“Gardening is muck and mysticism,” according to legendary garden writer Pamela J. Harper.

If you set out in search of gardening advice, you will find conflicting claims about techniques, cultural recommendations and even plant descriptions. Part of our mission as Penn State Master Gardeners is to arm the public with accurate information to use when working in their gardens.

After hardscape, trees are the major investment in most gardens. One of the first steps in making trees fulfill their promise is to reject long-held beliefs and embrace research-based techniques to ensure your investment thrives. So let’s explore the three most common myths in tree planting and maintenance:

Myth No. 1: Dig a deep planting hole and generously amend the soil to give the tree a good start.

Advertise with us

While this advice seems intuitive, the opposite is true. Dig a hole only to the depth of the root ball. First check that the root flare is properly exposed within the burlap wrapping or container. Then measure the distance from the root ball’s top to its bottom. Dig to that depth.

Do not amend the soil; don’t even bother to break it up. If it’s heavy clay, you should dig slightly more shallow than the root ball, by 2-4 inches, so that the top of the root ball is above the surrounding soil level. The width of the hole can be twice as wide as the root ball, but the bottom should be solid to help steady the tree.

Research has shown that trees make their own way in native soil, establishing themselves better than in highly amended conditions. In clay soil, allowing the top of the root ball to be slightly higher than the surrounding grade will keep water from filling the hole, ensuring aeration. After backfilling with existing soil, mulch the top of the root ball. Make sure the root flare remains visible.

Myth No. 2: Newly planted young trees must be staked

It has been found that staking has an adverse effect on how trees become established. A tree that has a sturdy root ball and is stable in the planting hole does not need to be staked. Its natural movement in the wind helps the tree to develop a sturdier trunk and root system.

Advertise with us

Staking may be needed, albeit briefly, if you are planting a bare-root tree that can’t stand on its own or planting in a location where wind or a severe slope will not allow the tree to stand upright. Seek guidance on recommended staking techniques to ensure that the tree grows properly and that none of the components injure the bark.

Myth No. 3: Covering a tree’s pruning cut with pruning paint helps to protect the wound.

If part of your garden maintenance this spring includes pruning, don’t paint the exposed cuts. Such products can do more harm than good, creating an environment prone to rot. Trees have their own built-in repair system that allows the wound to seal on its own over time.

Always use sharp, clean cutting tools. Penn State Extension provides accurate, up-to-date information on pruning trees and shrubs in the following online publications:

http://extension.psu.edu/publications/agrs-095

Advertise with us

http://extension.psu.edu/natural-resources/forests/urban-community/publications/pruning-landscape-trees

Steve Piskor is a Penn State Master Gardener and a state-certified horticulturalist.This volunteer program supports the outreach mission of Penn State Extension and provides research-based information on best practices in sustainable horticulture and environmental stewardship. For more information, email alleghenymg@psu.edu or call 412-482-3476.