Brian Mendelssohn’s fingerprints are all over Lawrenceville, in commercial and residential projects both big and small.
The creative force behind the single-screen Row House Cinema and adjoining Atlas Bottle Works, which opened in 2014 on Butler Street, the Miami native also developed Cobble House Condos on 42nd Street and designed the historic Starr Lofts that sit atop Smoke BBQ Taqueria.
All beauties, to be sure, but his most arresting venture may be in the century-old building in which he makes his home: an ambitious redo of the Arsenal Bank building at 4300 Butler St. As grand as it is funky, the mixed-used project is an artistic marriage of old and new that not only celebrates the storied building’s past, but embodies the creative spirit Lawrenceville has come to be known for. Judges for this year’s 10th annual Renovation Inspiration Contest, sponsored by Dollar Bank and judged by staff members of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and Design Center, liked it so much that they came up with a special award -- Best in Show -- because it was so strong in both commercial and residential renovation.
The former is Tender Bar + Kitchen, a Prohibition-themed restaurant opened by Jeff Catalina in 2013. The latter is five lofts on the second and third floors, the largest of which was once a 2,000-square-foot ballroom used for entertaining bank clients, weddings and dance practice for the Tamburitzans.
In this brilliantly sunny, wide-open space, Mr. Catalina came up with the idea for Tender. After Mr. Mendelssohn’s company, Botero Development, purchased the building in 2011, they used its raw expanse for several dance parties to raise money for Bike Pittsburgh. When it seemed everyone in the neighborhood lined up for admission, the restaurateur started talking to Mr. Mendelssohn to hash out a plan for the 3,000-square-foot dining room and kitchen on the first floor and a private dining room in a former barber shop in the basement.
Constructed in 1884 for $17,000, the three-story building was in deplorable condition when Mr. Mendelssohn paid $350,000 for it five years ago. It had been empty for years and many of its windows had been boarded over. Renovation wouldn’t be easy, or pretty, as the plumbing and electric were sure to be a nightmare and the layout defied modern sensibilities. But Mr. Mendelssohn, who specializes in rehabbing old buildings, isn’t easily deterred. Especially when you’re talking about one of Lawrenceville’s landmark buildings.
“I had a naive confidence of, ‘Yeah, I can do this,’ ” he says with a laugh.
Paramount in the redesign was maintaining as much of the building’s history as possible while adding a modern twist and meeting 21st-century building codes. Moss Architects’ point-on design kept the 15-foot ceilings, saved original wood floors on the upper levels and reused the bank’s marble floors and wainscoting (check out the front of the 18-foot bar). They also preserved six empty, century-old safes. It took a locksmith two days to open them (one became a bathroom.)
The red brick facade was repointed, all the windows replaced and Mr. Mendelssohn added a new entrance and staircase to the side of the building to allow easier access to the apartments above. Since the bank was built on a slope, Mr. Mendelssohn had to lower the original floors about 4 feet to meet ADA requirements. The building’s historic corner entrance, which once overlooked the covered 43rd Street Bridge, also got a facelift.
One plus was the building’s strong foundation, which in the 1820s supported a church that was later moved across the street.
“It’s probably better than anything in the city,” says Mr. Mendelssohn.
Meant to evoke the speakeasy spirit of the Gatsby era, Tender features red-and-gold art nouveau-style wallpaper, a tin ceiling and a wall under the front window decoupaged with handwritten checks dating to the 1890s. They were discovered in the basement and serve to remind customers of the bank that survived the Depression only to be bought in 1943 by the People’s Pittsburgh Trust Co., predecessor of PNC Bank.
The lofts, completed four months after the restaurant, also speak to the past with a hip, urban tone.
Mr. Mendelssohn’s 950-square-foot apartment is a case study in old vs. new. The kitchen is a modern marvel, with IKEA cabinets, a bright-white subway tile backsplash and white Corian countertops. But there’s plenty of creative reuse, too. Hundreds of books are housed in open shelving crafted from old joists and metal bars, while the striped wooden wall behind his platform bed was made from salvaged black walnut and oak floorboards. The faux marble mantel also is quite old. Vintage maps and old photos of Allegheny City and Pennsylvania on the walls complement the colorful fabric artwork of Brooklyn artist Peter Burr, who was Mr. Mendelssohn’s roommate at Carnegie Mellon University, where he studied engineering and material science.
The two-bedroom apartment in the top floor’s former ballroom is spectacular thanks to its open floor plan and a dozen 12-foot windows that offer ”ridiculous views and perfect sunsets,” Mr. Mendelssohn says. An original wooden stage with risers snakes along the front wall, providing an elevated platform for plants, artwork and furniture. The black-and-maroon linoleum floor — across which bank clients might have foxtrotted — is original.
“It’s almost identical to what it once was,” he says.
To maintain the feeling of openness but still afford privacy, the interior walls stop short of the ceiling. A small kitchen with cream-colored IKEA cabinets and white Corian countertops is tucked along one wall, and a long, narrow hall leads to the elegantly appointed master bedroom and bath.
Utterly sophisticated but charming with views of church steeples amid the rooftops, it’s the ultimate in urban living.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.