I’m not a hunter. But here in Western Pennsylvania, there are lots of people for whom deer hunting season is the highlight of their year.

Among them was a good friend from work, an enthusiastic outdoorsman. Back in 1998, he, along with his twin brother, was eager to help publicize a newly renovated hunting club in northern Michigan. So, as a favor, I wrote a brochure promoting the Beaver Lake Hunt Club and explaining how it worked to prospective members.

In return, I was invited to join the brothers and their dad for a weekend at the club’s lodge during hunting season. I had never been on a hunt before and just about everything that happened there seemed novel, starting with the fact that I visited during bow-hunting season. Rifle-hunting season comes several months later, with many of the same types of game being hunted with firearms instead.

There is a cultural distinction between the two types of hunters. Bow hunters tended to look down on rifle hunters as being part of “The Fast Buck Club.” And I imagine that rifle hunters tended to look down at their bow-hunting counterparts as primitives. I did my best to rise above those parochial distinctions.

Advertise with us

good aim

Before visiting the club, my education about hunting had been largely acquired through Bugs Bunny cartoons in which hunter Elmer Fudd would tromp through the woods in search of “wabbit.” What I discovered is that Elmer’s hunting technique was seriously deficient, particularly for deer hunters.

Instead of making a racket by trampling through the forest and alerting every animal of their presence, an experienced hunter would erect a tree stand from which to observe wildlife in silence from an elevation of 10 or 15 feet. The wildlife would then find the hunter, not the other way around. Deer, it turns out, have a keen sense of hearing, although their traffic judgment is terrible — as witnessed by the many deer carcasses along state highways.

I had initially assumed that the population density of deer would increase the deeper you penetrated into the woods. But what I discovered is that, contrary to my earlier expectations, deer seem to prefer open areas, such as those cleared for the natural gas wells which were scattered throughout the club’s 3,0000-acre site.

If deer had opposable thumbs, I imagined, they might even have built suburban-type settings for themselves. In effect, I came to understand that the deeper you go into the woods, the fewer deer you’ll find.

Advertise with us

There is, I soon discovered, a certain etiquette involved in deer hunting. For example, you need to respect the territory associated with another hunter’s tree stand and keep those zones a respectable distance from one another.

You also need to make sure that the animal you target is the type permitted for that season – doe, bucks, bear, coyote, turkey and so forth.

Baiting deer by leaving corn or other foods to make them easier targets is considered poor sportsmanship. It’s also unlawful in Pennsylvania.

Hunting without a state license or the permission of the property owner is not only bad manners, it’s illegal just about everywhere. And making constructive use of the dead animals as much as possible, rather than indiscriminately killing them for fun, is part of the hunting culture as well.

I also learned that unlike a rifle shot, which can bring a deer down immediately, a deer hit by a lethal arrow shot typically leaves the wounded animal with enough mobility to run away before collapsing from its injury. As a result, in bow hunting season, a deer has to be stalked twice: once to find and shoot the deer, and once again to track the wounded animal as it flees. Droplets of blood on the snow can make it easier to track in the winter. But it’s harder in the fall.

Advertise with us

At least in retrospect, I’m glad to have had those field lessons. It was good to know that what I had concluded from cartoons about hunting was wrong as well as unsportsmanlike.

It was interesting to learn that managing a deer herd through hunting can have important environmental benefits. It was comforting to learn that a sense of proportionality applies to hunting etiquette. And I was pleased to find that while the hunt itself is solitary, the camaraderie among hunters, back at the lodge at the end of the day, is a rewarding and high-value experience.

But it still fell short of making me a hunter, or even an admirer of Elmer Fudd.