“Please listen carefully as our menu options have changed.”

For more than a decade, I have had to listen to that same automated opening remark during phone calls with practically every consumer company with whom I do business. That greeting is often followed by a cheerful request to visit the company’s website and to download its phone app where, the phone bot claims, you can find answers to just about any question and take care of whatever business you need to address.

Some sites work better than others, but online automation often doesn’t work for me. If it did, I probably wouldn’t have needed to make a call in the first place. So bad bots tend to leave bad impressions of the company.

good patience

Advertise with us

Part of my issue is that their menus – even though they may have recently been changed – rarely include the reason for my call. Instead, they deal with such routine matters as placing an order, making a payment or learning my account balance – easy stuff. Some phone bots are equipped to listen for keywords that can help direct your call to a different automated attendant. But here too, my reason for calling almost never fits the simple voice commands a bot can understand. So I try to find a human attendant to explain my issue. However, I often end up shouting “representative!” or “customer service!” into the phone, over and over again, before making a human connection.

To be fair, speaking with a live human operator sometimes is offered as a menu option – although it’s typically the last option, presented after exhausting the other alternatives. Even then, you are typically asked first to enter some combination of your Social Security number, birth date, PIN, account number and more before being connected.

Those phone connections are often unstable, with calls dropped before a resolution is reached. And in many cases, the person you are speaking to is half a world away, speaking English so heavily accented that conversation becomes extremely difficult.

In some ways that’s ironic. For example, AT&T, which built its business around telephone service, seems to have developed an allergy to having its people talk on the phone. The same is true with Verizon, Comcast and most other utility services. And they’re not alone. Replacing people with various forms of automation has been around for years in other industries as well. Consider the self-checkout lines in grocery stores, gas stations, fast-food restaurants, banks, and even the post office although – importantly – each of them also offer human-staffed options.

I suppose I can understand the reasons for replacing people with automation. For one thing, finding people to do those jobs isn’t easy. In the North Hills where I live, just about every business has a sign prominently posted to announce that they’re hiring. The sluggish service in many restaurants and retail establishments confirms that the labor shortage is real. And then there’s the fact that a human can’t work 24/7 like a bot can.

Advertise with us

Humans demand to be paid for their labor. Bots don’t. Beyond that, a bot can endure all sorts of abusive language and bad behavior, whereas humans will complain, file lawsuits, go on strike or quit. Even so, I’m still partial to dealing with humans.

I know I’m far from alone in my dim view of the current generation of bots. According to a recent Forrester study, fully half of the customers who interact with a bot leave feeling frustrated and with negative opinions of the brand. So fine-tuning a chatbot to better understand customer intent is one approach that companies can use to make their automation work better. Regularly testing the technology to identify and fix annoying issues, like requiring callers to enter the same information repeatedly, is another.

But there is also, on the near horizon, the advent of a new generation of bots using artificial intelligence equipped with far greater comprehension of natural language than the ones currently in use. If using them can be paired with enticements such as price reductions, bonus points or other incentives, I could easily reconsider my negative impression – that is, of course, assuming the bot can resolve my issue.

At the same time, I know there is a lot of apprehension about AI and how it might morph into a more malevolent version of the HAL-9000 supercomputer from “2001: A Space Odyssey.” But, at least for now, I am prepared to march unafraid into that brave new world where I can get my business taken care of by a better bot, whenever I want.

Peter Longini, of McCandless, is a former communication professor, speechwriter and ghostwriter for business leaders and public officials.