Trish Imbrogno of Reserve played upright bass to seek the spotlight as a teenager and made a career in classical music. But she’d come to find herself in a wildly different genre where the grass was both greener and bluer on the other side.

When you’re a self-described unpopular teenager living in the hunting, fishing and camping hub of Kane in McKean County, the shine of the spotlight, or just standing out, can seem appealing.

“A lot of people I grew up with listened to country music,” said Imbrogno. “They were listening to Garth Brooks. They drove pickup trucks. Not that they had a farm — I think there were two farms in my town — but everybody thought they were a farmer. And, man, I hated it. I was like, get me out of here.

“I was a Deadhead. I wore bell-bottoms. I was a hippie.”

Advertise with us

Though the small-town dissident had no way of knowing it, she would grow up to become one of the region’s most sought-after bassists, playing with the Sweaty Already String Band, Molly Alphabet Band and Grant Street Grifters, among others.

She’d appear and record with The Jakob's Ferry Stragglers, Crandall Creek, Casual Hobos, Shameless Hex, Dead and In The Way, Shelf Life String Band, Joe McGuinness and Emily Pinkerton. And her discography would blossom to more than a dozen entries, including her first headlining album, “Bluegrass Love Songs Vol. I,” released this winter.

The album impressed Bruce Mountjoy, host of WYEP’s “Bluegrass Jam Session.”

“I have been around the bluegrass scene for a while, and this is one of the most interesting and ambitious projects that I have seen,” he said.

As a sprout, Imbrogno arose from a middle-class, blue-collar family. By age 13, she’d left behind attempts at other musical instruments and found the bass through her school’s annual recruitment demonstrations.

Advertise with us

“I looked at the stage, and I was like ‘It's a bunch of violins and whatever those things are, some of those things — and one bass,” she remembered. “There’s one person playing the bass. I was like, ‘Oh, people will see me if I play the bass.’ It was total vanity, total vanity at age 13.”

A passion took root.

“I always say the bass picked me, that I didn't pick the bass,” she said. “It was like, ‘Come here girl, you're gonna play me.’”

‘It’s almost a dance’

Imbrogno played through her first songbook in less than a week, joined the orchestra and spent the rest of her high school career working to stay ahead of students like a senior transfer student from New York.

“Man, he was this really good city kid, right? I was so mad,” Imbrogno said. “My mom still remembers I came in and threw my books down.... Because I was the best, right? And so I practiced and I practiced. I practiced before school. I practiced at lunch. I practiced after school. And I ended up chairing that first year at districts.

Advertise with us

“There was that competition and I couldn't let it go. I was like, ‘There's no way this kid's coming in here and making me look bad.’”

She got so good that during her senior year she enrolled in music performance at Duquesne University under former PSO principal bassist Jeff Turner. She went on to get her master’s degree in arts administration at the University of Akron, after realizing “top 10” orchestra jobs were not in her future.

She found fulfillment at the regional level.

“It was just something I felt like I should or had to do, and not for any reason. It wasn't the standout thing anymore.”

She’d grown.

Advertise with us

“It's a really cool instrument to play, because it's like another human being,” Imbrogno said. “It's like you're embracing an instrument that is the size of a person, and you have to manipulate that instrument.

“It's almost a dance, especially somebody playing with a bow. It's beautiful to watch somebody that has really good technique and they're really just dialed in with their instrument like that. That, to me, is the most amazing thing about the bass, it's almost an extension of my human persona.”

The baton sways

The jam band enthusiast then spent decades performing in classical orchestras between Pasadena, Calif., and Pittsburgh. Playing Carnegie Hall in New York brought her to tears.

“[Classical] is a very regimented thing. You play it this way. That's how the composer wrote it. That's how the conductor is conducting it,” she said. “You play what's on the page, and you basically are the best cover band in the world.

“That's not a derogatory statement. The Pittsburgh Symphony is literally one of the best orchestras in the country for what they're doing. I spent 25 years looking at a page of music and just doing what you're supposed to do.”

Advertise with us

But there came a point where she didn’t truly play for five years.

“I didn't touch it. I’d take it out of the corner, play some scales on it, make sure it was in one piece, and put it back in the corner,” said Imbrogno.

“I quit the job I came back to Pittsburgh to take and I was like ‘No more. I am not, not playing the bass.’ It was a miserable time, and the only thing I can attribute to it is that I wasn't making music in my life.”

Playing the Park House

In 2008, she and her partner, Peter Flynn, a finger-picking guitar player, began gigging as an acoustic blues duo to help fill that void.

“People would come up to me an be like, ‘There’s this bluegrass thing at the Park House, you should go there.’ And I was like, ‘I don't even know what bluegrass is. I don't know who you are,’” she said with a laugh.

Advertise with us

In 2012, they finally checked out the North Side bar.

“That's where I was like, ‘I am so hooked on this,’” said Imbrogno.

Together, the pair began to play there, drawing on Imbrogno’s childhood affinities by watering the jam grass side of things a la Yonder Mountain, Billy Strings and Green Sky.

“It's this long, skinny bar. I used to have to hold my bass over people's heads to get in and out of the place, because it was so packed,” she said. “And for the first few years, we'd play in the back of the bar with no amplification. Like, I don't think anybody could even hear us. But it was fun, man.”

She reveled in the newfound freedom.

Advertise with us

“There's no rules. You just get up there and you play. I'd go to the Starlite Jam on Tuesday night. So, I played up and down the neck. I played all the notes. I played whatever I wanted,” said Imbrogno. “Those guys would side-eye me, you know, roll their eyes. I could hear them rolling their eyes. And I didn't understand, you know? Nobody said, ‘Stop doing that.’”

Soon, the local bluegrass community started to take notice.

“Basses are kind of like pickup trucks, right? So people find out you have a bass, that you can play and they start calling you,” she said.

She took more and more gigs until, in 2018, with her contract renewal time coming up with the Butler County Symphony Orchestra, she found no room in her suddenly busy schedule for concert dates and made a decision.

“There’s this connection with your audience when you’re playing roots music — or any music really on a stage that isn't a classical stage — and you get this vibe of energy from the crowd that is immediate,” she said. “You step on stage and you have this immediate connection with your audience and it's a back and forth the whole show and that is unbelievable.

Advertise with us

“I want to do this every day, because I can walk offstage and feel like I have the worst show ever. And if someone comes up to me and goes, ‘Oh my God, it was so great’ and they tell me what a great time they had, it's not about me anymore. It's never about me when I step onstage. It's about making sure the people who are there to hear me are having a good time and enjoying what what we're doing.”

True grass

After some lessons in traditional bluegrass from one of “those guys” in 2019, she gained a healthy respect for the genre in which tradition is vital.

“I thought he was going to punch me. He was like, ‘What do you mean, you don't listen to Bob Moore?’ said Imbrogno with a laugh. “I started to dig into the Stanley Brothers and Flatt and Scruggs and, locally, Mac Martin was our guy.

“And I realized pretty quickly there is a counterpoint and an intricacy to this music. So, just like an orchestral score — where you have all of the parts, everybody's got their part — and you have to learn where you fit in and how to make that music work, to sound like the parts and the three-part harmonies and those stacks.”

The girl who had taken up the bass to stand out willingly stepped back again.

Advertise with us

“What I really loved about it, and what I still love about it, and what is a huge challenge every day, is understanding and really playing my role in that band — to be the bass player and not flashy, and make sure I am grounding and rooting the band and starting the drive,” she said. “It's everybody's job to keep time, but it is truly a bass player's job to stay on the front of that beat, if that's where it's supposed to be, for that feel and make sure everybody's got that pillow to land on when they're playing.”

In her mind, her new role beat the orchestra.

“You still have a lot more freedom. It's not prescribed what I'm playing. There's just a — I hate to use the word etiquette — but like, there's a basic way these songs are written and should be played,” she explained. “I can play G and D over that chord or I can play a walk, so it's not as prescribed as classical music. There's just a feel that needs to happen and a general type of playing that needs to happen when you're playing traditional bluegrass. And I don't feel boxed in at all like in the classical sense of playing.”

She lived out that ethos playing on numerous records.

“I have this pretty long discography, but if you go search me, you can't find me,” she said. “It's under everybody else's names.”

Advertise with us

She connects that idea to her past.

“I guess maybe a la Jerry Garcia — he never wanted to be the front person of the Grateful Dead — I don't need to be signing autographs and whatever after the show. I'm fine to go back in the green room and let whoever I've given the support to have that limelight. But maybe that's part of finding the true meaning of this instrument in the music, too.

“Bluegrass is a community. The whole genre is a community, and it's about being part of the bigger picture.”

Continuing her lifelong dance with the bass, Imbrogno stepped back into the light to grow further on “Bluegrass Love Songs,” an album she co-produced that features performances by Dede Wyland, Murphy Henry, Rainy Miatke and Becky Buller.

“I kind of just thought maybe it's time to do something under my own name, just to step out and do it,” said Imbrogno. “And I kind of wanted to prove to myself I could actually coordinate this thing and hire musicians, and get the engineers and actually take this thing start to finish.”

Advertise with us

The album consists of five traditional bluegrass songs carrying a central theme that she became fond of singing in her seven years since taking on a dual singing role. As her colleague Jimmy Hall put it, they’re “sad songs sung with great joy.”

With them, she continues to sway in time as she reaches up toward the sky.

“I have my bucket list for bluegrass: I need to play the Ryman, I need to play the Opry,” she said. “Now I've got my other list of stages to conquer in this new genre.”