Levi Meyers and Jason Bowman were looking for a Victorian they could afford to fix up, but there were three must-haves: brick exterior, no stairs and a garage.
“We got none of those,” Mr. Meyers said.
Yet it was perfect.
Maybe not at first, but with hard work and smart color choices, they turned this Carpenter Gothic-style horror show into a woodworker’s dream. It’s one of nine houses open from 1 to 5 p.m. June 7 for the Observatory Hill House Tour.
Over the next two weekends, nearly two dozen North Side houses will be on house tours, but none are quite like this one on Watson Boulevard. They may share some of its Second Empire and Queen Anne architectural elements but not its colorful, exuberant wood trim. Finished in 1896, the three-story house with six bedrooms and three full baths might have been the Watson Land & Improvement Co. model for the entire street, but an economic recession that year made it the only one of its kind.
This ornamental jigsaw style had a relatively brief buzz of popularity at the turn of the 20th century. Though seen mainly on exteriors (like the one in Grant Wood’s famous painting “American Gothic”), Carpenter Gothic’s elaborate wood details sometimes turned up inside, too. When Mr. Meyers and Mr. Bowman bought this house in May 2014, its original interior was almost entirely intact, including dentil molding atop paneled wainscoting in the entry, paneled doors with transoms and an oak staircase with carved newel post and balustrade. Even the seven fireplace mantels – most slate faux-painted to look like marble – were in place.
Read More
“So much of the original woodwork is here,” Mr. Meyers said.
Yet so many other parts were missing or lacking – like electrical, heating and plumbing systems. They had to replace more than 80 slates on the roof and rebuild, repoint and seal the two large chimneys. They also installed two high-efficiency furnaces and air-conditioning units and LED lighting throughout the house.
Mr. Bowman, a native of Wellsburg, W.Va., who previously renovated a mid-1800s row house in Wheeling, can do plumbing, painting and plaster repair. His partner, who grew up in Somerset, Somerset County, had never worked on an old house before, but he was eager to help feed PEX tubing into the walls and repaint 1980s-era faux painting that covered most walls, ceilings and trim.
A second-floor bath with an old clawfoot tub and beadboard wainscoting was transformed from bright shades of pink to serene gray. A khaki-colored parlor with unique corner cabinetry became dark blue with crisp white trim. The exterior, which had been light gray, teal and red, was painted recently in gray-green with white and red accents.
The kitchen, which was redone in the 1980s with blue-and-white tile counter tops and floors, is functional but not really to their taste. It, too, will be transformed.
“We’re doing one room at a time,” Mr. Bowman said. “It’s still a work in progress.”
The Observatory Hill House Tour runs 1-5 p.m. June 7. There are 12 stops altogether, including the starting point, Riverview United Presbyterian Church at 3505 Perrysville Ave. Transportation is by Molly’s Trolleys. Tickets are $12 if purchased by WednesdayJune 3 or $15 on tour day at the church. Information, advance tickets: www.observatoryhill.net. Proceeds benefit Observatory Hill Inc.
Kevin Kirkland: 412-263-1978 or kkirkland@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.