I was born during THE WAR in Erie. My mother and father, high school sweethearts, married in their early 20s just after dad was drafted in 1943. I arrived a scant nine months later in 1944..

By then, my father was with his Army unit at Fort Dix in New Jersey.

Dad must have been on leave at some point because my brother was born 16 months after me in 1945.

Then the war ended, my father came home, and we were among the families contributing to the post-war “baby boom.” In May 1949, I remember peeking out a window at our home to see my parents leaving to go to the hospital where my little sister was born.

Advertise with us

We were now a family of five. The early 1950s were a peaceful time for our family as we enjoyed growing prosperity in Erie.

good eatin'

My father worked long hours in a family grocery business. My mother’s full-time job was keeping house and caring for the three of us.

We were a typical 1950s family. Businesses closed on Sunday and families spent time together..

Always alert to adult conversation, my ears always took notice when I heard my parents say to each other, “Let’s go for a ride.”

Advertise with us

I looked forward to scrambling into the back seat on the right side of our two-door Dodge, where I had the best view. My younger brother was on the left, and Dad drove. Mom was a passenger on the bench seat, her left arm ready to fling across the seat to protect my baby sister perched there.

My favorite ride was driving around the peninsula, or Presque Isle, as it is called today. Of course, I wanted another look at the beach, the lake, the lighthouse and animals, especially keeping a lookout for deer.

But all those sights could wait until I saw (for me) the main attraction: THE BIG FISH.

As we slowly made our way to Peninsula Drive, I would press my nose to the window, not wanting to miss a second of that fascinating sight.

There it was, a restaurant shaped and painted like a giant fish. “There’s The Big Fish!” I would exclaim.

Advertise with us

Each time we drove by, it was as if I saw it for the first time  — the single eye looking straight at me. It seemed that there was a real fish trapped inside that building.

Sometimes we were stopped in traffic on the busy two-lane road, and I got a longer look, trying to make out what was inside The Big Fish.

Other times, we drove past quickly. I craned my neck to keep it in sight as long as possible.

Once, I asked if we could go there. The answer from the front seat was a quick and firm “No.”

Undeterred, I asked, “Why not?”

Advertise with us

“It's too expensive and their food isn’t good,” came the answer. That was that.

The Big Fish, with its eye staring at me, stayed with me, tucked in my memory bank. It reappeared occasionally to make me laugh.

By the time I could go to The Big Fish alone, it was gone. I was shocked that anyone would destroy that precious landmark. It was sad to think I would never see The Big Fish again.

Many years later, scrolling through the internet for Erie history, I discovered that I wasn’t the only one who thought The Big Fish was a big deal.

Someone had preserved the memory of The Big Fish in a photo. When I saw it, I was transported back to those peaceful years when The Big Fish was an important part of my early life.

Advertise with us

I realized I wouldn’t have to keep fortifying the memory; I had a picture to remember and to tell others about it.

It was so comforting to know that The Big Fish was a part of the history of Erie, not just a cherished memory for me.

We went for car rides to other places in the 1950s. We went “down to the dock” at the foot of State Street to watch the boats and fishermen. We rode into the country, where we would look for farms and farm animals.

But none of those rides were seared into my memory, like the ride to the peninsula and seeing The Big Fish.

Kathy Cook Mastantuono, a resident of Ross, is a member of La Roche University's Lifelong Learning Memoir Writing Program.