“He swore he was never gonna tear down another brick wall,” Moira Harrington said.
Her mother felt the same way. After her husband and son died within three days of each other in May 2009, she was not receptive to her daughter’s suggestion that they turn the sweeper shop into a dining room.
“I said, ‘We should really do something with this. It’s a great space.’ She said, ‘Are you crazy?’ But my perseverance paid off,” Moira Harrington said.
In 2012, demolition began and in 2013, they hired Perfido Weiskopf Wagstaff + Goettel Architects. Alan Weiskopf, a customer for 30 years, took the lead on design of the patio, interior work and facade changes. He also guided them through the city approval and permit process, but he couldn’t help them find a contractor.
Mike Kelly of Aspen Valley Contracting was the only one unfazed by the tight quarters with no room for heavy equipment. Five other contractors couldn’t deal with the narrow access on Corde Way. All patio materials came through one wheelbarrow at a time – Azek permeable pavers, tons of gravel and sand, three small trees and 100 floor joists from an old warehouse that were used as fencing. John Walter of Iron Eden supplied the joists, new iron railings, the front sign and an antique gate salvaged from Dixmont State Hospital.
The patio opened in May 2015 and work began on the interior of the middle building and the old sweeper space, now known as the party room. It has a reproduction tin ceiling, hardwood floors and a display holding 1930s bottles and other items dug up during construction of the rear patio. Aspen Valley’s contractors did the noisy work before the restaurant opened each day and worked quietly through lunch and dinner. Heating-air conditioning installers did their noisy work after closing each night.
“We never closed,” Moira Harrington said proudly. “The contractors were very accommodating and our customers were very understanding.”
The interior work and party room were finished in late 2015 as the facade construction was getting started. The city’s architectural review board had to sign off on new signage, a raised sidewalk for handicap accessibility, 20 new Pella windows and cornices and other trim that, together with black and red paint, unify the three storefronts into one facade.
Three grants totaling $53,000 from the Urban Redevelopment Authority helped pay for the exterior changes and the work was done by Jendoco Construction. Bloomfield Development Corp. and Bloomfield Citizens Council were very supportive, Ms. Harrington said.
She thinks her brother and her mother, who passed away in May 2015, would be proud.
“It exceeded our expectations,” she said. “I never imagined it would be what it is.”
Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1978.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.