As a young home economics teacher in the mid 1960s, one of my goals was to teach girls (there were no boys in home economics back then) the value of good nutrition.
I was teaching at Latimer Junior High School on Pittsburgh’s North Side.
I had a feeling most of the 13-year-old girls there – like most 13-year-old girls everywhere — would find the subject of good nutrition, well, rather boring. However, there were teaching aids available to make the subject more interesting.
Many of the teaching aids back then were supplied by the National Dairy Council, a great supporter of nutrition education. And one of their classroom experiments caught my eye. It was an experiment using two live rats, feeding one a “well-chosen diet” and the other a “poorly chosen diet.”
The way the experiment was supposed to work was that the rat being fed the poor diet would become somewhat lethargic, while the rat eating the healthy diet would be much more energetic.
At some point, the rat with the unhealthy diet would be switched to a good diet and, he too, would begin to thrive. If all worked out, the experiment’s message to the children would be: It is never too late to improve your diet.
It seemed like a great way to engage these middle school children in a “hands-on” activity and teach the value of good nutrition. The project was called, “The Value of a Well-Chosen Diet.”
I committed to this project with great enthusiasm. The National Dairy Council explained in detail just how to prepare for this experiment.
First: Build two cages for the rats using an 8-inch round cake pan for the top and bottom and a cylinder of wire mesh for the sides.
Second: Prepare the food. Full menus were provided. The well-chosen diet included protein, fruits, vegetables and dairy. The poorly chosen diet contained excessive carbs, sweets and no dairy. Both diets contained the same number of calories. We used the actual foods, ground them together, formed them into individual patties and froze them.
Third: Procure the rats. I learned that lab rats were being raised in a private home on Center Avenue in West View. I bought a cute white rat and a cute gray rat, naming them Bobby and Tommy after two boyfriends I was seeing at the time. One I later married!
The experiment proceeded as planned, with the children feeding the rats each day and cleaning their cages. Periodically, I would have the classes sit at a large table, putting their arms on the table to make a human wall. I would have the rats run freely on the table top so that we could observe them.
It wasn’t long before the rat being fed the poor diet began to show signs of distress such as weight loss, thinning fur and listlessness.
The children became very, very concerned. I repeatedly assured them that soon we would switch the malnourished rat to the good diet, and that he would thrive. That was the plan.
But then, one morning, I entered my classroom, uncovered the two rat cages, and was shocked to see that the rat being fed the poor diet was really struggling, close to death. The rat being fed the good diet was fine.
I was horrified! Quickly, I hid the rat cages from the children until I could decide what to do next. A science teacher at our school told me to feed burnt toast to the sick rat. I did what he said, but it didn’t help at all.
This little animal that the children had become so concerned about was now dying.
However, just like the television legal drama “Perry Mason” — very popular in the mid-1960s – there was mystery surrounding the dying rat. Was the sole reason for his demise the poor diet he was eating?
Well, perhaps not entirely. As it turned out, my classroom at Latimer Junior High, along with many others, had been sprayed for “bugs” the night before.
This procedure was apparently routine at Pittsburgh Public Schools at the time, although I did not know this. My lab in this very old school building was on the ground floor and probably had many bug issues, although I never saw any.
My conclusion was that the poorly nourished rat died because his defenses were down due to his poor diet and the bug spraying did him in.
I tried to explain this to the children, that good nutrition triumphs and keeps us healthy and helps us battle unhealthy situations.
I don’t think many, if any, were receptive to this explanation. They were too young and emotionally involved to process this information in a scientific way. I didn’t push it.
I never showed the children the rats again after the fatal bug spraying incident. It seemed best to just let the incident fade away. I buried the dead rat and found another home for the healthy rat.
If this experiment had worked, and had not been sabotaged, it would have been a terrific affirmation of good nutrition.
Instead, the story had a not so great ending. Unless you happened to read the February 1965 Pittsburgh Public Schools monthly news publication. The article was titled: “Teacher’s ingenuity aids nutrition study.” There’s a picture of me with the two rats.
The author of the article (it wasn’t me) took great liberty with the end of the story. It reads:
“With loving daily care, the experiment advanced to its fifth week. Bobby was strong and healthy, with a thick lustrous coat. Tommy, however, showed increasing signs of ill health. His fur was thin and shaggy, his nails were soft, he was listless and his growth was retarded.
“At the end of the fifth week, Tommy was placed on the well-chosen diet also, much to the children’s delight. This gave further dramatic proof of the role diet plays in physical and emotional well-being.”
Marilyn Moran Lanz, a resident of Hampton, is a member of the Lifelong Learning Memoir Writing Program at La Roche University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.