Early memories of the pandemic almost certainly include grocery stores. Capacity limits created lines out the door. The somewhat illogical urge to stock up on toilet paper left almost every paper products aisle empty. Stickers on the floors directed new one-way traffic patterns down aisles.

Navigating the new rules of the new normal made shopping experiences almost overwhelming, which is why Beth Kukucka remembers so well a moment that quieted all of that mental noise.

While shopping for groceries, she saw a family of six, standing together and all wearing masks, even the toddler. Something about that image allowed her to process another new facet of life at the time: Would we forget about each other and who we all are behind our masks?

Ms. Kukucka, 62, of Braddock, has more than 30 years of professional photography experience (including credits in Rolling Stone and Time magazines) and wanted to ensure the answer would be no.

Advertise with us

She started taking two pictures of consenting individuals of all backgrounds, races, identities and ages, one with the mask they wore to protect themselves from COVID-19 and one without it. In some cases, their clothing or something they held would change to further reveal details of their lives.

Then, she asked, “What would you like us to know about you? Who are you behind your mask?”

When presented as an exhibit — as it was at Braddock’s affordable housing community, The Ohringer — the subjects’ answers sit below their masked and unmasked photos.

The project, called Behind the Mask, could have just functioned as a time capsule of the pandemic era, although it’s that, too. But whether it was stress, isolation or some sort of emotional safety provided by Ms. Kukucka’s genuine interest, none of the subjects answered with the facts and figures of their lives, surface details a Google search might produce.

Instead, they bared their souls.

Advertise with us

Chris

Ms. Kukucka started the project in spring 2020. As it progressed, she called upon a few friends, like Chris Fry, whose husband, Mike, died of inoperable brain cancer about six weeks before the shoot.

His feelings about participating were mixed at first, but then he saw it as a way to honor his husband. To make that purpose clear to viewers, Ms. Kukucka created a photo of Mike with angel wings in the maskless photo, which Mr. Fry holds, and his words read, “I am grieving the loss of my husband. I can hardly imagine my life without him.”

“I had been pretty numb about losing  Mike, and that was the first thing that helped me face it, and it was a positive thing,” he said of his participation in the project. “It was hard — really, really hard — but it helped me start feeling again.”

Chris Fry, 52, shares his grief and honors his late husband behind his mask. (Courtesy of Beth Kukucka)

Kenneth

Advertise with us

Ms. Kukucka appeared on KDKA’s Pittsburgh Today Live morning talk show in March 2021, and Liz Johnson, 42, of Center, was watching.

As soon as she saw the segment about Behind the Mask, she hit the record button to show her then-17-year-old son, Kenneth Scanlon III. And she sent an email to Ms. Kukucka wondering if she would like to include her son.

He was diagnosed with autism shortly before age 3. Doctors told his family that he would never speak nor be a productive member of society and would need to be “in a home” after age 5.

Instead, he’s a student at Brashear High School, an employee at a local grocery store, is known for the sentimental cards he writes to family on holidays and is an outspoken advocate for those with disabilities, which is why his mom knew he would love to participate.

Ms. Kukucka welcomed the opportunity to photograph Kenneth. Below his photographs, his own words read, “I am autistic teenager who stutters. I am more than a mask or a label.”

Advertise with us

When he learned the Post-Gazette wished to include him in this story, he spoke the following, which his mother recorded: “It was a good way of telling people that just because I have a disability, I can make an impact on the world. And all of us that have disabilities will always be a part of the world. No matter how many people try to hide our voices, we will still be heard. I wanted to do this for everyone, be a voice for everyone.”

Kenneth Scanlon, 18, proudly shares that he lives with a disability behind his mask. (Courtesy of Beth Kukucka)

Hit the road

Ms. Kukucka took her act on the road in July 2021 thanks to a crowdfunding account that reached $3,100.

Over three weeks, she drove her Hyundai across the southern U.S., all the way to California and back, taking side streets and self-directed detours as her intuition prescribed.

She challenged her introverted nature by approaching strangers with the idea of these “two quick photos,” paused to see if they were still listening and then continued to explain her project. Among others, she met a can-can dancer who works by day as a cashier in Denver, a church-going grandma who works at a country music museum in Nashville and a Kansas man whose display contains only one picture because, as he said, “I’m not wearing a goddamn mask.”

Advertise with us

She soothed strong opinions by saying, “A lot of people feel the way you do,” and calmed her own shy nature by handwriting their answers, which gave her something else to focus on.

But she quickly learned approaching people is only difficult when you view them as strangers.

“I found myself feeling really comfortable because the more I photographed and the more stories I heard, the more I really got that no one is a stranger,” she said. “We have the same stories. We care about the same things, generally.”

Not just the surface

The pandemic arguably changed our identities, at least to certain audiences. To coworkers — and sometimes even friends and family — we were only the people displayed through a webcam. We wore dress shirts on top and sweatpants on the bottom. Our houses were perfectly manicured behind our heads with floors in other rooms covered in Mega Bloks and laundry.

Advertise with us

That choreographed view of “me” may have been why Ms. Kukucka’s subjects thirsted to reveal more and discuss truths that would have remained secrets even without a mask.

“I think the mask was symbolic of what was happening,” Mr. Fry, 52, said. “On Zoom, we had our work identity and that was the only way we were interacting. I think all of us defaulted back to, well, here’s the rest of my world that’s happening that no one is seeing right now because I’m at home.”

What the world couldn’t see about Mr. Fry was the year he took care of his dying husband, largely alone, because of pandemic restrictions. In their Churchill home, he helped his husband come to terms with his death while doing the same for himself.

A way to break those emotions out of isolation was to participate in Ms. Kukucka’s project.

“I would call it a major component of my grieving process,” he said. “It’s a public view of my grief, but his story is in there as well. I wanted Mike to be known because he died during the pandemic. I’m still here. I will be without a mask one day. He died behind a mask.”

Advertise with us

Transitions

Ms. Kukucka had a busy morning before being interviewed by the Post-Gazette. She first visited a church that used the video version of her project as a part of the sermon and then attended a drag queen show to photograph one of the performers, a juxtaposition she didn’t find ironic until it was pointed out.

“It’s all God. It’s all the divine. ’We’re all God in drag,’” she said, quoting spiritual teacher Ram Das without hesitation.

Her next day was busy, too: She was scheduled to be the speaker for a Communication Concepts course at Slippery Rock University.

“The reason I thought of her is we’re talking about non-verbal communication,” said the class’s instructor, Fadoua Loudiy, Ph.D. “This was perfect because the mask has hindered, to some extent, our non-verbal communication and made it more complicated.”

Advertise with us
Beth Kukucka’s photography project, Behind the Mask, is going through its own transition to a public speaking platform. (Courtesy of Beth Kukucka)

Ms. Kukucka uses the word “transition” to describe the difference between her subject’s first photo and the second, but, as it turns out, that word was more like foreshadowing.

“I figured out my 35-year photography career, and now I’m trying to figure out a new career,” she said.

As the U.S. strives to interact differently with COVID-19, dropping mask mandates and resuming pre-pandemic activities, she intends to wind down the picture-taking part of Behind the Mask and funnel her experiences into presentations with a visual component, like the one she gave at Slippery Rock. And separately, she’s creating two-minute videos aimed at encouragement, which are published on her YouTube channel.

She views Behind the Mask as “time sensitive but right on time” and, in her career, it’s the catalyst toward more universally impactful modes of artistic expression.

“It’s always been a natural part of my photography to try to find the heart of each moment, but it seems to be going into more of a universal feeling of, ‘We need each other, and you can play a part in that,’” she said. “It’s not just about booking an event or a portrait session now: It’s about contributing something.

Advertise with us

“I don’t know how it’ll play out, but I’m along for the ride.”

Learn more about Ms. Kukucka at www.bethkphoto.com, on IG @whoareyoubehindthemask and on YouTube by searching her name.

Abby Mackey: amackey@post-gazette.com, Twitter @AnthroAbbyRN and IG @abbymackeywrites.