Kelly Swart loves home renovation TV shows, especially HGTV’s “Rehab Addict” with Nicole Curtis. But her partner, Peggy Shields, is not a fan and was not eager to take on an 1880s apartment building in Lawrenceville as their first project together.

“I dragged her into it,” Ms. Swart said. “I liked this building even though it was a disaster.”

Ms. Shields went along because she loved the location.

“That’s what sold me. It’s on the [Allegheny] river side of Butler Street, close to Children’s Hospital,” she said.

Advertise with us

The couple’s renovation, which turned five cramped apartments into four modern living spaces with open floor plans, was entered in last year’s Renovation Inspiration Contest. Sunday is the deadline to enter this year’s contest (story at right) and if your project turned out as well as this one, you could be a winner.

The owners, who live in West View, credit this successful rehab to their flexibility in the face of surprises and the dedication of their contractors, Steve Reis and Tom Fitz, and brick mason Eric Rupert.

“Our contractors washed our neighbor’s car because there was so much dust,” Ms. Swart said. “Tom spent our money like it was his.”

That may explain why their neighbors were so supportive during the nearly two-year project, and why Mr. Rupert was constantly asked by passersby to do brickwork on their homes. Mr. Reis and Mr. Fitz, who both grew up in Lawrenceville, worked steadily through one Fourth of July and missed few days in the brutally cold winter of 2013-14.

“This was very disruptive to the neighborhood,” Ms. Shields said. “Our contractors were phenomenal.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Rupert had to rebuild all but the front wall of the three-story building. That meant taking down and putting back up 15,000 old bricks, some original, some reclaimed,

Ms. Swart and Ms. Shields, who paid $75,000 for the building, knew one wall would have to be rebuilt; they could see gaps of several inches between it and the floor joists. But the instability of the other walls was a surprise, as was the need to evict dozens of pigeons from the attic, demolish two rear additions and remove eight chimneys.

Not as surprising but every bit as expensive was the need to dig down several feet in the dirt-floor basement to install concrete and a French drain. The improvement with the biggest price tag -- about $25,000 -- was the sprinkler system.

Ms. Swart’s rehab dreams were about transforming spaces, not ripping up flooring and pulling nails (though they did plenty of both). She and her partner got lots of advice from friend and designer Anthony Lamb, who suggested the white subway tile in the kitchen and a neutral palette.

“I wanted color. Anthony said, ‘No, white and beige,’” Ms. Swart recalled, laughing.

Advertise with us

He liked their idea for new modern steel staircases along exposed brick walls, but not the sharp angle of the quartz kitchen counters.

“He bought into it eventually, but not in the upstairs bathrooms. No room,” she said.

The two lower apartments have full bathrooms on the second floor and powder rooms on the first floor, both with vanities made from salvaged rafters. The lower apartments have nearly 1,200 square feet and rent for $1,700 with water, no utilities. The upper apartments, which feature lofts built into dormers but only one bath, have 960 square feet and rent for $1,500. All are rented but tenants have not yet moved into the unit shown in the photos.

The upper units are accessed by a new steel and concrete stair tower designed by architect Brett Shank.

The women, who call themselves unskilled labor, did as much of the work as the contractors would allow. Ms. Swart stripped and rebuilt the 12 corbels on the exterior, even enlisting her visiting parents from Corry, Pa. She said the renovation, which was completed in October 2014, seems less painful 16 months later. “We are so proud.”

Advertise with us

She now watches TV rehabs through less rosy glasses.

“I have to laugh when they tear down a wall and say, ‘Look at this tragedy!’ That wouldn’t even be on my radar,” she said.

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1978.