it’s honestly wild that it took a year for someone in Pittsburgh to slap together a production of “The Last Five Years.”
Jason Robert Brown’s 2001 musical about the slow deterioration of a couple’s relationship told from dueling perspectives is the perfect pandemic show in many respects. The staging doesn’t have to be particularly elaborate, it’s relatively short and, most importantly, it requires only two actors to be on the stage at any given time.
No one was more surprised than Mitchell Dubin, 19, and Zoë Soteres, 18, that no one in the Steel City had taken the initiative at any point since last March to give “The Last Five Years” a shot. That’s why the two of them decided to acquire its licensing rights, rustle up a team of fellow young artists, craft a makeshift stage in Mr. Dubin’s Squirrel Hill backyard and put on one of the first live musicals in Pittsburgh since the COVID-19 pandemic began.
“We’re really thrilled to be able to give this to the Pittsburgh community and for this to be people’s opportunity to come back to the world of theater,” said Mr. Dubin, the show’s musical director and conductor.
Mr. Dubin and Ms. Soteres, who plays leading lady Cathy Hiatt, partnered with City Theatre Educational Programs on this project. There will be four performances in total, daily from May 13-16. You can pay $10 through City Theatre to either livestream them (except for the May 13 show) or to attend in person with a maximum audience of 50 other Pittsburgh theatergoers. Seventy-three tickets had already been sold within two days of being made available.
A backyard might not sound like a glamorous setting for a musical, but this one already came complete with a delineated patio that will be the stage and a grassy component that can easily fit 50 audience members. Everyone involved in the show besides the performers will be masked at all times. Seats will be spaced out to ensure social distancing, and audiences will be asked to stay masked during the show and not get too close to anyone they didn’t arrive with.
Read More

Ms. Soteres, a Winchester Thurston graduate and a freshman studying acting at DePaul University, will star alongside Jason Schmidt, a 20-year-old Chicago native and sophomore in Carnegie Mellon University’s musical theater program. Mr. Schmidt will be portraying male lead Jamie Wellerstein, whose story is told chronologically while Cathy’s is laid out in reverse.
The rest of the production, from the stage crew to the orchestra members, comprises student artists representing multiple corners of the Pittsburgh region.
“This group of people that we’ve assembled here are not just the best students, but I would put any of them up against professionals that do this,” said Mr. Dubin, a CAPA graduate and music teacher at Community Day School on a gap year before heading off to study music at Yale University in the fall. “We have such a talented group that you can’t just do at Pitt or CMU or Yale. We’ve amalgamated all these communities to come together, and this is the result.”
He and Ms. Soteres met a few years ago during a Jewish Community Center production and have been in an “artistic partnership” ever since, as she put it. Mr. Dubin wasn’t all that familiar with “The Last Five Years” other than how pandemic-friendly it could theoretically be, although he did once have the pleasure of meeting Mr. Brown while working at the French Woods Festival of the Performing Arts in Hancock, N.Y.
Ms. Soteres, on the other hand, was a big fan of the musical and its 2014 movie adaptation starring Anna Kendrick and Jeremy Jordan. So was Mr. Schmidt, who said Mr. Jordan’s turn as Jamie helped inspire him to pursue acting after high school.
“It’s generally a mid-20s, 30s kind of role,” Mr. Schmidt said. “I thought I’d have to wait a while to have an opportunity to play it. ... We’ve just tried to find as many creative ways to use the space as we can. It’s been a lot of fun and very creatively fulfilling.”
With the help of City Theatre Educational Programs, the group was able to secure the live-performance and streaming rights for “The Last Five Years” through Music Theatre International. They settled on Mr. Dubin’s backyard as a venue after realizing city parks couldn’t quite accommodate their ambitions due to COVID-19 gathering protocols.
“If you look at it from the right angle, it looks like it’s always been a theater,” Mr. Dubin said. “We’ve adapted the best we can to it and are making do with what we have.”

Those logistics were all cleared by January. In early February, Mr. Dubin and Ms. Soteres put a casting call out to find their Jamie and connected with Mr. Schmidt through Ms. Soteres’ vocal coach, who happens to teach at CMU. Rehearsals began in mid-February, allowing Mr. Schmidt and Ms. Soteres time to learn the show’s quite difficult collection of songs and get in the mindsets of two characters navigating a relationship that just isn’t working.
At a rehearsal in early May less than two weeks before opening night, Mr. Schmidt and Ms. Soteres were still workshopping the specifics of certain songs right down to at which moment in “A Part of That” Ms. Soteres would sit down and if they could pull off Mr. Schmidt decorating a Christmas tree as he pranced around the stage during “The Schmuel Song.” These kids mean business.
If all goes well, this shoestring version of “The Last Five Years” will serve as a balm for local musical fans, a re-introduction to live theater in Pittsburgh and a celebration of what artists of all ages can accomplish with a little vision and elbow grease.
“It’s one of the things I’m most proud of, that we found young artists that are motivated enough to do this essentially by themselves,” Ms. Soteres said. “I just think that it’s so important to encourage young people to get into the arts to get more innovation in the arts, and it’s our job to do that.
“And it’s also a great show! With all the talent that we’ve seen, it’s going to be an amazing production that’s going to make people laugh and cry and really think.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.