On an overcast Tuesday morning in McKeesport, Rev. Terry O’Connor arrived at St. Patrick Church for his daily morning mass, just as he has for decades.

Clad in violet robes — the color of penitence during Lent — O’Connor approached the altar and began his sermon to the few dozen assembled parishioners with an easy cadence. Train horns from a nearby railroad sounded behind him every few minutes, but they never broke his concentration.

The day’s theme was original sin and how Jesus died to redeem humanity before his resurrection on Easter.

“You can’t pay it back. You just follow the mercy of the Savior of the world, and that’s the amazing, great news,” he said.

Advertise with us

He concluded with communion and a prayer for those involved in the conflict in the Middle East, before greeting parishioners with a handshake and a wide smile.

In an illustrious family that has produced two Pittsburgh mayors, O’Connor has forged his own path, driven by his faith – one that he had never planned for.

A higher calling

O’Connor, 56, grew up in Squirrel Hill, the middle of three children and the son of a Catholic father — future Mayor Bob O’Connor – and a Jewish mother, Judy Levine O’Connor. He has an older sister, Heidy, and a younger brother, Corey — Pittsburgh’s current mayor.

O’Connor recalled that he was raised outside of the public eye; he was an adult when his father was elected to the Pittsburgh City Council in 1991. As a child, he celebrated only two Catholic and Jewish holidays — Christmas and Hanukkah. His goal was to become a professional tennis player.

“I didn’t make Wimbledon,” he said with a sly smile.

Advertise with us

Life had other plans.

He attended Central Catholic High School, which he said had a “huge influence” on him, as he grew close with the school chaplain, Rev. Robert George.

His father encouraged him to be baptized after he graduated.

“We’re not going to be here forever,” Bob O’Connor told his son. “Even when we die, you’ll have your faith.”

O’Connor said his father’s words held additional weight since he died in September 2006 at age 61 following a battle with brain cancer. He still gets emotional thinking about how he helped care for his father during his final months. His mother died in May 2024.

Advertise with us

O’Connor heeded his father’s advice and was baptized during his sophomore year at the University of Pittsburgh. His mother, he said, was initially worried about the effect it would have on their relationship given her Jewish faith, but became supportive once she saw the positive impact it had on him.

“I didn’t know I’d be a priest, but I knew something was happening then. I had this immediate union with Jesus, like he was my best friend,” he said.

O’Connor continued his studies, earning a law degree from Pitt, but he found himself increasingly reading the Bible, praying and attending daily mass. He soon realized what he wanted to do with the rest of his life.

“You can run, but you can’t hide from the Lord,” he said.

When O’Connor entered the seminary at 26, he thought he wouldn’t last a week. Decades later, he is in his 25th year as an ordained priest.

Advertise with us

Family ties

O’Connor and his brother, Corey, own their childhood home in Squirrel Hill. It has been their family’s gathering place for generations. Once a week, they return to the neighborhood to share Aiello’s Pizza and talk about Pittsburgh sports.

Corey O’Connor, 41, said he views his brother as a mentor due to their 15-year age gap and his extensive life experiences.

“He's been around a little bit longer, so he's seen things and done things that he can give advice to,” he said.

The mayor, who said he celebrates both the Jewish and Catholic sides of his family, has attended his brother’s masses and parish fish fries, where he has observed him interacting with people seeking guidance, including those who are not parishioners.

“He's always there to help somebody out, and I think that's why he had that calling many, many years ago,” he said.

Advertise with us

Heidy O’Connor-Kadosh, 60, said that her brother was well-behaved – if occasionally mischievous – from a young age.

“He was one of those siblings where the parents thought he could do no wrong,” she joked.

She said she did not expect her brother to become a priest, but she was not surprised when he went down that path due to his close relationships with teachers at Central Catholic High School.

Even though she is not a practicing Catholic, she attends her brother’s masses to support him, and asked him to lead a prayer and tell stories at her wedding.

“His homilies are just amazing. You can just feel the Holy Spirit hitting him and guiding him through,” she said

Advertise with us

O’Connor-Kadosh considers her brother one of her best friends, and he has a close relationship with her children, who know that they can go to him for anything, she said.

“His actions speak volumes – he's just a very kind, good-hearted person who wants to help people,” she said.

Priestly duties

O’Connor was assigned first to Our Lady of Fatima Church in Hopewell and then St. Therese in Munhall. He is now pastor of Mary, Mother of God Parish, and has been serving at its member churches, St. Patrick, Corpus Christi and St. Angela Merici, since 2018.

Developing personal relationships with more than 5,800 parishioners would be a challenge for anyone, but O’Connor sees it as his duty to meet people where they are to bring them closer to their faith.

“The important thing is to be there, be accessible, be among the people,” he said.

Advertise with us

While weekend masses can bring out hundreds of worshipers, O’Connor sees some of the same faces during the week, when 40-50 attend daily mass. Many of the frequent attendees are widowers, he said.

Bill Kersting, 83, of White Oak, said O’Connor administered last rites to his wife before she died in 2020. A member of St. Patrick Church for over 50 years, Kersting said he has always found O’Connor to be approachable and respectful, especially on that day.

“The way he was, it was very moving,” he said.

A priest’s life can be emotionally demanding. O’Connor often oversees funerals after his morning mass, and he spends many days delivering communion to the homebound, visiting hospitals and preparing for weddings.

“Some people think that we say mass on Sundays and play golf the rest of the week,” he said.

Advertise with us

He is also involved in the parish’s administrative work alongside business manager Cathy Nola. Together, they oversaw $1.5 million renovations at St. Angela and St. Patrick, involving new lighting, wheelchair ramps and accessible entryways.

Nola, a former bank manager, had taught religious education at the parish for decades before O’Connor recruited her to be business manager. She credits O’Connor with helping her realize that her current job was the perfect mix of her faith and business acumen.

“It’s so funny – I feel like I should have been here my whole life in the church,” she said. “I love banking, but this is my heart.”

O’Connor spends his evenings in prayer. He said he takes “rosary walks” around St. Angela to gather inspiration for homilies. Some of his ideas come from watching the news or talking to parishioners about what they are worried about.

“The world is a tough place sometimes, and the message of Jesus gives everybody hope,” he said.