When considering Mon Valley history, Andrew Carnegie and steel mills come to mind, but so does the mystery of the B-25 “Ghost Bomber.”
The legend and facts surrounding the military plane that went missing on Jan. 31, 1956, are familiar to most Pittsburghers by now. The B-25 bomber made a miraculous emergency landing in the Monongahela River, quickly sank and was never recovered after many fruitless searches. Two crewmen died.
The mystery has been immortalized in a new mural in the Linden Tunnel in Duquesne, part of the Steel Valley Trail’s 10-mile stretch from McKeesport to Pittsburgh’s Hays neighborhood, a small section of the much longer Great Allegheny Passage trail.
good mural
The nonprofit Steel Valley Trail Council sought creation of a mural for a nondescript concrete trail tunnel that is now anything but.
Plagued by graffiti, volunteers cleaned and painted over obscene language numerous times. Artwork became a solution because graffiti artists are typically less inclined to deface murals.
Read More
The trail council asked the public, local organizations and historians what they wanted to see. They vetted dozens of suggestions and came up with a list of more than 45 people and scenes — more than 200 years of history — to be compressed into the 8-foot-high mural adorning both sides of the 63-foot-long tunnel.
People depicted include Carnegie, Rachel Carson, August Wilson and Fred Rogers on bikes. Riding with them is the lesser-known E.R. Crawford, who founded the region’s first tin-plate mill and lived in a mansion, now long gone, above the tunnel in Duquesne.
The E.R. Crawford Estate Trust Fund donated money for the mural, and a competitive mini-grant from Rivers of Steel heritage corporation brought the total to $5,500.
The mural draws from history in the trail’s eight communities: McKeesport, Duquesne, West Mifflin, Whitaker, Munhall, Homestead, West Homestead and Hays.
“I think the final product is beautiful,” said Ryan Henderson, a grant manager for Rivers of Steel. “You have a slice from all around the region representing all of these important Pittsburgh moments, places, things and stories and it is helping to beautify the space and share with people.”
Contemporary scenes easily blend with the past, featuring popular destinations like Kennywood and Sandcastle Water Park.
The brightly colored mural is a surprising visual treat nestled in a wooded section of the Duquesne stretch, which has recently been repaved with a smoother asphalt surface.
“I think the local people enjoy seeing scenes they are familiar with and things that are no longer there,” said Roy Bires, of Swissvale, who is president of the trail council. “For people out of town, they will get to see a part of the tri-state area and learn what it is about.”
Since the Steel Valley trail is part of the GAP, thousands of riders from throughout the country pass through annually on their 333-mile, off-road bike journey from Pittsburgh to Washington, D.C.
Gone but still alive in the mural are the Duquesne branch of the Carnegie Library, the Homestead and Duquesne steel works, National Tube Works, and the 68 Homestead, Duquesne, Kennywood, McKeesport trolley.
The artist behind the project, Zachary Rutter of Munhall, is an art teacher in the West Mifflin School District.
“Most people know about the Ghost Bomber, but then there’s E.R. Crawford,” Rutter said. “I learned about his impact in the community and it blew my mind. There are things in the community that people don’t know and I was happy to plaster this history on the walls.”
While he was painting the mural over the summer, more than 100 cyclists, many from out of town, stopped to watch and comment.
“Oh my God, Mister Rogers is on the wall,” said more than one.
Explanations of the mural’s characters and scenes will be available via a QR code added later in the year.
“There’s a lot of community and character in the mural, not just architecture and historical elements,” Rutter said.
Bires said the most popular image seems to be the bomber, which is flanked by Sandcastle’s Lazy River ride and the Hays bald eagle nest.
The juxtaposition of the images is spot on.
The specifics of the bomber’s landing information are recorded in federal government files and were provided by the Senator John Heinz History Center in the Strip District.
“The Ghost Bomber will remain one of Pittsburgh's most enduring mysteries and I think Pittsburghers like it that way,” said Andy Masich, president and CEO of the history center. “It’s nice to have some unsolved mysteries.”
Is the bomber still in the Mon?
The last time the bomber was illustrated in such a spectacular public fashion was more than a decade ago in another mural that graced the Heinz History Center.
“The legend does live on. Pittsburghers know and are still curious about it 75 years later,” Masich said.
He believes that the plane still lies in its watery grave in the Monongahela, likely in a large hole dug for an ice breaker.
For people who lived nearby and worked in the mills, the incident is particularly mysterious.
“Many people who live in the Mon Valley think the plane was taken out by the government the night it crashed into the river,” Bires said.
“There are rumors that some steelworkers saw the plane lifted out of the river,” continued Bires, who worked in the Mon Valley steel mills when he was young.
Some years ago, the Heinz History Center and the B-25 Recovery Group joined forces to find the missing plane with sonar and other tools, with no luck.
According to records assembled by the history center and others, the plane was on a routine flight delivering parts to Harrisburg when it ran out of fuel.
The plane cruised silently over the Homestead High Level Bridge (now the Homestead Grays Bridge) and pulled a perfect wheels-up landing, Masich said.
“All the crew and passengers got out on the wings of the plane and shouted to people gathering on the shore.”
The plane took on water and started sinking, spurring the six crewmembers to jump into the river to swim to the bank. Some onlookers dove into the dangerously cold 32-degree water to help. Four crewmen made it and two drowned.
“There were a lot of cold and wet people,” Masich said. “That may have contributed to the confusion of why area hospitals reported more victims than the plane’s manifest had listed.”
The reports of excess injuries fueled speculation of Russian spies and Las Vegas showgirls on the flight.
The secrecy surrounding the aftermath of the emergency plane landing during the Cold War era led some to believe their mission was associated with atomic weapons that might have been on board, Masich said.
Some thought that Navy Seals or other clandestine military troops spirited it away, he said.
Some residents said they saw crews cutting the wings off the plane and loading the parts in a truck.
“There is no evidence for any of that,” Masich said.
At least three planes crashed into the Monongahela River in the 1950s and ’60s and some witnesses might have seen other planes lifted out of the river and put on flatbed trucks, potentially conflating the incidents, he added.
Salvage rights for the plane were sold; crews dragged the river and could not find the bomber.
Armed with sonar and other tools, the history center and the B-25 Recovery group found no evidence of the bomber. They did find mundane items like shopping carts.
Deep silt on the river bottom made for poor visibility and it kept moving and settling after barges and tugboats passed by, Masich noted.
If the plane is still there, what would be left today? Landing gear and the engine block, he said. The acidity of the Mon in the heyday of steel making could have eaten away the aluminum skin of the bomber, he added.
The official accident report is redacted. Why the government secrecy?
While some point to a cover-up, Masich said redacting information is standard procedure for witness confidentiality in investigative reports released to the public.
“I don’t believe there is something the government is trying to hide,” he said.
The history center interviewed the pilot, Maj. William Dotson.
“He wouldn’t speak about it. I think, truthfully, he lost two crewmembers that day. It is not a joking matter and it is not something that needs to be paraded or made fun of. He didn’t have anything to offer to the story.
“I’m sure he felt some responsibility for the crash,” Masich said.
The story might not be over.
“Someday that water may go down or there may be a project, say, a channelization effort and some of that bomber might appear,” Masich said.
If anyone has evidence or memories of the 1956 Ghost Bomber incident, Masich requests they contact the Heinz History Center to add their story to its collection.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.