Are aphids garden menaces or victims of oppression?

Sure, they're cute with their small legs, slow movements and how they seem to graze without a care in the world. They're like little cows. A garden society would be hard-pressed to find members who empathize with aphids. But maybe these pests just get a bad rep.

Aphids come in a variety of colors, but the body plan is more or less uniform from species to species. That body plan consists of six legs, straw-like mouthparts, cornicles -- a pair of little spines projecting from the abdomen -- relatively long antennae and limited physical capabilities.

Like cows, aphids don't have much use for dazzling feats of athleticism. Their food -- plants -- can't run away. And as plants are constantly pushing sap through their stems to new growth, the aphids literally have their dinners pumped into them. Aphids have it pretty easy on the food end, which leaves them plenty of time to do what they do best.

Advertise with us

Making babies is the aphids' stock in trade. I've broken the process down into five easy steps:

Step 1: Do away with males entirely so as to skip that tedious "mating" business.

Step 2: Give birth to clones.

Step 3: Actually, give birth to pregnant clones.

Step 4: When populations become too dense, give birth to pregnant, flying clones to colonize new plants.

Advertise with us

Step 5: Repeat steps 1-4.

Nothing succeeds like excess, but nothing feeds like excess either. Aphids are bug candy. Seriously, anything will eat an aphid. Ladybugs, fly larvae, lacewings -- you name it. Even worse, death hovers above as well. Certain wasps lay their eggs inside aphids. As the baby wasps develop, they devour their aphid host, leaving nothing but a "mummy." What's an aphid to do?

Start a neighborhood watch program. Suppose one aphid gets munched. That aphid releases a pheromone that all her sisters smell almost immediately. In response, they make like lemmings and jump off their plant into the great beyond. Out of the frying pan and into the fire.

Life in the undergrowth isn't nearly as cushy as it was on their host plant. Rarely having much use for physical prowess, the aphids run a clumsy gantlet back to the relative safety of the canopy. And sadly, aphids are just as delicious on terra firma.

Earwigs, countless beetles and centipedes make quick work of aphids on their crawl back to the top. Death from above and death down below. Can't an aphid get a break?

Advertise with us

Well, the ant mafia is always happy to help out a bug in need, if slavery seems preferable to getting eaten. Aphids, taking in more sap than they can use, excrete the excess as a sticky, sugary substance called honeydew. Ants love honeydew like the French love cheese.

Ants are said to "farm" aphids, moving them from plant to plant and warding off would-be trouble makers. And from the aphid's perspective, all seems great until they can't supply their ant benefactors with the goods. Should the honeydew dwindle due to drought or plant stress, the ant mafia withdraws their protection and eat any aphids that fall to the ground.

Sounds a lot like extortion to me.

Such is an aphid's life. Sell yourself into slavery or live a life fraught with danger and death. Yeah, they eat your roses and caused some distorted buds. Look a little closer. You'll likely find ants. Or you'll find some of the many, many aphid-eaters out there. Nothing yet? Give it a week.

Without the "protection" of the ant mafia, the aphid herd quickly dissipates under the onslaught of all their natural enemies. From a gardener's interest, if you remove the ants from the equation, nature will take its course soon enough. Gruesome, merciless nature.

Advertise with us

Or maybe by taking the ants out, you are setting the aphids free to live their own lives.

It's a judgment call, really. No one can answer those existential questions but the aphids. When you get down to it though, if aphids could talk, they'd probably only say "Moo."