There are lots of old, pretty houses in Edgeworth. So when John and Mary Menniti went househunting in 2004, they knew renovations were in their future. They toured 401 Maple Lane and fell in love despite the work that lay ahead.
"The first time we went into the house, it was scary," he said.
The yard was overgrown and the wallpaper on every wall was starting to come down — with the plaster. But the couple pulled up a corner of the rug and saw beautifully preserved floors. They had found their diamond in the rough.
Now, 10 years later, after an extensive renovation, they're forced to move because of work, and their four-bedroom, 2½-bath Italianate-style house is on the market for $570,000 (MLS No. 1030546) with Patricia Happe of Berkshire Hathaway Home Services, (412-741-6312 or www.thepreferredrealty.com). The house is open by appointment.
Built in the 1870s by a member of the McKinney family, the house is one of the original homes built on the Shield Nurseries lots.

PG graphic: Edgeworth
(Click image for larger version including Sales Snapshot)
The Mennitis acted as their own general contractor and restored the home thinking they would live there forever. It also became the home of Mrs. Menniti's Italian Garden Project, which preserves and passes on the gardening know-how of local Italian gardeners. Heirloom plants and a fig tree grow by a row of mature maples. All that remains from the original yard is the stone pathway and patio uncovered during cleanup.
They replaced wiring, plumbing and heating systems, and had asbestos removed. The couple also righted many years of muddling, including a 1950s project that enclosed the front porch and included a two-story addition. The Mennitis reopened the porch and the addition now houses a kitchen on the ground level and a bedroom upstairs.
"We kept the board-and-batten ceilings, installed new handrails, replaced the stairs and the front porch floor," Mr. Menniti said.
The exterior of the home was painted a neutral tan and new downspouts were installed.
Inside, the 20-by-8-foot foyer has a circular staircase with original oak handrail. About 30 percent of the plaster on the curving walls around the staircase was replaced, along with the plaster crown molding found throughout the house.
The 18-by-15-foot living room has its original fireplace mantel and ceramic-tile surround.
"I was told that in the early 1900s one of the girls that lived in the house used to stage neighborhood plays in that room," Mr. Menniti said.
In the 15-by-12-foot dining room, the original crystal chandelier hangs from an original plaster medallion.
"When the home was built in the 1870s, there was no electric. It was first retrofitted with gas light then electric," he said.
The kitchen renovation was done in 2009. The 24-by-18-foot space features a large center island, two sinks and two pairs of French doors that offer easy access to the patio. White custom cabinetry was made by Mike Meerdo of Baden and is accented by brushed nickel hardware. Fixtures and replica tin tile were used to create a backsplash.
The original 14-by-10-foot kitchen is now the first-floor laundry. When renovations were underway, they uncovered the original back staircase behind a wall.
"It had been sealed since the 1970s and led to another upstairs kitchen and quarters, probably for a maid," Mr. Menniti said.
The upstairs was renovated in 2004 along with all of the bathrooms.
The master bedroom measures 18 by 16 feet. It has a master bath that features a pedestal sink and standing shower with marble trim.
The couple prefer to sleep in a 19-by-16-foot bedroom painted a mossy green. A nearby bathroom has wood wainscoting, pedestal sink and high ceilings.
The other two bedrooms measure 15 by 10 feet and 12 by 11 feet.
The property's county assessed value is $435,600 (www2.county.allegheny.pa.us/RealEstate/Search.aspx).
Over the last three years, seven properties have sold in the 400 block of Maple Lane ranging in price from $900,000 in September 2011 to $385,000 in June 2013 (www.realstats.net).
There's a separate two-car garage with room for an apartment above. Heating is zoned with two furnaces but there's no central air conditioning.
"We looked into whole house air but we were not convinced it could be done effectively," Mr. Menniti said.
They used two window units on the first floor, and one in each bedroom and found it to be cost-efficient and effective.
Rosa Colucci: 412-263-1661 or rcolucci@post-gazette.com. Twitter: PGRosa_Colucci.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.