For Rabbi Daniel Fellman, Wednesday is a day to celebrate.
That day, Christians will gather around the tree to open presents while celebrating the birth of Jesus. But that night, the Jewish community will light the first candle on their menorahs.
This year, Christmas and the first night of Hanukkah fall on the same day, an occurrence that has only happened four times since 1900, Hebacal, which tracks Jewish holidays, found. And the next time the two holidays will fall on the same day is in 2035, then again in 2054.
“It's actually a wonderful occurrence,” Rabbi Fellman of Temple Sinai in Squirrel Hill said. “Both holidays are trying to bring light and bring goodness to the world and to help people look out at others with kindness and with favor. Our world needs more of that, not less.”
The occurrence happens because the Christian and Jewish faiths follow different calendars.
The Hebrew calendar is an adjusted lunar calendar, meaning it largely follows the lunar cycle. But to ensure Jewish holidays such and Hanukkah and Passover align with their traditional seasons on the Gregorian calendar — the primary dating system used by the Western world — an additional leap month is added to the Hebrew calendar every two or three years, northjersey.com reported.
Read More
Hanukkah is always observed on the 25th day of Kislev, the ninth month of the Hebrew calendar. But because the Hebrew and Gregorian calendars don’t line up, the start of the holiday can begin as early as Nov. 28 or as late on Dec. 27, depending on the year.
While rare, the occurrence has been dubbed Chrismukkah, the celebration of both Jewish and Christian festivities. Chrismukkah has its roots in the 19th century, according to a 2016 The Times of Israel article. German Jews at the time were becoming increasingly assimilated into mainstream German Christian culture and adopted Christmas traditions in a secular way, NPR reported.
Today, Chrismukkah gained pop culture significance after being featured in a 2003 episode of the TV series “The O.C.” In the episode one of the show’s main characters observed Chrismukkah to celebrate his Jewish and Protestant heritage.
Families across the region are now gearing up to celebrate both Christmas and Hanukkah.
“We have families who have trees and have Hanukkah menorahs both up on display in their home, and I know we have families who will have gifts for both and probably be drinking eggnog while eating their latkes,” Rabbi Fellman said.
Temple Sinai, Rabbi Fellman said, “prides itself and holds one of its core values as being inclusive.” Because of that, the congregation has several families of multiple faiths.
“It's double celebrations,” Rabbi Fellman said. “And the way most families look at it is we celebrate other people's birthdays, even though it's not our birthday. So why can't we celebrate other people's holidays, too? And so, you know, as a Jew. I can go to a Christmas party. I can say Merry Christmas to somebody and mean it, and want to legitimately celebrate them the same way I can go to their birthday party on their birthday and celebrate their birthday.
“It doesn't take anything away from me; if anything, it adds for me.”
Father Terry O’Connor of the Mary, Mother of God Parish in the White Oak and McKeesport area, grew up celebrating Christmas and Hanukkah because his parents observed different religions. The family lived in the heart of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community, and his mother, Judy, was Jewish; his father, former Mayor Bob O’Connor, was Roman Catholic.
“My mom loved Santa Claus, the gift giving, the Christmas tree,” Father O’Connor said. “So Christmas was really a big deal in our house.”
But they also lit the menorah, gave Hanukkah gifts, fried donuts and indulged in potato pancakes. Jewish relatives would attend Christmas parties and vice versa.
“I'm blessed with both the worlds that I grew up in,” Father O’Connor said. “Now I'm a Catholic priest so obviously my focus is on the birthday of the Lord, on Christmas. However, I still enjoy getting together [for] Christmas and a lot of the Jewish relatives are gathered for that. I also enjoy the opportunity to be gathered with them in any Hanukkah celebration.”
At Temple B’nai Israel in White Oak, Debbie Iszauk, the office manager, said “it’s lovely” that Christians and Jews can celebrate the holidays together even though they have different meanings. While Christmas celebrates the birth of Jesus, Hanukkah recalls a Jewish revolt against Greek-Syrian oppressors more than 2,000 years ago. Afterwards, a vial of oil that should have only lasted one night miraculously lasted eight days.
“This is the time of the year that we all wish each other goodness and happiness and light,” Ms. Iszauk said. “So the fact that they both fall on the same day this year, no, I don’t have any special significance to that but it is the season of sharing of light and joy.”
Rev. David Poecking, regional vicar for the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh, said the holidays falling on the same day has “a certain poetry to it.”
“It's nice when we can say happy holidays and mean that in the fullest sense, not merely as a euphemism, but as something that embraces holidays being observed by both Jews and Christians,” Father Poecking said.
At the Jewish Community Center of Greater Pittsburgh, things are business as usual, Rabbi Hindy Finman said, noting that Tuesday morning people were getting in their pre-holiday workouts at the Squirrel Hill facility’s gym.
Others, Rabbi Finman said, took advantage of schools being closed to travel, a challenge the JCC had to face when planning Hanukkah-related events and activities.
The facility, she said, is “a very welcoming space,” filled with people of different religions.
Because of that, Rabbi Finman said she views the two holidays falling on the same day as “an opportunity for more people, rather than just Jews or just people who celebrate Christmas, to be thinking about how can we add light to our communities, universe, in a spiritual sense.”
Now, people across the region and country are gearing up for both holidays with their own family traditions.
“I’m fine celebrating the same two holidays on the same day,” Rabbi Fellman said. “I think it’s good for humanity.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.