Whether you have admired a grove of American beeches (Fagus grandiflora) in our hardwood forests, or planted the showy ‘Tricolor’ European beech (F. sylvatica) in your yard, be on the lookout for beech leaf disease.

The disease, which also affects Asian beech species, was discovered in Ohio’s Lake County in 2012. It is caused by a species of foliar nematodes (Litylenchus crenatae subsp. mccannii) that attacks leaves, then decimates emerging buds.

The destruction of buds arrests the tree’s growth for the next growing season and is especially hard on saplings. Once the buds are destroyed, branches die, and eventually so does the tree.

To determine the current state of beech leaf disease in our region, I spoke with Eric Countryman, district manager, East Pittsburgh, for the Davey Tree Expert Company, and Sandy Feather, a green industry team educator for Penn State Extension of Allegheny County.

Advertise with us

Nematodes, which live in the soil, get in between the veins in the leaves and cause them to look shrunken and shriveled, with striping, Countryman said. The damage is “easy to spot when you look at the tree.... The life gets sucked out of it.”

He has seen the disease in Pittsburgh’s northern suburbs and less frequently in the city.  The Davey Institute is working with Cleveland Metroparks to find treatments to stop or slow the disease. They have found that PolyPhosphate 30 will improve the health of the tree, providing “a boost to keep the tree as healthy as possible.” If you have beeches on your property, Countryman recommends prophylactic treatment done by a certified arborist.

Feather said treatment of landscape trees is possible if it’s caught in the early stages, but “if treated trees are surrounded by untreated trees, treatments are unlikely to help much.

“Treatments suppress the nematodes, but do not cure the tree. The woods are another story. There are no treatments that are practical on such a large scale,” she said.

Once beech leaf disease moves into the wild, “understory trees die within a few years. More mature trees die as well, but it takes them longer,” Feather said.

Advertise with us

“Beech is a foundational ecological species. A lot of wildlife depends on beech nuts, called mast. They are eaten by bears, turkey, ruffed grouse and deer.”

Feather has seen the disease locally at Toms Run Nature Reserve in Kilbuck. Beech leaf disease is found in all 67 Pennsylvania counties and is prevalent in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic regions.

In addition to the PolyPhosphate treatments, arborists are using injectable fungicides and foliar applications to maintain tree health. Multiple fungicide applications begin in July, when new buds are formed, in an effort to hit nematodes before they can get into the buds.

Researchers are looking at the genetics of nematodes as well as identifying trees that are surviving the impact of the disease. As with ash trees that survived emerald ash borer, scientists are looking for individual resistant beech trees.

With full knowledge of the disease’s impact in this region, the two local experts held different opinions on whether to plant a beech tree in the home garden.

Advertise with us

If you want to add a beech to your landscape, you should do so, but with eyes wide open, Countryman said. “A single beech — I would still plant them.”

‘Tricolor’ and other cultivars of European beech do not appear to be as susceptible to the disease, he said. If you are adding trees to the landscape, it is always a good idea to avoid a monoculture and select a variety of species.

Feather did not recommend planting a beech tree at this time. “I love them — they’re one of my favorite trees — and it pains me to say it.”

She also pointed out that in planting one, you are taking on the expense of ongoing treatment in an effort to stave off beech leaf disease.

If you already have a beech tree in your yard, you will need to take on the care to optimize its chances for survival. Look for a certified arborist to treat your trees. You can find one on the website of the International Society of Arboriculture, treesaregood.org.

Advertise with us

Beech leaf disease is a relatively new problem, and a lot of research remains to be done. Holden Forests and Gardens, Ohio State, Penn State, Cleveland Metroparks, Davey and Bartlett Labs are among the organizations researching the disease. For more on beech leaf disease, visit Holden Forest and Gardens website, holdenfg.org.

“It is an all-hands-on-deck issue,” Feather said. “It’s a big deal because beech trees are important, especially for their ecological value.”

Carol Papas is a Penn State Master Gardener. This volunteer program supports the outreach mission of Penn State Extension and provides research-based information on best practices in sustainable horticulture and environmental stewardship. For more information, contact the Penn State Extension of Allegheny County at alleghenymg@psu.edu or 412-482-3476.