Though Aliquippa is known for football and has produced several NFL Hall of Famers, this Beaver County town also boasts having raised a few giants of music. There’s composer Henry Mancini, who wrote Audrey Hepburn’s “Moon River,” and the Steals brothers, who wrote one of the most popular Top 40 songs of the 1970s in “Could It Be I'm Falling in Love.”

good songs

One of the songwriting twins, Melvin Steals, still resides in Beaver County with his wife of 56 years, Adrena Richardson Steals, a Pittsburgh native and Westinghouse High School graduate.

After he and brother Mervin experienced musical success in Philadelphia, Melvin returned home and enjoyed a successful career in education. He earned a master's degree from Duquesne University and a Ph.D. from the University of Pittsburgh. His brother, meanwhile got married, had children, moved to East Orange, N.J., and became a successful union carpenter.

Advertise with us

On Feb. 9, the brothers celebrated their 79th birthday.

Their road to international acclaim started on Green Street in Aliquippa. The youngest of eight children born to Alabama natives Thomas Steals Sr. and Leola Williams Steals, Melvin and Mervin sang in the choir at Mt. Olive Missionary Baptist Church.

Their father worked at J&L Steel. At age 47, he died of pancreatic caner when the twins were just 5.

At Aliquippa High School, the twins were basketball stars who competed against a talented Midland High School team that featured future NBA and ABA pros Simmie Hill and Norm Van Lier and went on to win the PIAA Class A title in 1965.

After graduating from Aliquippa High in 1964, the Steals brothers took their many talents to Cheyney State University near Phildelphia, the oldest HBCU in the nation, where they also played basketball.

Advertise with us

There they met vocalist Eddie Holman of “Hey There Lonely Girl” fame, who encouraged the twins to become part of the burgeoning Philly music scene of the late 1960s.

During summer breaks from college, the twins returned home and spent time writing songs at Steel City Records, a recording studio in East Liberty.

“Lots of good people hung out there, including a young Phyllis Hyman before she eventually made her mark in Philadelphia,” Melvin Steals recalls.

During their days at Steel City Records, the brothers penned songs for Hyman and an upcoming band from Ellwood City, The Jaggerz.

The Steals twins wrote “Gotta Find My Way Back Home” for The Jaggerz, who were signed by famed Philly producers Leon Huff and Kenny Gamble. The Aliquippa brothers were specifically signed to compose the tune for The Jaggerz, a group already famous for the Top 40 hit “The Rapper,” written by band member Donnie Iris.

Advertise with us

In recent years, rap artist A$AP Rocky has sampled “Gotta Find My Way Back Home.” The Steals brothers still receive monthly checks from BMI for record sales, Melvin says.

Following success with The Jaggerz, the brothers met with producers Billy Jackson and Paul Leka at the behest of New York-based record mogul Clive Davis. Legendary Philadelphia producer Thom Bell would be the final hurdle.

“When Tommy heard ‘Could It Be I’m Falling In Love,’ he was very impressed, and was ready to sign us to a deal,” Steals says.

The song was originally to be performed as a duet by Peaches & Herb, but when the duo balked, Bell suggested The Spinners and Atlantic Records. Bell also suggested lending the tune an “Al Green beat” similar to the slower disco groove on Green's “Let's Stay Together.”

“And the rest is history,” said Steals.

Advertise with us

Original recordings of the hit released in November 1972 credit Mystro and Lyric as composers. It is now correctly credited to Mervin Steals (piano, music) and Melvin Steals (lyrics).

After success with The Spinners, the brothers penned “Impossible Decision,” a song that achieved some success in the Pittsburgh market. The song is credited to Dewi Cheatum & Howe and was released on Curtis Mayfield's Chicago-based Curtom label.

Steals says he has no regrets about relocating back to Western Pennsylvania after their songwriting success.

“Philadelphia is a big city and lots of situations were occurring there. We just didn't want to get involved with that type of lifestyle. Lots of foolishness at the time. It was a good time for me to finish my education and help ones who needed help in our schools here,” he said.

Steals taught at his alma mater, Aliquippa High School, where he mentored and developed a special reading program for high school athletes who struggled with reading.

Advertise with us

During his 36 years as an educator, Steals also taught in the Quaker Valley and Seneca Valley school districts and was an adjunct professor at Duquesne University.

“I honestly believe it was God's will that I was able to stay home, enjoy my wife, our three children and grandchildren,” he said.

The Steals brothers continue to write songs. They are credited as writers and composers along with Colin Leonard, McKinley Jackson, Kaytranada and Kali Uchis on the song “10%,” which won a Grammy for best dance recording in March 2021.

Melvin Steals said "10%" came about when their attorney at Famous Music/Sony Records was contacted in 2019 about sampling “Love Thang,” one of their songs performed by First Choice, a female Philly trio.

Rapper Chubb Rock also used a piece of the song in his 1991 hip-hop banger, "Treat 'Em Right."

The brothers recently wrote a new tune called “Say Hello” for Russell Thompkins Jr., the original lead vocalist for The Stylistics. The song was released on the twins’ birthday, Feb. 9.