Fox Chapel-area District Magisterial Judge Matt Rudzki knows those appearing in his, or any, court feel a sense of “helplessness.”
Whether they’re there to fight a speeding ticket, solve a landlord-tenant dispute, or, for juveniles, to defend themselves against accusations of vaping in school or truancy, those individuals — and those who support them — are stressed.
And for many, there’s another layer of anxiety.
good justice
Research shows that 70 to 90% of youth offenders have experienced one or more types of trauma, and there’s mounting evidence that childhood trauma exposure is likely a key risk factor for run-ins with the law.
That trauma can be triggered by knowing they are not in control, being confined to a small space (that some district magisterial courtrooms and waiting rooms are), having to face accusers or abusers, or even the colors on the wall.
“Most of the people coming into court are there on, what is likely, the worst day of their lives,” he said. “We need to meet people where they are.”
For Rudzki, who took the bench in January after one term as the mayor of Sharpsburg, that’s achieved by acknowledging all the facets of trauma-informed justice.
He’s one of only two Allegheny County district magisterial judges to offer night court -— held on the last Thursday of every month — to allow citizens to avoid the stress of missing work or school. He covers his waiting room walls with locally created art stamped with positive affirmations. And he’s the only magisterial judge in the county to invite therapy dogs and trained handlers.

“I think you get better responses from people when they’re comfortable, and they know they’re in a setting where they’re being heard,” he said. “It’s intimidating to be in front of a judge in robes. I want to try to break own those barriers.”
Man’s best friend
Animal Friends Therapets liaison Marcy Fenell didn’t know what to expect when she brought a dog to Rudzki’s courtroom for a experimental visit in April.
The organization’s therapy dogs have experience inside Beaver County family courtrooms, but in Rudzki’s case, they’re asked to visit in the waiting room, once per month on days when juvenile cases are heard.
“It helps the kid in question, but also those around he or she,” Fenell said. “It makes people a little bit nicer, chills them out a little bit, because you aren’t focused on being the next one in the court.”
Volunteer handlers of Therapets dogs are trained to only engage with individuals who seem willing, and to do so while essentially ignoring their environment — ask no identifying information and nothing about the reason for their presence.
Instead, they introduce their dogs, talking about funny things they do or what they like. Often, those visiting the courtroom will offer stories about their own pets.
But the dogs offer more than distraction: They’re scientifically proven to lower stress hormones.

“The last few years have been tough for everybody,” Fenell said. “When someone is going in to meet with the judge, I think if you’re in a happier, better frame of mind, there’s probably a better outcome for everybody.”
Art with authority
Whether it’s a juvenile day or not, those visiting Rudzki’s courtroom need only look at the waiting room walls for a reminder that their current situation is impermanent and a shared experience.
Six pieces of abstract art emblazoned with messages such as “You matter,” “It’s OK to not be OK” and “You are not alone,” decorate the waiting room walls.
While the messages are meaningful, their backstory lends authority.
Katie Whysong was a Fox Chapel School District middle school student when she was diagnosed with depression. After hearing about a program where students and teachers decorated school restrooms with positive messages, she approached her art teacher, Nanci Goldberg, with a similar idea, thinking it was a way to reach kids battling mental illness, just like her.
Goldberg championed the idea, but then the COVID-19 pandemic hit.
Although Katie received unwavering support from her parents, Alisa and Todd Whysong, friends, doctors, medication and therapies, she took her own life 10 days after her 15th birthday in March 2021.
Soon after she died, her parents picked up a piece of mail meant for their daughter. It was a welcome packet from the Human Rights Campaign to which she’d donated her allowance money.
“She was really into advocacy for mental health, just any kind of marginalized community,” Ms. Whysong said. “She was really a little activist.”
To honor Katie’s legacy, they started the nonprofit Positive Painting Project. At events, which are held at community gatherings and in schools, individuals paint whatever strikes them onto canvases. After they dry, one of six “messages of hope” are screen printed on top of their art, and they’re hung in public spaces such as schools, businesses and, now, Rudzki’s courtroom.
“I think the extension of her interest in human rights to what Matt’s doing would please her, that she would feel that’s exactly who she wanted to reach,” Mr. Whysong said. “We know that mental health is a huge part of what comes across Matt’s desk. So, being able to provide that support, that’s what the whole goal is.”
Compassion rules
Before Rudzki invited therapy dogs into his courtroom, he sought the approval of 5th Judicial District President Judge Kimberly Berkeley Clark, who was “very glad” to approve his request. Not only does it align with her own beliefs about trauma-informed court, but also she knows such initiatives are supported by the Pennsylvania Judicial Roundtable, on which she serves.
“Many people who have issues that lead them to court, they also have histories of poverty and trauma and a lot of other things,” she said. “What we want to do is at least do no additional harm, and really understand how trauma impacts everything.”
While night court, art and therapy dogs are all appreciated, those are just part of how sensitivities are displayed.

“The physical space is part of being trauma-informed, but I’m not sure it’s the first part of it,” Clark said. “A lot of it is the atmosphere the judge creates, being respectful of people, being understanding and patient.”
Issues such as space in magisterial district courtrooms and waiting rooms, lease agreements in those buildings, budgets, and concerns about allergies or phobias of dogs all factor into why some jurists choose not to partner with therapy animal programs or other more demonstrative gestures of trauma-informed justice, she said.
And there are those with even more robust programs. In the 5th Judicial District’s Family Division, led by Administrative Judge Kim D. Eaton, trauma-informed measures are unmistakable, with a playground, wellness center, sensory room, wiring to dock kids’ electronic devices and decor in therapeutic colors.
Other measures include Clark’s years-old initiative to adopt time-specific hearings rather than forcing defendants and families to wait for unknown amounts of time — a policy that continues to spread to other jurists. In the future, she’d like to adopt hospital-like progress screens for juvenile cases, where defendants are assigned numbers instead of having cases paged on a loudspeaker.
But no matter how implicit or overt the efforts, they express compassion that can permanently alter how citizens interact with the legal system.
“I can make all the right decisions, but if I deliver the message in a way that’s disrespectful or not trauma-informed, litigants may perceive that the system is not fair,” she said.
Although trauma-informed court may not require the existence of hope-inspiring art or therapy animals, there are benefits to such obvious displays, as Rudzki sees it: “I think people want change, and people can see I’m implementing that change on the bench.”
Abby Mackey: amackey@post-gazette.com, Twitter @AnthroAbbyRN and IG @abbymackeywrites.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.